- Aug 30, 2017
- 16,322
- 67,560
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
everyone's settled on carlton if you go by the media, don't buy it
They do seem to trade in most Giants players though
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
everyone's settled on carlton if you go by the media, don't buy it
that's fair, but most of them turn out to be spuds so in a way they're kind of a sh*t player filterThey do seem to trade in most Giants players though
I'd like this to happen
Saints ->Brodie
Carlton->Dunstan
GC->Whatever pick we were getting for Dunstan
Of course the flaw in the plan is that Carlton would prefer to get the better player in Brodie over Luke themselves
Contracted for another two years not on a higr wage. Firmer puck 5. Late first IMO2 poor AFL games and 7 average NEAFL games in 2 years plus a blown knee. What do you think he’d be worth?
Both Bruce & Paddy would be on the trade block if it were up to me
Wingard staying apparently according to Robbo.
Not surr we'd need another mid if we picked up Shiel and Setterfield.I wonder what would need to be added to give up our two firsts and end up with Setters, Shiel and pick 12?
Take Caldwell with 12 and we win the off-season.
2 poor AFL games and 7 average NEAFL games in 2 years plus a blown knee. What do you think he’d be worth?
Very different injury than Freeman. Most players seem to recover well from and ACL. Former pick 5 that some rated as high as pick one. I'd be happy to give up am early second for him.No idea, maybe start with what we got Nat Freeman for.
If it is early 2nd round, I would prefer to roll the dice in draft , got some rippers in the 20’s .....Williams ( slider) , Bowman, Sturt , Duursma , McHenry .
What picks could we likely get for players like Dunstan, Hickey, Bruce etc?
Wonder if we could put a player/pick package together to get another pick in the top 10.All contracted so the deal would be slightly in our favour.
Dunstan - 30-40
Hickey - 25-35
Bruce - 20-30
What picks could we likely get for players like Dunstan, Hickey, Bruce etc?
Signed him at 10:23 this morning.We got Kelly yet?
It depends on Suns as they hold a contract and if Saints make contact. Sorry I cant say much until trade week is over as people have a tendancy to take things the wrong way but conversations with clubs are taking place as you would expect.
2 poor AFL games and 7 average NEAFL games in 2 years plus a blown knee. What do you think he’d be worth?
Signed him at 10:23 this morning.
Only cost us this year’s first, next year’s first, Steven and Gresham.
Have since on-traded him to Hawthorn for Ryan Shoenmakers and their 5th Round pick
#werebackintownbaby
I wouldn’t expect you to give away any more than that. Cheers mateIt depends on Suns as they hold a contract and if Saints make contact. Sorry I cant say much until trade week is over as people have a tendancy to take things the wrong way but conversations with clubs are taking place as you would expect.