List Mgmt. 2015 Trade, Draft, Rookie Draft and FA Megathread

[STK2020]

according to stevo bellchambers also wants out of essendon. so they might be desperate for a ruck

Carlton sniffing around Bellchambers

 

[TheLastEmperor]

only way i am cool with that is if we know a way to get another first rounder close to pick 5/6

May as well just keep our first and find another way to get Carlisle then

 

[dewah07]

So you don't want him because you think he'll improve us too much and we won't get as high of a draft pick next year?

Righto.

and hes a flog

and he is massively overrated

need anything else?

 

[dewah07]

There's a guy on SS that started a 'Jake Carlisle' topic. Click on his username and look at his recent postings. He's been spot on regarding a few selections before they were made public and claims his source works for the club.

Anyway, his rumour is our 1st and 3rd pick for Carlisle and their 2nd.

theirs no way clubs are talking specific trades with other clubs right now.

 

[Defacto]

rather than the dons second rounder this year, i'd rather their 2nd rounder next year

 

[TheLastEmperor]

theirs no way clubs are talking specific trades with other clubs right now.

No doubt but that doesn't mean employees at our club don't have conversations about trades and throw out hypotheticals with each other.

 

[Defacto]

theirs no way clubs are talking specific trades with other clubs right now.

i'd be surprised if they werent talking all year round bout them tbh

 

[Barrels]

There's a guy on SS that started a 'Jake Carlisle' topic. Click on his username and look at his recent postings. He's been spot on regarding a few selections before they were made public and claims his source works for the club.

Anyway, his rumour is our 1st and 3rd pick for Carlisle and their 2nd.

I'd deadset puke.

 

[SaintWWodonga]

No thanks, let go into the draft after mids...

 

[dewah07]

i'd be surprised if they werent talking all year round bout them tbh

about specific like 1/3 for their 2nd?

no chance any draft picks have been discussed IMO

 

[Barrels]

Cal Twomey is reporting the Crows are waaay into Alex Keath, but that Geelong and the Saints have made enquiries too...

Gimme a 23yr old free swing 196cm former gun KPD, over assisting Essenscum in ANY way at all.

 

[Defacto]

about specific like 1/3 for their 2nd?

no chance any draft picks have been discussed IMO

fair point. i wouldnt know to be honest

 

[Choomah]

Lol Bellcho is ****ing horrid

 

[Moorabbin Ghost]

There's a guy on SS that started a 'Jake Carlisle' topic. Click on his username and look at his recent postings. He's been spot on regarding a few selections before they were made public and claims his source works for the club.

Anyway, his rumour is our 1st and 3rd pick for Carlisle and their 2nd.

Does anybody honestly think that our club would ever do that trade? It's horrible and will never happen. Look how highly we rated pick 1 last year, do we think we'd trade away Pick 5 this year for an OOC player with form and injury issues (not to mention WADA)?
If a rumour smells funny then it's probably bulls**t!

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Does anybody honestly think that our club would ever do that trade? It's horrible and will never happen. Look how highly we rated pick 1 last year, do we think we'd trade away Pick 5 this year for an OOC player with form and injury issues (not to mention WADA)?
If a rumour smells funny then it's probably bulls**t!

Bloody hope so mate I'm still dry retching just at the thought of it.

 

[Defacto]

interesting post from the same bloke with the carlisle post. gilbert will sign on for another year, just signed on with another management team

 

[bird_man]

and hes a flog

and he is massively overrated

need anything else?

If he's that overrated you won't have to worry about him sending us high up the ladder and leaving us with a shit draft pick then will you?

 

[dewah07]

If he's that overrated you won't have to worry about him sending us high up the ladder and leaving us with a shit draft pick then will you?

he would be an upgrade on whatever else we had (which is what an ageing fisher and dumpster maybe? a 19yo KPD and keys?) but he would be overrated for the amount of draft concessions and money we would be investing…

and this isn't a i hate KPD things because this is exactly the way i want us to get our next KPD but the timing is just way way off

 

[Defacto]

when was the last time a pick that high was given up for a defender, out of interest

 

[Periphery]

he would be an upgrade on whatever else we had (which is what an ageing fisher and dumpster maybe? a 19yo KPD and keys?) but he would be overrated for the amount of draft concessions and money we would be investing…

and this isn't a i hate KPD things because this is exactly the way i want us to get our next KPD but the timing is just way way off

The timing isn't off at all?

 

[Defacto]

he would be an upgrade on whatever else we had (which is what an ageing fisher and dumpster maybe? a 19yo KPD and keys?) but he would be overrated for the amount of draft concessions and money we would be investing…

and this isn't a i hate KPD things because this is exactly the way i want us to get our next KPD but the timing is just way way off

hows the timing off? 2018 and 2020 is only 3-5 years away

takes defenders a minimum of 4 years to get going

 

[dewah07]

The timing isn't off at all?

yes it is we need to hit the draft the way we set out from the start.

we then need to focus more of our resources into top ups form other clubs when we want to make the jump to top4 contender

 

[bird_man]

he would be an upgrade on whatever else we had (which is what an ageing fisher and dumpster maybe? a 19yo KPD and keys?) but he would be overrated for the amount of draft concessions and money we would be investing…

and this isn't a i hate KPD things because this is exactly the way i want us to get our next KPD but the timing is just way way off

I don't get your theory. What if Treloar wanted to come to us? Would the timing be off? Would he be too much of an improvement on our other mids?

You are talking dribble.

 

[dewah07]

hows the timing off? 2018 and 2020 is only 3-5 years away

takes defenders a minimum of 4 years to get going

we have to hit the draft, we can't afford to risk our rebuild on him

 

[dewah07]

I don't get your theory. What if Treloar wanted to come to us? Would the timing be off? Would he be too much of an improvement on our other mids?

You are talking dribble.

of coarse not, he's not overrated and the draft concessions would most likely be worth it if we didn't have to dip into 2016 draft picks