McInerney is worth some love too.
List Mgmt. 2020 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals
- Thread starter scaryness
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
yep, big future
- Banned
- #16,378
And a young list costs less dollars. It's also a consequence of investing in the talent we want to keep as marquee players.
Why NOT to draft ‘em, Swans board style:
Thiltthorpe: the spectre of 2m Peter, inbetweener & could lose years to OP.
Hollands: dodgy knees, half forward who doesn’t fill a need.
DGB: skinny & key defenders aren’t worthy of pick 3.
Phillips: will just go home to Vic after a few years anyway, not tall or fast enough.
Clearly, none of them are any good.
The only solution is evidently to reach for a speedy half-back flanker.
Thiltthorpe: the spectre of 2m Peter, inbetweener & could lose years to OP.
Hollands: dodgy knees, half forward who doesn’t fill a need.
DGB: skinny & key defenders aren’t worthy of pick 3.
Phillips: will just go home to Vic after a few years anyway, not tall or fast enough.
Clearly, none of them are any good.
The only solution is evidently to reach for a speedy half-back flanker.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
You leave out my number 1 wish!
SwansProudly
Moderator
- Sep 5, 2016
- 9,453
- 26,554
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Sydney Swans AFLW
- Moderator
- #16,382
Swans have parted ways with Elijah
www.sydneyswans.com.au
“It is obviously a sensitive situation and a legal process is still to play out, but in working with Elijah and his management, our collective view was that the right call for both Elijah and the club is to part ways. We have also consulted with the AFLPA and appreciate the support James Gallagher and his team has provided during the process.
“This has been an incredibly difficult situation for Elijah, his family, and those involved. We are keen to see Elijah receive ongoing education and support in the hope that he can mature and learn from this experience, make better decisions in the future, and take steps towards rebuilding his career.”
Sydney Swans Statement: Elijah Taylor
The Sydney Swans have parted ways with player Elijah Taylor.
“This has been an incredibly difficult situation for Elijah, his family, and those involved. We are keen to see Elijah receive ongoing education and support in the hope that he can mature and learn from this experience, make better decisions in the future, and take steps towards rebuilding his career.”
Chaisa
Brownlow Medallist
- Jun 2, 2013
- 15,003
- 14,898
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- The Exers
Yeah I still remain unconvinced.
Parker - will he still be around by the time we hope to start competing? Answer is probably but he has a lot of milage in his legs, I suspect in 3 years time he'll mostly be a forward by that point
Rowbottom - a star, but one swallow does not make a summer
Stephens - will he actually play on the ball? Still skinny and has mostly been a specialist winger at all levels, so it's hard to see him playing in the centre square long-term.
Campbell - yet to play, his skillset isn't really that of an inside mid either (excellent skills but not a great accumulator). Again like Stephens I don't think he's gonna be an onballer.
Hickey - not young, mostly been a B-grader throughout his career. Has to be upgraded if we're to go places.
Blakey - little exposure on the ball, IMO his best position is as a utility
Clarke - improving but if he's in our first choice onball combination we have problems. Still only feels like a depth player.
Florent - coming off an ordinary year, still quite a few significant weaknesses. Has to improve if he's going to be in our starting onball combination
Hewett - good defensive player, probably doesn't have enough attacking class to be a top-tier onballer though.
Naismith - can't stay fit. Decent when he's there but I think he's done.
Warner - decent hype and looks OK on the trading paddock but still a long way off it and I'm not sold he makes it.
So we've got 1 star onballer, an aging star onballer, a number of excellent utilities/outside types and the rest are B-grade types. It's clearly at least a midfielder short IMO.
Swans have parted ways with Elijah
“It is obviously a sensitive situation and a legal process is still to play out, but in working with Elijah and his management, our collective view was that the right call for both Elijah and the club is to part ways. We have also consulted with the AFLPA and appreciate the support James Gallagher and his team has provided during the process.Sydney Swans Statement: Elijah Taylor
The Sydney Swans have parted ways with player Elijah Taylor.
“This has been an incredibly difficult situation for Elijah, his family, and those involved. We are keen to see Elijah receive ongoing education and support in the hope that he can mature and learn from this experience, make better decisions in the future, and take steps towards rebuilding his career.”
They make it sound like it was a mutual decision to part ways, and Taylor wanted it just as much as the Swans. In reality we wanted him gone and basically fired him. Not that I am not pleased we fired him, but the business talk about collective view and the business talk associated with that is weird.
Swans coach comments on potential recruit Paddy McCartin
Will McCartin be on an AFL list in 2021?www.sen.com.au
Seems like we are about 95% to draft McCartin as a rookie.
- Apr 26, 2016
- 39,914
- 82,420
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Moderator
- #16,386
If I'm being honest looking ahead 4-5 years, I don't think any bar one will be full-time mids. They all have a few strings to their bow that will see them be played in other roles as well as on the ball.
And unlike some, I am not a fan of the idea of a rotating bevy of hybrid mids at our centre bounces.
- Apr 26, 2016
- 39,914
- 82,420
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Moderator
- #16,387
Pure wingman IMO so I don't consider him part of our midfield stocks.
- Apr 26, 2016
- 39,914
- 82,420
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Moderator
- #16,388
Because Gulden has the attributes that can be found at any stage of the draft - ticker, hardness, accumulation, endurance, pressure, work rate.
Campbell has the much rarer attributes that are generally only found in the very early stage of the draft - elite foot skills, line-breaking pace, poise and composure.
Gulden also has something that of recent times is something most of our draftees haven't had, and that is a natural instinct to find the ball. You can have all the talent in the world but if you are only getting 10 disposals a match you aren't going to be of much use as a midfielder.
Guys like Rohan, Stoddart and Ling are perfect examples. Very talented players who all don't or didn't get disposal numbers they probably should.
kickthething
Brownlow Medallist
I don't get this thinking, this then must apply to every bid that gets matched not just number 1. Are the draftees so insecure they cannot handle not being the first choice of a club...the whole draft is filled with players who are not the clubs first choice so why is it an issue at the first pick. If the 10k is a reason, then you are picking a player who is not so confident in their own ability to generate plenty more than that in years to come. Make no mistake, between themselves the boys know who the number 1 pick is.
This comes up so often it is simply ridiculous to have as a reason Adelaide would not pick JUH. They should definitely pick him as you never know, there just might be a reason the Dogs cant match the bid, very unlikely of course, however, they will be derelict in their duty to the footy club if they do not select the clear number 1 pick first. Put it on the Dogs to match, then go for Tilthorpe or McDonald or whoever....
- Apr 26, 2016
- 39,914
- 82,420
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Moderator
- #16,391
Yes. But the flip side of course is you get mids who have no trouble getting 30 possessions, but a fair portion of them don't achieve much with those possessions. I don't think that will be the case with Gulden, but you never know, and it's why I think Campbell has the greater upside. It will depend on how he is developed and played.
But I think they will both be 50/50 in terms of inside mid and other positions (small forward for Gulden, wing/flank for Campbell), so neither have to be prolific.
TheMase
Brownlow Medallist
Mmm that’ll bring the list back to 33 again, so up to 5 senior list spots available and 1 rookie... I think.
I can’t see how we will only take 3 now. I think we will trade back into this draft in some capacity whether it be top 10 or to grab someone like Neale (ruck) in the second-third round.
McCartin you’d think is fairly likely too.
I can’t see how we will only take 3 now. I think we will trade back into this draft in some capacity whether it be top 10 or to grab someone like Neale (ruck) in the second-third round.
McCartin you’d think is fairly likely too.
TheMase
Brownlow Medallist
Not at all weird. Pretty normal for a professional organisation like the Swans.
- Aug 9, 2016
- 5,081
- 6,316
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Swans have parted ways with Elijah
“It is obviously a sensitive situation and a legal process is still to play out, but in working with Elijah and his management, our collective view was that the right call for both Elijah and the club is to part ways. We have also consulted with the AFLPA and appreciate the support James Gallagher and his team has provided during the process.Sydney Swans Statement: Elijah Taylor
The Sydney Swans have parted ways with player Elijah Taylor.
“This has been an incredibly difficult situation for Elijah, his family, and those involved. We are keen to see Elijah receive ongoing education and support in the hope that he can mature and learn from this experience, make better decisions in the future, and take steps towards rebuilding his career.”
Thank goodness that has been laid to rest.
I wonder if Gulden will follow similar lines to a guy you actually compared him to recently, Dayne Zorko. Hadn't thought of that comparison but I think it might be on the money. Has the knack to play as a forward and good goal sense but in the end he's too valuable as a midfielder to go forward for much of his career. I don't think I'd write Gulden off from being a permanent midfielder.
kickthething
Brownlow Medallist
Collective view is code for we have this statement from our legal eagles to avoid any unfair dismissal claims issues going forward. Swans wanted him gone and liaised with the other parties to make it happen. Simple as that. Its how you need to work to remove even the most obvious of cases for dismissal these days.
- Apr 26, 2016
- 39,914
- 82,420
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Moderator
- #16,397
Can you not mention the possibility of us ending up with Neale please?
I talk shit a lot so I'm allowed to, but things you talk about often come to fruition, so now you're just getting my hopes up!
kickthething
Brownlow Medallist
For what was considered the most compromised draft in history, COVID has actually balanced the draft a bit imo. The late picks in this draft are going to be very interesting, I am sure clubs have smokies tucked away this year and there will be many surprises at the back end of this draft and commentary on the night around what can you tell us about him?? with quizzical looks on faces....
Even my smokie Flynn Maguire might be a show..!!
Chaisa
Brownlow Medallist
- Jun 2, 2013
- 15,003
- 14,898
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- The Exers
Judging by the statements the only way it doesn't happen is if we draft McDonald and/or he suffers a concussion within the next week.
- Apr 26, 2016
- 39,914
- 82,420
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Moderator
- #16,400
Fair call. I think it will be a reverse, in that he will prove far too valuable inside 50 to spend large chunks in the midfield. His goal sense, and most importantly his ability to set up and create scoring opportunities around goal is elite, and under-appreciated on this board. However if I think that about his forward craft, and you think that about his midfield craft, it's likely Horse will have the exact same conundrum. That's why I think he (and Campbell) will follow the Heeney, Dawson, Blakey route of being capable in too many roles and shifted around a lot.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll
