2014 Trade/FA Discussions

Remove this Banner Ad

At the end of the day i'm happy for Ryder to go for what ever reasons but if he does it has to be a fair and good trade done.

At the moment, there is no doubt Essendon are going to get under Paddy's market value which will leave supporters and the club somewhat disappointed.

With exit clauses hanging over your player's heads (and Patrick being the first player who may seek to exercise such clause), Essendon are going to want to get a trade done fairly quickly, as playing hardball may ultimately allow the floodgates to open for other players, which is certainly not in their best interests. (Then again, if the club is quick to accept a deal that is well below his true worth that would be a huge indicator to me that players may easily activate the exit clauses).

Couple that with the fact he has a show-cause notice hanging over his head (this would significantly drop his value), and makes a nomination for a particular club (whispers suggest Brisbane), then a second round draft pick would be a great result for Essendon IMHO. If the whispers are correct, Brisbane do not need another pure ruckman and it is clear he would become our main forward target. As he is relatively untried as a permanent forward this would again decrease his worth in our eyes. (I personally believe he would be very successful for us kicking 50+ goals).

The ramifications of getting a second rounder when he is worth a first far outweigh the potential floodgates that may be opened by activating an exit clause.
 
Yeah - hopefully the Pies' footy department is a little more realistic. If we get Ryder done and based on their needs I can see Leuy or Stef in black and white next year.

Both in contract with Martin just signing a new 3 year deal.

Bergs is worth more to us than on the market from a playing perspective, but the intangible asset of his loyalty to the club is immeasurable to our group and I would very shocked and disappointed for him to go.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Love the group think on the Merrett scenario I posted. If you went to Ross Lyon on Saturday morning and said give us pick 16 and we will give you Merrett today, old Rossy Boy would have jumped at the deal.

Pick 16-20 won't win you a flag next year, picking up a monster defender might. Always a fair deal.
 
Both in contract with Martin just signing a new 3 year deal.

Bergs is worth more to us than on the market from a playing perspective, but the intangible asset of his loyalty to the club is immeasurable to our group and I would very shocked and disappointed for him to go.
So is Beams so all parties would have to be happy to move.
 
Love the group think on the Merrett scenario I posted. If you went to Ross Lyon on Saturday morning and said give us pick 16 and we will give you Merrett today, old Rossy Boy would have jumped at the deal.

Pick 16-20 won't win you a flag next year, picking up a monster defender might. Always a fair deal.

We won't be offered a first rounder. He had a poor season and has had to have surgery post-season.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Love the group think on the Merrett scenario I posted. If you went to Ross Lyon on Saturday morning and said give us pick 16 and we will give you Merrett today, old Rossy Boy would have jumped at the deal.

Pick 16-20 won't win you a flag next year, picking up a monster defender might. Always a fair deal.
Lyon wouldn't give us a first rounder for Mitch Clark doubt he would pay that for a 30 year old
 
Herp.

Brian Lake, a two time all-Australian was traded for pick 41 and a slight upgrade on a second round pick.

Merrett, as much as I love the guy, is not Brian Lake.

Not saying he would definitely attract a 1st rd pick, what I am saying is Hawthorn and Freo will be desperate to fill that monster defender position. Will be interesting to see if they came at the lions what they would part with. I don't play the 'this trade in year x means that a trade this year can only be worth 'x' new year=new market
 
Lyon wouldn't give us a first rounder for Mitch Clark doubt he would pay that for a 30 year old

Wasn't on the cusp of a premiership then. If Sydney win the flag this year, every contender is going to want 2 monster defenders to be able to cover Tippett and Franklin. They might inflate the worth of a mature key defender in the short term.
 
Wasn't on the cusp of a premiership then. If Sydney win the flag this year, every contender is going to want 2 monster defenders to be able to cover Tippett and Franklin. They might inflate the worth of a mature key defender in the short term.

Like when hawks gave up 4th or 5th rounder for lake. I would love an early pick, just don't see it happening
 
I love the idea of getting players with the potential that Beams and Ryder have but if it is going to cost us players such as Luey who has committed to the club previously and is a player which our clubs culture has the potential to be built around, just seems way too much of a risk to take. We have seen the club come along really nicely this year, with the young kids showing great promise and the older blokes stepping there game up also. I just feel like we should keep the loyal, interstate players around as proof to the younger guys that it is a great club and build on this before we start unloading these blokes. Keep pick 4, let the storm blow over and continue with growing our own talent rather than trading it in at the cost of our guys.
 
I love the enthusiasm for our mighty team, but at least be realistic, no team even on the brink of a premiership would trade their future for 30 year old bloke who will only be around for 2 years max. Love merrett, but certainly no star, not even all australian like lake was.
 
You'd think if Sauce was going anywhere that Gold Coast would be all over him and probably his preferred destination.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

2014 Trade/FA Discussions

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top