Mega Thread 2018 Trade Period Discussion part 2! (cont. in Part 3 - link in OP)

[70lethal]

This famous #5 pick ....the plane hasn't left the Airport yet, on it's around Australia Tour ...stay tuned

I want pick 5's F.F.P. brisbane-perth-mel-gc-adel in 24 hours

 

[Jetwa5h]

With all these robberies taking place, Carlton must feel like idiots giving us pick 13 and McAdam for Gov.

Seems so long ago..............

 

[kirky]

They not only take it, but say thank you afterwards. Its madness.

They dont need picks 2 and 3 in all seriousness, they need a treasure chest of picks to rebuild their list. I am trying to remove my Crows bias here. But I think if they took all our 2018 picks and 1st next year for 2 and 3, they can properly start assembling a good squad. ffs We will even give them Hamish to do their picks for this year lol.

Think I am joking, I would seriously entertain that thought for them to not botch it up.

Again I only want 2 and 3 if our Club rates Luko and Rankine that highly. If they DONT, they lets take all our picks and rebuild our list inside a month.

If we are only going to have two picks just get 2 & 3 and give up 8, 13, 16 and 21. Should do it and if not throw in next years 1st rounder.

Would be great just to see the melts.

 

[hippyhippy]

If we are only going to have two picks just get 2 & 3 and give up 8, 13, 16 and 21. Should do it and if not throw in next years 1st rounder.

Would be great just to see the melts.

if hamish thinks they are as good as everyone thinks.. i'll do it and let him work his magic in the later rounds if needed.

 

[FR0GGY]

Trade Radio saying Kade Kolodjashnij going to Melbourne for a pick in the 50's after being taken pick 5 in the 2013 draft.

Scrimmshaw went for less than that, using this years positions as a guide, hawthorn traded 2019 rd 3 pick (53 this year) for gold coasts 2019 4th rd pick (59 this year), pick difference is around 67 for a 2016 pick 7!

Suns will finish last next year, hawthorn may slide a little.

 

[azza77]

Trade Radio saying Kade Kolodjashnij going to Melbourne for a pick in the 50's after being taken pick 5 in the 2013 draft.

He's 1, maybe 2 head knocks off needing to retire from the sport altogether. Has already missed large chunks of time with concussions related symptoms. It's an extremely sad and crappy position to be in, but despite his talent he is the definition of 'damaged goods'.

However, one could argue they're better off keeping him while he's on the park, as that provides a bigger benefit than trading him for absolute peanuts...

 

[kirky]

if hamish thinks they are as good as everyone thinks.. i'll do it and let him work his magic in the later rounds if needed.

But we might not have many spots available on our list - that may be part of the problem. Therefore as they say on the tables - “we are all in”.

 

[jaytex]

We've done two deals today... what's the problem?

i'll assume you're being facetious

 

[hey shorty]

Maybe we are cut out of a top 5 pick...not needed and unloved

We won't be cut out, you can still trade picks post draft.

 

[jenny61_99]

i'll assume you're being facetious

We've done two deals today. That's two more than yesterday!

 

[jaytex]

We've done two deals today. That's two more than yesterday!

i'll assume you're being deliberately obtuse for the lols

 

[exit]

I've done 2 turds today, which is 2 more than yesterday.

 

[hey shorty]

i'll assume you're being deliberately obtuse for the lols

Still more than a few clubs.

Picks can be traded up to draft night, I wouldn't expect us to do anything tomorrow either.

 

[DJ75]

Could we trade 8, 13, 16, 21 + 2019 1st to GC for 2, 3, 29 & 2019 2nd?

That leaves GC with draft picks 8, 13, 16, 19, 21 & 24 this year.

For a club that is basically starting from scratch it would give them a very good starting point. Surely with 6 picks inside the top 25 they could find some talent who want to stay there...

It would also leave us with 3 picks - Luko, Rankine and an Ogilvie special.

I'd feel much better with 3 picks than with just the 2 picks in the draft if we are giving up a load of picks. The 2019 picks would only be a small number apart.

 

[jaytex]

Still more than a few clubs.

Picks can be traded up to draft night, I wouldn't expect us to do anything tomorrow either.

sad face. guess i'm just hoping we one day live up to the lofty highs of two years ago when it all went down to the wire with Gibbs first time around. that was a really fun afternoon.

 

[hey shorty]

Could we trade 8, 13, 16, 21 + 2019 1st to GC for 2, 3, 29 & 2019 2nd?

That leaves GC with draft picks 8, 13, 16, 19, 21 & 24 this year.

For a club that is basically starting from scratch it would give them a very good starting point. Surely with 6 picks inside the top 25 they could find some talent who want to stay there...

It would also leave us with 3 picks - Luko, Rankine and an Ogilvie special.

I'd feel much better with 3 picks than with just the 2 picks in the draft if we are giving up a load of picks. The 2019 picks would only be a small number apart.

I'd do that, but would they ??

They might to screw Port for the lols.

 

[dude316]

We've done two deals today. That's two more than yesterday!

 

[Tex200]

I'd do that, but would they ??

They might to screw Port for the lols.

If they get 5 then maybe

 

[hey shorty]

sad face. guess i'm just hoping we one day live up to the lofty highs of two years ago when it all went down to the wire with Gibbs first time around. that was a really fun afternoon.

We may do, theres still a lot that needs to be done. Wingard aside, every big deal has something to do with another one.

 

[Betts are off]

I've done 2 turds today, which is 2 more than yesterday.

You may need some metamucil champ!

Gotta stay more regular then that!

 

[hey shorty]

If they get 5 then maybe

That's my thoughts

 

[Legz]

But 72 wasn't enough?

Consider it goodwill. We’re unlikely to use either 68 or 72, whereas whatever we give them will be an active pick.

Other than to be difficult, no reason to not give them 68. Don’t it would carry much currency for any other deals.

 

[hey shorty]

I dont agree much with Lloyd but he is spot on when he says the Suns are the worst list in AFL history.

They could be in for some frightful beatings next year.

 

[WheresGroomgone]

The names escape me at the moment, but I know of a couple of Crows players that we let go for compassionate reasons and allowed a smooth transfer.

I think there was a ruckman we had from Perth and Kane Johnson IIRC too as well.

The problem with being compassionate is that you know someone will exploit the system well.

We also helped a Gallagher or a Collins (can't remember) return to Melbourne due to compassionate reasons when his room mate took his own life.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Scorpus]

I dont agree much with Lloyd but he is spot on when he says the Suns are the worst list in AFL history.

They could be in for some frightful beatings next year.

That's saying something when you consider Carlton's list over the last 2-3 years