- Banned
- #301
Ottens (Had enough time waiting) to either McIntosh or Sandilands?
I can't decide, any help.
I can't decide, any help.
2009 Trade Discussion- Part 7
- Thread starter swans4eva
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Did you seriously wait until now? Who was your backup?
If you have waited until now he will be back in 2 weeks anyway...might be worth holding on.
Can't decide whether to hold onto Chad and cover with Broughton and then trade out Ziebell to Gia, or keep Ziebell and trade out Chad to another gun back such as Enright or Lockyer.
Maybe I should hold Chad for a week and see how Hodge goes.
Maybe I should hold Chad for a week and see how Hodge goes.
- Oct 9, 2003
- 47,027
- 46,325
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Eagles (NFL), Suns (NBA)
I'm not expecting Corey to play this week and with my bench in Robinson and Beams not playing this week, I had to trade one of the kids to ensure coverage for Corey. Plus I wanted to get Muston as well. After much deliberation I traded Mitch for Muston against my desires as I still think Mitch can rise further. However the extra 33K cash from trading Mitch instead of Beams will allow me to upgrade Suban next week to anyone under 335K and I've got my eye on either Mundy/Hodge/Ryder.
The other trade this week was Chad to Enright. Had to be done to plug holes in my backline, plus I don't think we'll see Chad back to his best if/when he does return later this year (they may decide to mothball him if their finals chances are shot by then).
11 trades left now and still top of my league with a tough game this week, so reasonable happy with where I'm at.
The other trade this week was Chad to Enright. Had to be done to plug holes in my backline, plus I don't think we'll see Chad back to his best if/when he does return later this year (they may decide to mothball him if their finals chances are shot by then).
11 trades left now and still top of my league with a tough game this week, so reasonable happy with where I'm at.
I'm wondering who teh best upgrade is out of swan and tuck
Tuck has big finishes to the season so I believe there scores could be close? I Have enough money for either so thats not too much of a worry!
Tuck has big finishes to the season so I believe there scores could be close? I Have enough money for either so thats not too much of a worry!
if money isn't a worry then you would be silly imo not to go swan... he is an absolute jet and has had a stella past few weeks....
Myself i have tuck and am a huge fan of his scoring potential... but if its out of those two and money isnt a problem then swan all the way for me.
BB with broughton as cover (he will def get solid game time over the next few weeks with the injuries Freo have suffered in their backline) i recon your best bet is to wait.....
It will give you enough time to see how hodge has pulled up from his break.... it will also allow you to get more information on how chad's surgery went and an update on how long he will be out for.
Yeah thanks mate i would like teh extra dough obviously but if you believe swan is going to outscore tuck by a fair margin, which i also thought may as well go for him!
looks like ill be putting balla on the field with warren as emergency now. glad i am trading ziebell as well now. and hopefully big mac plays and has a shocker
.
rodneygrinters
Draftee
thanks for your help. much appreciated
Juddy88
Brownlow Medallist
This Chadwick trade is doing my head in, still can't decide.
I did:
Robinson>Muston
TTuck>NDS
Running low on trades is my big problem. May have to trade Chad some time but have held onto him because Hodge is back in. Still starting three rookies atm, with one player that I still really want to upgrade.
I'm probably going to have to settle with Grimes/Broughton as a 7th back and Muston/Hartlett as a 6th mid, which is by no means ideal.
Robinson>Muston
TTuck>NDS
Running low on trades is my big problem. May have to trade Chad some time but have held onto him because Hodge is back in. Still starting three rookies atm, with one player that I still really want to upgrade.
I'm probably going to have to settle with Grimes/Broughton as a 7th back and Muston/Hartlett as a 6th mid, which is by no means ideal.
foley4brownlow
Team Captain
who you looking at mate? im getting enright for chad. enright is a great backline option who will average 90 for the year. he is super consistent gets 75+ every week and hardly ever misses a game. also plays for geelong so is always gana be a loose man and not get tagged.
Juddy88
Brownlow Medallist
Yeah Enright may be a good option. Just concerned by the fact Harley and Taylor are both out. Same with Mackie.
There's plenty of solid options, just unsure whether I should trade him as I have decent cover.
- Thread starter
- #316
this may be a massive shock to everyone... but i only have 5 trades left!
I hav completely upgraded my team though to what my finishing team was planned to be at the start of the year. I may trade chornes in the next few weeks though if need be but all other trades are for injuries...
My team (I really like the look of it now)
Defence- Hodge Goddard Chornes Adcock Drummond Mackie Grimes
Petrenko Broughton
Midfield-Ablett Gibbs Pendles Swan Cross Salopek
Cockie Muston
Rucks- Jolly Kreuzer
Jacobs Browne
Forwards- Deledio Johnson Franklin Gia Pavlich Higgins Ross
Ballantyne Wright
Last two trades for year will probably Muston to Rookie and Jolly/Kreuzer to Cox
But that wont be for around a month so unless i need to get rid of a player for injury i can sit back and watch the big scores roll in
Predicted score- 2174
I hav completely upgraded my team though to what my finishing team was planned to be at the start of the year. I may trade chornes in the next few weeks though if need be but all other trades are for injuries...
My team
(I really like the look of it now)Defence- Hodge Goddard Chornes Adcock Drummond Mackie Grimes
Petrenko Broughton
Midfield-Ablett Gibbs Pendles Swan Cross Salopek
Cockie Muston
Rucks- Jolly Kreuzer
Jacobs Browne
Forwards- Deledio Johnson Franklin Gia Pavlich Higgins Ross
Ballantyne Wright
Last two trades for year will probably Muston to Rookie and Jolly/Kreuzer to Cox
But that wont be for around a month so unless i need to get rid of a player for injury i can sit back and watch the big scores roll in
Predicted score- 2174
Pumbi
Club Legend
Mitch Brown -> Ballantyne
Zaharakis -> Swan
Was around $10 000 off changing the former to:
Beams -> Muston
Out of the midfielders available and in contention (Swan, Sewell, Murphy, Stanton, Tuck, Thompson, Salopek, Hayes, Montagna) I just couldn't go past the Collingwood messiah.
Chose to pass on Muston because there was no one really suitable to downgrade to in the present circumstances. I already have Hartlett and Sidebottom in my midfield so there was no need for a 3rd rookie midfielder.
Leaves my team with 8 trades with only Hill and Hartlett/Sidebottom to upgrade.
Zaharakis -> Swan
Was around $10 000 off changing the former to:
Beams -> Muston
Out of the midfielders available and in contention (Swan, Sewell, Murphy, Stanton, Tuck, Thompson, Salopek, Hayes, Montagna) I just couldn't go past the Collingwood messiah.
Chose to pass on Muston because there was no one really suitable to downgrade to in the present circumstances. I already have Hartlett and Sidebottom in my midfield so there was no need for a 3rd rookie midfielder.
Leaves my team with 8 trades with only Hill and Hartlett/Sidebottom to upgrade.
this may be a massive shock to everyone... but i only have 5 trades left!
I hav completely upgraded my team though to what my finishing team was planned to be at the start of the year. I may trade chornes in the next few weeks though if need be but all other trades are for injuries...
My team
Defence- Hodge Goddard Chornes Adcock Drummond Mackie Grimes
Petrenko Broughton
Midfield-Ablett Gibbs Pendles Swan Cross Salopek
Cockie Muston
Rucks- Jolly Kreuzer
Jacobs Browne
Forwards- Deledio Johnson Franklin Gia Pavlich Higgins Ross
Ballantyne Wright
Last two trades for year will probably Muston to Rookie and Jolly/Kreuzer to Cox
But that wont be for around a month so unless i need to get rid of a player for injury i can sit back and watch the big scores roll in
Predicted score- 2174
You planned your finishing team at the start of the year with Ross, Grimes and Kreuzer. You didn't plan on getting Bartell, Kornes, Riewoldt, Cox or Thompson. Your right i am shocked
- Thread starter
- #319
You planned your finishing team at the start of the year with Ross, Grimes and Kreuzer. You didn't plan on getting Bartell, Kornes, Riewoldt, Cox or Thompson. Your right i am shocked
Firstly im shocked at how shit you are reading as i said that i was already upgrading kreuzer to cox and i have swan in my team! Secondly u pointed out grimes and ross and i have always planned on having a midranger as my 7th forward/7th back.
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
As you said Jolly or Kreuzer to Cox is an upgrade isn't it. There's no need to be so nasty just because your shit at explaining yourself. And i stand by what i said, you haven't aimed high enough. Good luck.
Juddy88
Brownlow Medallist
Pie Legend
Premiership Player
- Mar 2, 2008
- 4,148
- 194
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool FC, Timberwolves
Hmm was planning to trade one of Beams or Zahararkis this week, no closer to knowing which one
Any help?
Any help?
Similar threads
