List Mgmt. 2018 Draft/Trade/FA (Pt. 2)

[Iva Bigun]

Out of the 3 likely top picks we get 2 of them, which ever 2 that’s is it is a win for us regardless

 

[Peel67skin]

Bytel is pretty good , good height as well .

 

[17er]

Bytel is pretty good , good height as well .

Do you think we should get him at #80? I couldn't find anyone with him in their top 30.

 

[Peel67skin]

Do you think we should get him at #80? I couldn't find anyone with him in their top 30.

Take him like Sam Mitchell / dan Swan, Neale ,Ballard , worpel , his injuries cause him to fall out of ranking . At the start of the year a lot of people rank him as high as Top 20 , obviously you can't rate him high if you don't see him much this year .

* Powell- don't think anyone mention him at all last year top 30 , yet you think he is a good pick by Clayton .
Ballard - most rated him higher than 40+ , yet he fell to 40+.

 

[17er]

I think we should get Mitch Podhajski, because after the departure of Kolodjashnij we really need a player that nobody knows how to spell or pronounce. Lukoskious and Homshc can only go so far. I also like Brayden Ham because you can never have enough Braydens, Tyron Smallwood because his name could be a character in Game of Thrones, Zac Foot because of the commentary potential "Foot poor by foot", Zak Butters because South Park, Jackson Hately because we might have as many Jacks as St Kilda and Xavier Duursma because of the way Bruuuuuuce will say his name.

 

[Peel67skin]

I think we should get Mitch Podhajski, because after the departure of Kolodjashnij we really need a player that nobody knows how to spell or pronounce. Lukoskious and Homshc can only go so far. I also like Brayden Ham because you can never have enough Braydens, Tyron Smallwood because his name could be a character in Game of Thrones, Zac Foot because of the commentary potential "Foot poor by foot", Zak Butters because South Park, Jackson Hately because we might have as many Jacks as St Kilda and Xavier Duursma because of the way Bruuuuuuce will say his name.

Let's do it . Nothing wrong with your preference , everybody have their own type of players they like .As long you are happy who dare to disagree with you .

 

[17er]

Take him like Sam Mitchell / dan Swan, Neale ,Ballard , worpel , his injuries cause him to fall out of ranking . At the start of the year a lot of people rank him as high as Top 20 , obviously you can't rate him high if you don't see him much this year .

* Powell- don't think anyone mention him at all last year top 30 , yet you think he is a good pick by Clayton .
Ballard - most rated him higher than 40+ , yet he fell to 40+.

Actually, Ballard was very highly rated in his U17 year, but grew about 15cm and his form suffered. Still played rep footy and was the only junior player in the last 2 years to keep Lukosius out of a game. Suns actually had Ballard on the board at #19, but opted for Powell because they knew the WA clubs would get him before they could and were very lucky that Ballard fell down so far given his high grades from 2 years at the National Champs.

Where will you pick Bytel?

 

[Peel67skin]

Actually, Ballard was very highly rated in his U17 year, but grew about 15cm and his form suffered. Still played rep footy and was the only junior player in the last 2 years to keep Lukosius out of a game. Suns actually had Ballard on the board at #19, but opted for Powell because they knew the WA clubs would get him before they could and were very lucky that Ballard fell down so far given his high grades from 2 years at the National Champs.

Where will you pick Bytel?

I myself rated him between 35+ -50 .
With F/S and academy bid ,pick 29 could fell to 34-35 . ( Thomas , Blakey,quanor , west, McFadden,Bailey Scott etc)

 

[Mini GF]

I myself rated him between 35+ -50 .
With F/S and academy bid ,pick 29 could fell to 34-35 . ( Thomas , Blakey,quanor , west, McFadden,Bailey Scott etc)

The mystical Peel knows his stuff. Believe me. This guy should be read carefully.

 

[SnusCG]

Actually, Ballard was very highly rated in his U17 year, but grew about 15cm and his form suffered. Still played rep footy and was the only junior player in the last 2 years to keep Lukosius out of a game. Suns actually had Ballard on the board at #19, but opted for Powell because they knew the WA clubs would get him before they could and were very lucky that Ballard fell down so far given his high grades from 2 years at the National Champs.

Where will you pick Bytel?

I was actually reading the other day, it was Melbourne that looked likely to take Powell from us with their mid 20’s and 30’s picks rather than any of the WA teams.

Bytel I expect to be gone by 40. He doesn’t have a lot of exposed form this year but looked a likely top 10 pick til injury struck last year. Should swoop at 29 if we want him

 

[Peel67skin]

The mystical Peel knows his stuff. Believe me. This guy should be read carefully.

I am part of Ablett cheering God Squad until I joined GC BF . Mystical enough Mr Bods.

 

[Mego Red]

I like this mock draft a lot!
My criticisms are that they didn't know Geelong has to pick in the first round and they sold the Suns short on their trade. Turned out that they made a trade between the Cats and Lions, incidentally keeping within the rules, but it was a big miss.

Having the Suns give up on Rozee to take a crappy deal with Adelaide is just like the continual rubbish offers posted here every day.
#6 and #24 for #8 and #16 just benefits the Crows too much.
Make it #6 and #29 for #8 and #16 and it starts to look more realistic,
or #6 and #24 for #8 and #13 would be even better.
#6, #24 and #29 for #8, #16 and #21 gets the Suns what fans want = Caldwell, McLennan and O'Halloran

I've said all along that Port and the Crows have the best deals available for the Suns, although GWS have the overall picks to really make things interesting.

It needs to be a trade the other team would do as well.

 

[Peel67skin]

It needs to be a trade the other team would do as well.

Yep .

 

[OB11]

That would actually be awesome for us. Walsh would slot straight into our midfield and we'd still get our main priority in replacing Lynch. I don't think it happens though because Carlton already has 9 small forwards and barely enough players to actually field a midfield let alone have any left over for the VFL.

Tomorrow Cal will be pushing for the Suns to swap for Pick #1, on Wednesday he'll be spruiking the King Twins again and by Thursday night he will be predicting
1. Walsh
2. Lukosius
3. Rankine
4. M. King
5. B. King
6. Rozee
7. Smith

Hear all his theories here-

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-11-13/podcast-team-reveals-their-mock-draft-for-the-first-round

What small forwards do the Blues have - if I can't name them easily they probably are not any good.

They had Matty Wright but he's left and Rankine is in a different stratosphere to anyone they have down that end of the ground.

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[17er]

It needs to be a trade the other team would do as well.

But do you agree that any deal for the Suns pick #6 needs to be better than the rival bids?

If Port offer #10 and #15 and GWS offer #9 and #19, don't the Crows need to offer #8 and #16 to beat them? We'll chuck in #29 to make it worthwhile.

What if the bidding gets fierce and GWS puts up #9, #11 and #19 for #6, #24 and #29? Can the Crows match that with #8, #13 and #21?

Nobody in the media seems to understand that the Suns are holding pick #6 and a baseball bat. You will cop a whack if you really want that pick, but someone is going to pay it because there's going to be a ripping good player available and the Suns want more first round picks.

 

[17er]

What small forwards do the Blues have - if I can't name them easily they probably are not any good.

They had Matty Wright but he's left and Rankine is in a different stratosphere to anyone they have down that end of the ground.

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

Jarrod Garlett
Jarrod Pickett
Zac Fisher
Cameron Polson
Sam Petrevski-Seton
Alex Fasolo
David Cunningham
Darcy Lang
Kym LeBois

 

[Peel67skin]

Jarrod Garlett
Jarrod Pickett
Zac Fisher
Cameron Polson
Sam Petrevski-Seton
Alex Fasolo
David Cunningham
Darcy Lang
Kym LeBois

185212"]
Jarrod Garlett- fail
Jarrod Pickett- injured more than playing game
Zac Fisher- Gun
Cameron Polson- fail
Sam Petrevski-Seton- Gun
Alex Fasolo- injuries prone
David Cunningham- ?
Darcy Lang- ?
Kym LeBois-?

 

[Ben Drever]

Scrimshaw and his old man..
Sounding like the... that they are.
Saying no one wanted him because of his injuries.. but hawks came running..

Pretty sure your old man went running to the hawks asoon as GC called your name draft night.

Jack even said his old man stole the spotlight at a dinner with clarko..

Sounds like the bloke has tickets on himself.

Goodluck with clarko you 2.
He hates lazy w***ers.

The scrimshaw name deffinetly wont go down with folklore with the HAwthorn footy club.

That i am sure of

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/ha...r/news-story/ceb1402961fc3b2b1e59515e7652d760

 

[17er]

185212"]
Jarrod Garlett- fail
Jarrod Pickett- injured more than playing game
Zac Fisher- Gun
Cameron Polson- fail
Sam Petrevski-Seton- Gun
Alex Fasolo- injuries prone
David Cunningham- ?
Darcy Lang- ?
Kym LeBois-?

Darcy Lang played 44 games for Geelong, deciding he'd rather play for Carlton than be traded to the Suns as part of the Gaz deal. He played 11 games for Carlton this year. He came in at pick #16 in the 2013 Draft.

Alex Fasolo has played 101 games in 8 seasons for Collingwood and kicked 133.89

David Cunningham was selected by Carlton at #23 in 2015

Kym LeBois was picked by Carlton #5 in the 2016 Rookie Draft

Carlton have spent far too much on small forwards to take risk on Izak Rankine now.

 

[Peel67skin]

Darcy Lang played 44 games for Geelong, deciding he'd rather play for Carlton than be traded to the Suns as part of the Gaz deal. He played 11 games for Carlton this year. He came in at pick #16 in the 2013 Draft.

Alex Fasolo has played 101 games in 8 seasons for Collingwood and kicked 133.89

David Cunningham was selected by Carlton at #23 in 2015

Kym LeBois was picked by Carlton #5 in the 2016 Rookie Draft

Carlton have spent far too much on small forwards to take risk on Izak Rankine now.

I hope you are right , but don't mind Sam Walsh if Carlton don't pick him .

 

[Peel67skin]

THE_GUN

Just for you .

 

[17er]

THE_GUN

Just for you .

You, sir, are a comic genius!












Of football related stuff

 

[Ben Drever]

Cals road to draft podcast.
Few rumblings.
Nothing new for GC

http://m.afl.com.au/news/2018-11-19/podcast-rumour-mill-in-overdrive-days-out-from-draft

 

[Jirik13]

Jarrod Garlett
Jarrod Pickett
Zac Fisher
Cameron Polson
Sam Petrevski-Seton
Alex Fasolo
David Cunningham
Darcy Lang
Kym LeBois

Only Pickett, Polson, Garlett, LeBois are small forwards. Pickett most talented but has skin-fold issue. All of them will probably turn out crap. Carlton could definitely use Rankine. Yes, Fisher can play the position too but will be a midfielder, flanker eventually.

 

[17er]

Only Pickett, Polson, Garlett, LeBois are small forwards. Pickett most talented but has skin-fold issue. All of them will probably turn out crap. Carlton could definitely use Rankine. Yes, Fisher can play the position too but will be a midfielder, flanker eventually.

Nope. All 9 are forwards, with some listed as midfield forward. They are all young too, 21 to 23 next season. But sure, why not add a 10th small forward with their only selection inside the first 3 and a half rounds?