Mega Thread 2019 List Management, Free Agency & Trade thread #2

[Hogwild]

See this is what shits me. Gws does a salary dump and hawks go “former no 1 pick who’s previously shown elite football ability before injuries”... I tell ya what ,future 4 ths best we can do and gws -“done”....
Do the pies understand the concept of a salary dump??

You don’t get to push him out and then start getting picky on the demands ffs.

But of course we’re not hawthorn and this is Collingwood we’re dealing with- the team that embodied the term “wins trade week”

Bell will play hard ball and they will fold - he knows that we hold all the aces here

 

[Taylor]

22 and 58 covers the Henry bid, that's all we needed and some late stuff to protect us if an academy kid we want gets bid on in the main draft.

They will pay a bid from #13 on wards. (assuming they bump down from a Green bid, potentially #58 not moving)

 

[freo_leo29]

22 and 58 covers the Henry bid, that's all we needed and some late stuff to protect us if an academy kid we want gets bid on in the main draft.

Does it cover all the way to 11?

Wonder what Aish will cost tho, maybe 51 gets it done and 58 doesn't

 

[FreoRicci]

Is it me, or the overrating of St Kilda's trade period is hilarious.

Dougal Howard- meh. He ll have to play CHF as they have none. Traded out Bruce.
Zak Jones- meh. Nothing different to what they already have now. Ross, Billings about the same
Ryder- cooked.
Hill- only elite player really.

No top 20 pick. First pick is Pick 32. Won't get King next year.
Very Vanilla

 

[apuchar]

They will pay a bid from #13 on wards. (assuming they bump down from a Green bid, potentially #58 not moving)

or going up. I assume other academy and f/s will eat up multiple lower range picks. Otherwise you are correct, we will need to draw from next years first. If that's how it works

 

[yakka man]

 

[SHill Shall]

Does it cover all the way to 11?

Yes - easily!

 

[Taylor]

#22 and #58 are 1003 points, a Green bid will push back our picks to be 973 points

A bid at #11 costs us 1063 points
A bid at #12 costs us 1014 points
A bid at #13 costs us 970 points

 

[Cheesewheel]

With Carlton stalling I wouldn't mind us giving the Jack Martin tree a shake.

 

[Purpellian Anchor]

Yes - easily!

how? I get it covering 12 but not 11 if there is no bid on Green. It is 20% discount right?

 

[apuchar]

Does it cover all the way to 11?

Wonder what Aish will cost tho, maybe 51 gets it done and 58 doesn't

I assume we will try and deal in future picks for Aish or trade back in something around that area if 58 goes. Bell knows what he is doing. It will be covered.

 

[Hogwild]

Good.....hold the line

 

[apuchar]

They will pay a bid from #13 on wards. (assuming they bump down from a Green bid, potentially #58 not moving)

Is it 20 or 25 % the discount. It said 25% on the pdf I got.

 

[G Mus]

Think Kanes right there, but of a list-cloggy approach

 

[silverscope]

Is it me, or the overrating of St Kilda's trade period is hilarious.

Dougal Howard- meh. He ll have to play CHF as they have none. Traded out Bruce.
Zak Jones- meh. Nothing different to what they already have now. Ross, Billings about the same
Ryder- cooked.
Hill- only elite player really.

No top 20 pick. First pick is Pick 32. Won't get King next year.
Very Vanilla

Pretty much what I said earlier their list was very Vanilla last year and adding those players doesn't push them into the top 4 challenging category. They'll still be around that 7-12 range at best.

 

[Taylor]

Is it 20 or 25 % the discount. It said 25% on the pdf I got.

Resource - 2019 AFL Draft Order

Every trade as it happens!

www.bigfooty.com

The spreadsheet here is very helpful

 

[wayToGo_]

Think Kanes right there, but of a list-cloggy approach

Agreeing with Kane Cornes? RUOK?

 

[apuchar]

Resource - 2019 AFL Draft Order

Every trade as it happens!

www.bigfooty.com

The spreadsheet here is very helpful

cheers

 

[ChimpaWompa]

Daniher not being traded apparently, big oof

 

[Alfonz]

Pretty much what I said earlier their list was very Vanilla last year and adding those players doesn't push them into the top 4 challenging category. They'll still be around that 7-12 range at best.

At best. I see them as 17th. Maybe 15th if Adelaide can't right the ship and North falter. But even those 2 sides I think are better than the Saints, and I think the rest of the lower teams have more upside than the Saints. I'm hoping that future 2nd rounder we have will be close to pick 20.

 

[pluggeranddoc]

32 AND 51 for Bruce. That's pathetic. Easy win by Bulldogs there

Unlike Freo they used a bit of Vaseline on us!

 

[apuchar]

Unlike Freo they used a bit of Vaseline on us!

Yeah. Horrible. Hopefully, it helps get you the other players you want

 

[Unique Name]

Unlike Freo they used a bit of Vaseline on us!

Brad Hill is a top 3 winger in the comp and you'll have him for another 5years+. Don't worry about the picks.

The Bruce deal is a shocker though IMO. I rate Bruce and think he's going to do bloody well at the Doggies.

 

[Freoforever86]

Would like Menadue still, looking unlikely but

 

[hoopdaloop]

Just quietly, we need to be hoping that Carlton give away pick 9 because in my opinion if they miss Papley they are a shoe in to bid on Henry