Mega Thread 2013: Trade Hypotheticals

[ThePuppetMaster]

Watts to Carlton is growing legs.

Not happening.

His decision will be based on if the new coach has him in his plans for the future, if so - he'll stay.

I talked to him at a supporter function, he made it very clear that he (also named two other players) found it difficult under Neeld due to constant criticism and an open lack of confidence in his future at the club.

 

[HBF]

Yarran is under contract until the end of next year so if the Eagles are interested they will need to offer something decent.

And if Betts leaves, there's no way we'd consider trading Yarran.

 

[Sydswans0512]

Sounds like Sydney want the world for Mumford. They will have to just keep him at that price. Why all the talk of him leaving anyway?

People were asking his worth

 

[Sydswans0512]

Not on current form.

Obviously haven't seen him lately nearly best on ground last weekend would be a walk up start for Gold Coasts first ruck

 

[Jeremias]

Wait a second.....did I just read that Yarran for Gumbleton is a likely straight swap?

Wow...

 

[Scotty_222]

Obviously haven't seen him lately nearly best on ground last weekend would be a walk up start for Gold Coasts first ruck

Dunno bout that

 

[Sydswans0512]

Dunno bout that

Gold Coast are 17th for hit outs Swans are 2nd behind West Coast Mummy must be doing something right

 

[Sydswans0512]

Sounds like Sydney want the world for Mumford. They will have to just keep him at that price. Why all the talk of him leaving anyway?

A Hawthorn supporter thought pick 50 and Taylor Duryea was fair

 

[Livinthedream]

Cooney been linked to Hawthorn because of Lake.

Ch 10

This one is growing legs all the time.
Will be as a free agent if at all.

 

[BEEG]

Help settle an argument that I was having with a Carlton supporter last night

We were discussing what we would give up for the Num 1 pick

So this is what we both said so ill let you guys decide which is the better deal for GWS

Pies - 1st pick, Sidebottom, Brown
Blues - 1st pick, Simpson, Warnock

 

[Suma Magic]

Pies deal streets ahead.

 

[philthy05]

This one is growing legs all the time.
Will be as a free agent if at all.

if you re-signed franklin then signing cooney would be impossible.

only way you could sign cooney is if franklin leaves, and as you wont know that until the last moment i doubt you are chasing cooney hard right now. this means any leaks regarding hawks going for cooney has to be bull.

 

[I am Jack]

Help settle an argument that I was having with a Carlton supporter last night

We were discussing what we would give up for the Num 1 pick

So this is what we both said so ill let you guys decide which is the better deal for GWS

Pies - 1st pick, Sidebottom, Brown
Blues - 1st pick, Simpson, Warnock

Pies trade is MILES ahead.

Sidebottom worth pick 1 alone.

 

[muttonchops]

Pies deal every day of the week.

 

[Bert Man]

Blues deal doesn't come close to the Pies. GWS could do with midfield class- Sidebottom and a good backman- Brown.

 

[God Save Max King]

Pies deal is miles ahead.

 

[Igloo]

Yeah, Collingwood deal is way better.

 

[BEEG]

His opinion was Simpson still has plenty of class and Warnock is on par with Brown which I found amazing

 

[coniglio_number1]

Warnock is great at tapping but that's it. He is useless around the ground. Brown and sidebottom are both proven premiership players, I'd take the pies deal

 

[dlanod]

His opinion was Simpson still has plenty of class and Warnock is on par with Brown which I found amazing

Simpson is the weak part of the deal. Sidebottom and Brown are both really useful pieces and in the right age group. Warnock would be an upgrade on Brogan, but Simpson's already 29 and will be gone in a few years whereas Sidebottom will be around for years to come. Collingwood every day of the week.

 

[Andre the Giant]

No thanks to either

We'll just keep pick 1 and take another champion in Boyd thank you

 

[It Just Is]

Wait, wasn't it Cooney and Lake who weren't on speaking terms last year because their Mrs had a blow up?


Disclaimer: Only a very vague recollection of this and could be way off the mark.

 

[bluespooner]

if you re-signed franklin then signing cooney would be impossible.

only way you could sign cooney is if franklin leaves, and as you wont know that until the last moment i doubt you are chasing cooney hard right now. this means any leaks regarding hawks going for cooney has to be bull.

It is likely coming from his manager for improved dollars in a contract. I've never known Hawthorn to signal as to whom they may be willing to trade for at this stage of a season.

As you say, if Franklin re-signs then there would be no hope to accommodate Cooney in the salary cap.

 

[Masto]

Pies deal. You could then on-trade that 1st round pick for a ruckman. It would make them a much better team.

 

[Joshen]

Obviously haven't seen him lately nearly best on ground last weekend would be a walk up start for Gold Coasts first ruck

I'd take Dixon and Nicholls ahead of Mumford everyday of the week.