List Mgmt. 2015 Trade, Free agency and draft rumours

[Steven Tyler]

Aish is a dud.

There, I said it so it's true!

Hope so, because like everyone else, he's off to either Collingwood or Geelong

 

[Thaihawk]

Orourke played well on Saturday, really hard at the ball. I think he will be a player, especially after a full pre season. Be pushing to be in the best 22.... Hopefully

I can see a future midfield with Jed, and J.O'R featuring prominently.

 

[Glacier]

I think you will find draft order does correlate with likelihood of success although of course there are exceptions. Why do you think Aish will be an exception?

Why do I think?
Because I don't think he's elite or will rise to that level
Simple really

Happy enough for the kid if he has a tremendous career however

As for the rest of my post, I answered and received a blah blah blah which is not really intelligent for someone who went on about proper discussion

 

[Bad Boy Beama]

AHH I see
I dont rate him as highly as some on here and maybe not as lowly as some on here yet I am asked to back up my opinion with all sorts of data and stats because you dont agree and you DO rate him.. I get it
So having an opinion based on what I have seen is not good enough for you??
Well heaven forbid anyone have a differing view than you..
For the record I dont rave about Aish because for me I see not alot to rave about
Good enough young fella but does he have the potential to be an elite midfielder that we need???
I dont think he will be

But again that is just my opinion as I have repeatedly stated all along, and I have never said my opinion is the be all and end all

If thats ok with you of course

Calm down, ease on up and take a deep breath

 

[Glacier]

Calm down, ease on up and take a deep breath

Perfectly calm, why would I get fired up over a footy discussion?

 

[halfback dasher]

Hay Mods , can we open a "Aish is crap , no he's not " thread .....?

 

[Ned Ryerson]

Or he could go fishing and not attend. Is that not a good look as well?

Not if he wins it.

 

[Boo71]

Ha

I agree but you will need some facts to back up your opinion or they won't let it go, just saying.

Were are your facts, data, stats, and video footage to back up the fact that you agree, just asking.

 

[nickrebellious]

Aish is really decent. He's still light as a feather with hardly any core strength. Hes one of those guys who needs to develop physically still, but he's so classy. Would love him at the Hawks and for our first pick would be an absolute steal.

 

[MrPremiership]

Hartlett?

Port shopping him around to alleviate salary cap pressures, could we get him with out first pick? Can come accross as a Wayne Kerr at times, but he is 25 and can re-generate our midfield without compromising our premiership window.

 

[Glacier]

Hartlett?

Port shopping him around to alleviate salary cap pressures, could we get him with out first pick? Can come accross as a Wayne Kerr at times, but he is 25 and can re-generate our midfield without compromising our premiership window.

Big bodied midfielder with pace..

 

[Brishawk]

Why do I think?
Because I don't think he's elite or will rise to that level
Simple really

Happy enough for the kid if he has a tremendous career however

As for the rest of my post, I answered and received a blah blah blah which is not really intelligent for someone who went on about proper discussion

I didn't feel the need to quote or respond to 'So?', 'So what?', 'So you want to pay him...?'.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-ne...-draft-to-get-to-geelong-20150922-gjs0l1.html - interesting to see if things get messy with the Dangerfield scenario.

 

[Brishawk]

Big bodied midfielder with pace..

If only you posted with such clarity on Aish we might be able to have a conversation.

 

[Brant]

Hartlett?

Port shopping him around to alleviate salary cap pressures, could we get him with out first pick? Can come accross as a Wayne Kerr at times, but he is 25 and can re-generate our midfield without compromising our premiership window.

I know in this scenario, they're the ones shopping him, but surely they'd not be as silly as to trade an asset to a contender desperately needing that asset?

 

[Glacier]

I didn't feel the need to quote or respond to 'So?', 'So what?', 'So you want to pay him...?'.

Why post shit then if you dont want me to pick it apart

 

[MrPremiership]

Big bodied midfielder with pace..

Is gettable, not aboslutely elite but would be a good get to replace the incumbents.

 

[Glacier]

If only you posted with such clarity on Aish we might be able to have a conversation.

Small light bodied overrated unproven potential midfielder
There you go

 

[MrPremiership]

I know in this scenario, they're the ones shopping him, but surely they'd not be as silly as to trade an asset to a contender desperately needing that asset?

If it meant they could use the cap on Charlie Dixon.....then I could see them doing it

 

[Cynic]

Hartlett?

Port shopping him around to alleviate salary cap pressures, could we get him with out first pick? Can come accross as a Wayne Kerr at times, but he is 25 and can re-generate our midfield without compromising our premiership window.

He is a complete dick.

 

[Brant]

If it meant they could use the cap on Charlie Dixon.....then I could see them doing it

I just think they'd do anything to send him to St Kilda etc rather than us. Or to Adelaide as a replacement for Dangerfield ;-)

 

[Brishawk]

Why post shit then if you dont want me to pick it apart

Next time I will just post references to my past glory years as a junior footballer as evidence why a player won't realise his potential.

 

[Milkshaker]

He is a complete dick.

Glacier?

 

[Ned Ryerson]

This is from Hartlett's Wiki page - I love when you can tell whether the player has written their own profile or not:

"He is a medium-sized midfielder who reads the game exceptionally well, has clean hands, vision and kicks the ball superbly from any where inside 65m"

 

[Big Hotdog]

SEN - Richmond and North have put big 5 year deals to Hamish Hartlett who is a free agent next year-reportedly.