- Jun 16, 2012
- 25,870
- 27,254
- AFL Club
- Sydney
He’s still a much better player than hickey. Arguably be cheaper with less commitment
List Mgmt. 2020 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals
- Thread starter scaryness
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
He’s still a much better player than hickey. Arguably be cheaper with less commitment
- Oct 2, 2016
- 12,644
- 26,395
- AFL Club
- Sydney
McCartin
- Jun 16, 2012
- 25,870
- 27,254
- AFL Club
- Sydney
I’d do pick 3 for treloar
Draft Campbell and gulden
Play McLean and Sinclair in the ruck with both alternating as key forwards
Draft Campbell and gulden
Play McLean and Sinclair in the ruck with both alternating as key forwards
- Jun 16, 2012
- 25,870
- 27,254
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Especially if pies paying us 300k of his salary
- Oct 10, 2012
- 2,334
- 2,696
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Putting it out there, I want Holland if he is available we need that Dynamic player !!!
- Nov 11, 2012
- 36,743
- 43,430
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Hope so to
Disagree about Treloar. Would be useful for many clubs but isn't useful for where the Swans will be in 2021. Also pick 3 is wildly overvaluing Treloar considering Collingwood are desperate to get rid of him.
With the dispute on when our 'rebuild' started, I guess it depends on whether you think we need to finish outside of the 8 to officially be on a list rebuild. I tend to think along the lines of when we were / are bringing in players that we can see as part of our next flag push (and we're only going to know the outcome of that in hindsight). But, even forgetting that while we were still making finals, we were up there in putting the most debutants on the field (pretty sure we even led Brisbane for a while)...and ignoring that Heeney, Papley, Mills, Dawson, Melican, others came slightly earlier...
2016 - Florent (11), Hayward (21) - I give these two some slack. Florent might have had a more difficult year than most not being able to see family in Vic. Hayward coming off horrible injuries last year and being thrown around the ground. Even Fox from this year looks like he might be a dependable defender around in time for our next push.
2017 - Ling (14), McCartin (33). Whether Ling comes good is uncertain, but the potential and high-ish pick was there. The club were ecstatic when McCartin got through to our 2nd pick.
2018 - Blakey (10), Rowbottom (25), McInerney (44)
2019 - Stephens (5), Gould (26), Warner (39). It was pretty clear we rated Warner highly so I'm willing to wait before judgement. Gould similar, since he was highly rated and playing senior footy, probably slid a bit in the draft tbh.
Obviously it's not complete - for me, we need at least 1 more key forward or defender (with McCartin to play the opposite end), a serviceable ruck that can play the whole year and another inside mid (unless the club are supremely confident on Warner). We'll be able to satisfy at least 1 of those with pick 3, which we should definitely keep.
2016 - Florent (11), Hayward (21) - I give these two some slack. Florent might have had a more difficult year than most not being able to see family in Vic. Hayward coming off horrible injuries last year and being thrown around the ground. Even Fox from this year looks like he might be a dependable defender around in time for our next push.
2017 - Ling (14), McCartin (33). Whether Ling comes good is uncertain, but the potential and high-ish pick was there. The club were ecstatic when McCartin got through to our 2nd pick.
2018 - Blakey (10), Rowbottom (25), McInerney (44)
2019 - Stephens (5), Gould (26), Warner (39). It was pretty clear we rated Warner highly so I'm willing to wait before judgement. Gould similar, since he was highly rated and playing senior footy, probably slid a bit in the draft tbh.
Obviously it's not complete - for me, we need at least 1 more key forward or defender (with McCartin to play the opposite end), a serviceable ruck that can play the whole year and another inside mid (unless the club are supremely confident on Warner). We'll be able to satisfy at least 1 of those with pick 3, which we should definitely keep.
We wouldn’t need to give up Pick 3 given how apparently desperate the pies are to get him off their books. Regardless I dont think he wants to come back to sydney
- Oct 2, 2016
- 12,644
- 26,395
- AFL Club
- Sydney
We should have gone after Darcy Fort over Hickey
- Oct 10, 2012
- 2,334
- 2,696
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Agreed - Phillips better in short term. But i think Hollands can be the wild upside that only a few players possess.
Also see Paddlebum and Phillips as similar (when side by side with parker and Hewett) we need some extra speed, that Florent would have provided if he was the top tier talent we hoped for.
What's Dean Towers up to these days?
- Oct 10, 2012
- 2,334
- 2,696
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Craziest deal since Tom Boyd
Bobbyblackeyes
Debutant
- Oct 19, 2020
- 73
- 115
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Who has been the most successful player that people can remember that suffered an ACL prior to being drafted? Also how high did said player get drafted that year?
Thanks
Thanks
Personally think its crazier.
MarkP
That guy
And we all know how that worked out.
Won them a flag.
Should say I agree with you it is nuts.
MarkP
That guy
I am still trying to reconcile Daniher getting a top 10 pick for his deal but the Cameron one falls to 11 or 12 or whatever.
Numbers make no sense.
When system like that appear arbitrary then they are useless.
Numbers make no sense.
When system like that appear arbitrary then they are useless.
No way in the world am I paying that much for Zac Williams.
Think they overpaid to ensure they got support for Cripps to keep him happy and re-sign. If they fail to make finals again and Cripps leaves, Carlton are gonna be looking very silly.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll
