Game Day 2019 Draft - now with poll!

[All_In]

View attachment 785748 View attachment 785750

Gold Coast cleaned up with a first-rate midfield to go with the key position kids from last year. Hard to fu** it up when you get gifted pick 1. A+
Melbourne, well they need forwards and took the tallest and shortest blokes they could find. C
Giants, yeah they really need more midfielders. Lucky no one wanted to bid on Green. A
Sydney, Stephens... good pick but is he what they need? B
Adelaide: future planning is great but where's the elite midfielder they're crying out for? Did dropping from 4 to 6 hurt them? B-
Fremantle: bang bang bang. Forced to pick up Henry early but they've done well. A
Hawthorn: Will Day, maybe a bit early but when do the Hawks get it wrong? B-
Port: Bergman and Gerogiades. Bergman yes but Georg is early, could have gone at 22. Forward line five years from now was selected tonight. C+
Bulldogs: Weightman... do they have a glaring list need? B
Geelong: Stephens and De Koning, filling list needs before the collapse. If only they had a midfield. B
Carlton: Kemp, wow. Philp, who? Sos had a lot of fun, but WTF on Philp. B
Richmond: Dow... hopefully he's better than his brother. Maybe the genetics scared everyone off til 21. C+

Gold Coast, Giants, Fremantle the winners tonight.

Nuffie

 

[jc67]

Sounds like Mrouch.... so not really what we need? Or is it the case of best available?

Robertson gets it out of the contest and into the 50 pretty well and seems to move it almost exclusively forward (IMO mrouch gets stuck in the contest a bit, and goes backwards and sideways too much)

I think Robertson’s poor kicking % might be because of getting an impossible (albeit hacked) kick out of the contest pretty regularly.

We should be trading up to get him.



On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Deaneus!]

Nuffie

Go jump out of a plane

 

[StonesThrow]

Yeah Gould and Robertson would be good. One elite kick and both tough nuts.

 

[dogs105]

SOS just said that Carlton rated Kemp and Philp inside 10 ("we rated the boys inside 10")

Really? Philp inside 10?

EDIT: Just clarified and said Philp was rated inside 20

They got a player rated in their top 20 at 20? Got to hand it to SOS

 

[Sanders]

I don't have you on ignore ....I should, but i don't ..... I just skim past ....you know, like a drunk homeless man on the street, you just give a wide berth to

don't be so hard on yourself, you're not quite that bad

 

[Pea Nut]

Yeah Gould and Robertson would be good. One elite kick and both tough nuts.

Would send the must add leg speed campaigners in to full melt down mode.

 

[Deaneus!]

"The Blues – who had traded picks 11 and 62 to the Suns in exchange for 17 and 22 – then traded 22 and 25 to the Power for pick 20.

They then used pick 20 on unheralded midfielder Sam Philp, who missed selection in the under-18 Vic Metro team this year and was a surprise invite to the NAB AFL Draft Combine."

So... they turned 11, 25, 62 into 17, 20?

Philp wouldn't have been available at 25?

Yikes, that's a big call with the talent on the board. I think SOS ****ed that one up.

 

[Mutineer]

Mutineer in order, what would be your 4 players in preference for our next 2, ignore who Port and Brisbane might pick and any of them quick skilled mids?

1. Rantall based on the most projected upside,2. Robertson based on leadership and character, 3. Rivers based on versatility, 4. Gould based on his hardness, 5. Worrell based on X factor but personality?,6. Bianco based on perceived go home factor.

 

[Untouchables22]

Robertson, Worrell, Jones, Stephens, Gould, Rivers, Rantall, Blanco.

So stressed that we won’t get any of these..

 

[Elite Crow]

1. Rantall based on the most projected upside,2. Robertson based on leadership and character, 3. Rivers based on versatility, 4. Gould based on his hardness, 5. Worrell based on X factor but personality?,6. Bianco based on perceived go home factor.

What about this Sharp fella?

 

[DJ75]

For me, I'd look at the following;

Gould
Schoenberg
Bianco

I'm not overly high on Gould's ceiling, but two of these 3 could be good.

 

[Crowman32]

I dont think hamish will pick robertson, doesnt rate his kicking. Hope im wrong as i think the kid can seriously play.

 

[Mutineer]

What about this Sharp fella?

Ah I missed him very speedy and agile outside runner, good overhead but a somewhat inconsistent kick even though it's very penetrating, I'd slot him in after Rivers probably. Certainly a perceived list need.

 

[FAITH]

Big H totally misjudged what Swans were planning on doing.

Credit to the Swans.

Tough pill to swallow for H.

 

[ams4crows]

Bianco has crazy go home factor wouldn't go near him with a 10 ft pole

 

[Elite Crow]

Big H totally misjudged what Swans were planning on doing.

Credit to the Swans.

Tough pill to swallow for H.

Or you were full of it and we got the player we had wanted all along.

 

[Mutineer]

Big H totally misjudged what Swans were planning on doing.

Credit to the Swans.

Tough pill to swallow for H.

Bullshit. If he wanted Dylan Stephens so desperately he keeps pick 4.

 

[FAITH]

Or you were full of it and we got the player we had wanted all along.

The Crows box were almost in tears, didn't you see them?

Oh well. Good lesson for the boys.

We Finally got our Big Fish haha.

 

[latinoheat]

Elijah Taylor anyone? Or Tahney?

 

[FAITH]

Bullshit. If he wanted Dylan Stephens so desperately he keeps pick 4.

No one predicted Swans would take Stephens @5.

Thats why they're a great club. They pulled our pants down and got Hamish's boy.

 

[spexau]

The Crows box were almost in tears, didn't you see them?

Oh well. Good lesson for the boys.

We Finally got our Big Fish haha.

lol "in tears" .. hardly

 

[FR0GGY]

Is Gould at 192cm really 106kgs?

 

[Donkey Magoo]

No one predicted Swans would take Stephens @5.

Thats why they're a great club. They pulled our pants down and got Hamish's boy.

Yeah, I dunno about that, McAssey seemed pretty hot the last week or so.

 

[FR0GGY]

No one predicted Swans would take Stephens @5.

Thats why they're a great club. They pulled our pants down and got Hamish's boy.

Plenty brought it up on here as a possibility, don't tell me they (the crows) couldn't even think of that as a possibility.