2015 Draft, Trades and Free Agency rumours.

new breed · Sep 29, 2015

Fremantle considering Jeremy Howe ( Melb ) . Howe's girlfriend is from Perth and Jeremy has close relatives in Perth and is open to a move away from Victoria . Fremantle have already approached Howe to gauge his interest in moving West , a trade needs to be agreed .

pantskyle · Sep 29, 2015

new breed said:
Fremantle considering Jeremy Howe ( Melb ) . Howe's girlfriend is from Perth and Jeremy has close relatives in Perth and is open to a move away from Victoria . Fremantle have already approached Howe to gauge his interest in moving West , a trade needs to be agreed .

I'd expect Melbourne to ask for a first rounder, not sure where Freo are going to get the picks required to bring in McCarthy, Bennell and Howe...

Lyyynnnchy · Sep 29, 2015

pantskyle said:
I'd expect Melbourne to ask for a first rounder, not sure where Freo are going to get the picks required to bring in McCarthy, Bennell and Howe...

Not worth a first rounder

Not tall enough to be a KPF, not quick enough to be a small forward. Will forever be stuck as a mid sized forward with average skills except for his marking ability.

pantskyle · Sep 29, 2015

Lyyynnnchy said:
Not worth a first rounder

Not tall enough to be a KPF, not quick enough to be a small forward. Will forever be stuck as a mid sized forward with average skills except for his marking ability.

Melbourne will certainly be asking for one and knowing Freos late first pick I'd say they would insist on it.

dazzledavey36 · Sep 29, 2015

TBellicious said:
jake melksham lol

Liam Jones lol

Lyyynnnchy · Sep 29, 2015

pantskyle said:
Melbourne will certainly be asking for one and knowing Freos late first pick I'd say they would insist on it.

He was dropped from the Melbourne team at least once or twice IIRC?

pantskyle · Sep 29, 2015

Lyyynnnchy said:
He was dropped from the Melbourne team at least once or twice IIRC?

Played every game this season didn't he?

dazzledavey36 · Sep 29, 2015

Lyyynnnchy said:
He was dropped from the Melbourne team at least once or twice IIRC?

Has never been dropped in his 100 game career.

Gysberts2Bate · Sep 29, 2015

Lyyynnnchy said:
He was dropped from the Melbourne team at least once or twice IIRC?

Has missed just one game since debuting in 2011, and that was in 2013.

Lyyynnnchy · Sep 29, 2015

pantskyle said:
Played every game this season didn't he?

May have been the season prior. I would have him as a pick around 25 to 35. 25 being if a club is chasing him, 35 if he is looking to get out of Melbourne. I mean, even Melbourne don't seem to know where to play him.

Where would you have him play? Not defensive or creative enough for HB and he's not creative enough and with no ability to run through the middle he isn't suited as a HF

pantskyle · Sep 29, 2015

Lyyynnnchy said:
May have been the season prior. I would have him as a pick around 25 to 35. 25 being if a club is chasing him, 35 if he is looking to get out of Melbourne. I mean, even Melbourne don't seem to know where to play him.

Where would you have him play? Not defensive or creative enough for HB and he's not creative enough and with no ability to run through the middle he isn't suited as a HF

Has never been dropped and missed only one game apparently.

Personally I'd play him as a genuine forward pocket but I wouldn't want him at the Eagles anyway.

I agree with your valuation of him however Melbourne would ask for a first IMO, doesn't mean they'd get it though.

go_the_dockers · Sep 29, 2015

Lyyynnnchy said:
May have been the season prior. I would have him as a pick around 25 to 35. 25 being if a club is chasing him, 35 if he is looking to get out of Melbourne. I mean, even Melbourne don't seem to know where to play him.

Where would you have him play? Not defensive or creative enough for HB and he's not creative enough and with no ability to run through the middle he isn't suited as a HF

pantskyle said:
Has never been dropped and missed only one game apparently.

Personally I'd play him as a genuine forward pocket but I wouldn't want him at the Eagles anyway.

I agree with your valuation of him however Melbourne would ask for a first IMO, doesn't mean they'd get it though.

A 1st round pick for a 10 goal a year forward. Haha.

pantskyle · Sep 29, 2015

go_the_dockers said:
A 1st round pick for a 10 goal a year forward. Haha.

No one said he was worth a first round pick, in fact you could read the posts you quoted where the value was agreed at being 25-35.

raffrox · Sep 29, 2015

pantskyle said:
No one said he was worth a first round pick, in fact you could read the posts you quoted where the value was agreed at being 25-35.

There's a few posts saying that Melbourne would ask for one though so it's still a valid comment.

pantskyle · Sep 29, 2015

raffrox said:
There's a few posts saying that Melbourne would ask for one though so it's still a valid comment.

No it's not. An opinion on what Melbourne may ask for has no bearing on what people here suggest he could be worth, which was actually mentioned at being pick 25+.

raffrox · Sep 29, 2015

pantskyle said:
No it's not. An opinion on what Melbourne may ask for has no bearing on what people here suggest he could be worth, which was actually mentioned at being pick 25+.

Sorry thought police but I disagree that it wasn't a valid comment.

pantskyle · Sep 29, 2015

raffrox said:
Sorry thought police but I disagree that it wasn't a valid comment.

Disagree all you want, it's right above in writing.

Only an idiot would think otherwise.

kane249 · Sep 29, 2015

go_the_dockers said:
A 1st round pick for a 10 goal a year forward. Haha.

10 goals a year? That's like gold in Ross Lyons game plan

raffrox · Sep 29, 2015

pantskyle said:
Disagree all you want, it's right above in writing.

Only an idiot would think otherwise.

Relevant enough to be quoted.

kane249 said:
10 goals a year? That's like gold in Ross Lyons game plan

That's not a nice thing to say about a fellow eagles supporter.

kane249 · Sep 29, 2015

raffrox said:
Relevant enough to be quoted.

That's not a nice thing to say about a fellow eagles supporter.

It's called a joke Chuckles, lighten up.

raffrox · Sep 29, 2015

kane249 said:
It's called a joke Chuckles, lighten up.

Are you talking to me or pantskyle? He's the one that called you an idiot.

halfback dasher · Sep 29, 2015

pantskyle said:
I'd expect Melbourne to ask for a first rounder, not sure where Freo are going to get the picks required to bring in McCarthy, Bennell and Howe...

And Shoey

kane249 · Sep 29, 2015

raffrox said:
Are you talking to me or pantskyle? He's the one that called you an idiot.

Shh quiet little one, the adults are talking now.

pantskyle · Sep 29, 2015

kane249 said:
Shh quiet little one, the adults are talking now.

Dearie me.

Marc_Remillard · Sep 29, 2015

go_the_dockers said:
A 1st round pick for a 10 goal a year forward. Haha.

Where do we sign!!

Australia v India - 4th Test Boxing Day!

2015 Draft, Trades and Free Agency rumours.

Brownlow Medallist

Angry Ape

Brownlow Medallist

Angry Ape

Danger

Brownlow Medallist

Angry Ape

Danger

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Angry Ape

Brownlow Medallist

Angry Ape

Brownlow Medallist

Angry Ape

Brownlow Medallist

Angry Ape

Wibble

Brownlow Medallist

Wibble

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Wibble

Angry Ape

Maderator

2015 Draft, Trades and Free Agency rumours.

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account