List Mgmt. 2019 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals Thread

[caesar88]

Sometimes you need to make hard decisions and if we can get a bundle of first rounders it might be worth it

But then we are just stalling the rebuild even further. We have a group of youngsters now who are no more than five years apart, so they should be a solid group to take us through to our next flag-contending team. We need to put the pieces for that next team in place, not trading the pieces for 18 year olds!

 

[Ticky009]

That's the first tied to the Crows. Jones may well get a big $ offer from the Blues, they have plenty of cap and a desperate need for mature hard nuts. I'm amenable to that trade.

Any movement to Carlton, from our team or any other is going to be dependent on who they get as coach too not just $.

 

[kickthething]

If the high ish number of uncontracted players is by design.....I would suspect we have a few interesting ins on the way...

 

[mtooler]

We'd only get a 2nd rounder for Jones, around pick 25-30 is my guess.

 

[mtooler]

Dawson probably a future 3rd rounder.

 

[Wayne Swan]

Dawson probably a future 3rd rounder.

Dawson and the others being talked about on here are all worth far more to us than what we'd get for them in a trade. Dawson is looking better and better each week, other than the fact he's up for renewal, I don't see any other reasons he's not re-signing.

Papps, well any rumour around him is laughable, he loves the club as much as we do, as do all his family, not sure who or where this rumour started.

We thought Jones may have gone two years ago, reckon he'll re-sign as well now he's part of the midfield rotation which suits him better than a HB role. If he wants to go I'd expect value in return.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Dawson and the others being talked about on here are all worth far more to us than what we'd get for them in a trade. Dawson is looking better and better each week, other than the fact he's up for renewal, I don't see any other reasons he's not re-signing.

Papps, well any rumour around him is laughable, he loves the club as much as we do, as do all his family, not sure who or where this rumour started.

We thought Jones may have gone two years ago, reckon he'll re-sign as well now he's part of the midfield rotation which suits him better than a HB role. If he wants to go I'd expect value in return.

Sage from poster Mr Swan.

 

[mtooler]

Dawson and the others being talked about on here are all worth far more to us than what we'd get for them in a trade. Dawson is looking better and better each week, other than the fact he's up for renewal, I don't see any other reasons he's not re-signing.

Papps, well any rumour around him is laughable, he loves the club as much as we do, as do all his family, not sure who or where this rumour started.

We thought Jones may have gone two years ago, reckon he'll re-sign as well now he's part of the midfield rotation which suits him better than a HB role. If he wants to go I'd expect value in return.

Agree, some of the trade ranges for Jones, Dawson etc are amusing.

 

[scaryness]

Fantasy hypothetical

North get: John Longmire, Zak Jones
Swans get: Rhyce Shaw, Jy Simpkin, 2nd rounder

 

[dosser]

Another hypothetical.
Adelaide get Dawson and our first round
We get first pick

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Another hypothetical.
Adelaide get Dawson Rose and our first round
We get first pick

 

[swansfan51]

So basically we upgrade our 1st round pick for free and Adelaide take a hit to their salary cap

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

So basically we upgrade our 1st round pick for free and Adelaide take a hit to their salary cap

sounds eminently fair to me ... if Rose shows some form, the Crows need a small or medium forward to help Betts.

 

[Membling]

Brief look at championships:

If we get a pick outside of to three (Rowell, Anderson or Young) pretty even with next 6 or so players

Flanders would be good get as an inside mid
Kemp as a utility would be good - being played in the backline through the championship for a weird reason more damaging through mid
Ash as a line breaking HBF also good in this range

For our second hopefully Robertson slides, another good inside mid
Or we take a punt on Sharp - good kick, very smart player. Can be a bit lazy on two way running but skill is definitely there

 

[mtooler]

Fantasy hypothetical

North get: John Longmire, Zak Jones
Swans get: Rhyce Shaw, Jy Simpkin, 2nd rounder

That would be a solid deal for us.

 

[mtooler]

Another hypothetical.
Adelaide get Dawson and our first round
We get first pick

That would be wonderful!

 

[Edmund hunt]

We need a qick midfielder or a top pick in the draft imo

 

[dosser]

That would be wonderful!

They would get a good player (who is an adelaide boy) as well as pick 4 or something. It would be good for them, and we get Rowell (although I would be upset to lose Dawson).

 

[SwansProudly]

I do not want to lose Dawson - his kicking, his marking, ideal wing/centre for us

 

[Membling]

We need a qick midfielder or a top pick in the draft imo

Top picks look to be more your inside mids/utilities/HBF types.

No Gaff like wings in the top 10 at this stage

I wouldn't say no to a player like Parish but feel we need to be targeting rucks & defenders still. Sinclair was the right call because without him we'd be screwed, English would be the type of player I'd prefer we chase.

Luke Jackson would be an interesting get with our 2nd or 3rd pick. WA ruck. Needs work on tap but that is what cox is for

 

[Ticky009]

Jones can go if we must. Need to sign Dawson.

 

[Punts]

I would be keeping Pink on the list

 

[S120]

I would be keeping Pink on the list

Definitely. We re-signed him last year based on not much and now he's actually showing a lot of promise as a defender, we've got to keep him around. Particularly with question marks over Jack Maibaum (I reckon he would have played seniors this year had he not got hurt) and Grundy retiring.

On top of keeping Pink, we'll need to either keep Maibaum around (if his body is OK then i'd be all for it) or get another solid KPD in over the off-season.

 

[6yearsold]

I think we have enough young players. Time to start trading in some mid-late twenty year olds.

 

[F_therest]

Pick 12 ish from Adelaide isn’t too far off not sure we could realistically expect more. If he wants to leave I’d be comfortable with that exchange.

Is Papley under contract?

No way you guys would want to trade him, but have heard he's considering going back to VIC.

Would be happy to trade Crows 1st for him.