Teams 2021 Rate My Pre-Season Team

[WaynesWorld19]

Scores and rankings - Big Footy SC - 2021 Group - PLEASE JOIN NOW...Code is 157223

We have setup the Big Footy SC Group for 2021 This is open to every SC Campaigner to rank yourself against friends & foes .....to get bragging rights Either click here: https://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/afl/classic/?action=join-group&code=157223 or follow instructions below. Who will be the...

www.bigfooty.com

 

[Raveneyes]

View attachment 1033328


This is a team I quite like the balance of - if I do end up starting the really expensive players like Lloyd, Neale, Gawn and Macrae, who are absolutely elite but might be well overpriced if shorter quarters really benefited them.

On the other hand, taking too many mid-priced punts can be just as bad, so currently this is the team I have. I've tried to ensure I have the rookies folk like at this early stage but it's so early it's basically irrelevant.

Nice team!

One thing - Docherty had surgery removing a malignant tumour last month, so I don't know how much of his pre-season has been affected at this stage (if at all).
If so there's plenty of options at his price. Witherden, Doedee, May etc

 

[Eagling]

Nice team!

One thing - Docherty had surgery removing a malignant tumour last month, so I don't know how much of his pre-season has been affected at this stage (if at all).
If so there's plenty of options at his price. Witherden, Doedee, May etc

Yeah, I have considered Witherden but probably a year too early unless Hurn goes down. Hopefully Doc is okay but if not I did have Luke McDonald as a 4th defender with Preuss over Gawn, so if Doch isn't right I'd probably punt on McDonald. I'm hoping Doch recovers nicely and if he is fit, he has massive proven upside with the additional benefit that people might have been scared away by his whelming 2020.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Yeah, I have considered Witherden but probably a year too early unless Hurn goes down. Hopefully Doc is okay but if not I did have Luke McDonald as a 4th defender with Preuss over Gawn, so if Doch isn't right I'd probably punt on McDonald. I'm hoping Doch recovers nicely and if he is fit, he has massive proven upside with the additional benefit that people might have been scared away by his whelming 2020.

So who's going to be taking the kickouts for WCE this year, Hurn...Witherden...both?

 

[Gigantic]

v1.01



Pretty happy with this one atm.

Only premos I'm not too sure about at this point are Taranto and Heeney.

 

[Eagling]

So who's going to be taking the kickouts for WCE this year, Hurn...Witherden...both?

I'm not sure at the moment to be honest. I do think Witherden is going to be groomed to be Hurn's successor and has a lot of potential upside with our gamestyle and the dimensions of Optus giving Witho more space to work. If I had to guess, I'd say it'd probably be both.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Why not?

I think he is a trap and people will be trying to trade him out before the bye rounds.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Hurn goes down.

 

[Shinboner1]

v1.01

View attachment 1033342

Pretty happy with this one atm.

Only premos I'm not too sure about at this point are Taranto and Heeney.

I'd drop doedee/pruess for grundy and rookie and then you'd have set and forget from the start.

 

[balmainforever]

Gone mad here. Nothing over 500k

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Gone mad here. Nothing over 500k
View attachment 1033411

Finally a team with Hurn Dog in it.

You sir deserve all the puppies

 

[Shinboner1]

Gone mad here. Nothing over 500k
View attachment 1033411

Team looks ok and you'll score well early.
Even with some players going to premo status I dont think you'll get a full side before rd23.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Gone mad here. Nothing over 500k
View attachment 1033411

Perfect team to do roughy manouvers on.

Trade half out early when they are spudding up, trade them back in again when they start tonning up.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Gone mad here. Nothing over 500k
View attachment 1033411

Nice!

Ok here's my crack at a no rookies on-field team.

 

[Ingy]

Gone mad here. Nothing over 500k
View attachment 1033411

I don't think it's that mad.

In 2021 it will make more sense than G'n'R

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Nice!

Ok here's my crack at a no rookies on-field team.

View attachment 1033424

Just set and forget not a bad tactic

 

[DERIBERATE]

mid price madness mk I

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Nice!

Ok here's my crack at a no rookies on-field team.

View attachment 1033424

Hurn kicked more goals in the U17 championship than that bunch of injury faults will in all of 2021

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

OK so here is my team from earlier followed by a team no Gawndy.

You save 503k going down to NicNat and Prooose which upgraded Cunnington and Pedlar to Bont and Cripps.
NicNat averaged 30 less than Gawn and if Prooose averages 90 he drops 30 points to Grundy per week.
Bont and Cripps would average 60 more than Cunnington and Pedlar. You lose Pedlars cash gen but get some of it back on Prooose.
You still have to use two trades possibly more trying to get Gawndy in. But have two more midfield keepers.

Its almost a zero sum game.

Cant see Gawn averaging over 140 and if he averages 140 his price will come down maybe 50-70k.
One stinker from Gawn who has a great early draw and you win but gotta be ready to pounce.

All too hard. Set and forget. Im still going to play around with a few no Gawndy teams though in case theres a 2020 induced rookie shortage.





*Could also bring in Danger/Dunkley FWD instead of Bont and have one less FWD rookie

 

[Schulzenfest]

Personally I'm expecting I'll go with Grundy but not Gawn. Gawn's price is just ridiculous, Grundy on the other hand is arguably underpriced if anything.

 

[Ingy]

OK so here is my team from earlier followed by a team no Gawndy.

You save 503k going down to NicNat and Prooose which upgraded Cunnington and Pedlar to Bont and Cripps.
NicNat averaged 30 less than Gawn and if Prooose averages 90 he drops 30 points to Grundy per week.
Bont and Cripps would average 60 more than Cunnington and Pedlar. You lose Pedlars cash gen but get some of it back on Prooose.
You still have to use two trades possibly more trying to get Gawndy in. But have two more midfield keepers.

Its almost a zero sum game.

Cant see Gawn averaging over 140 and if he averages 140 his price will come down maybe 50-70k.
One stinker from Gawn who has a great early draw and you win but gotta be ready to pounce.

All too hard. Set and forget. Im still going to play around with a few no Gawndy teams though in case theres a 2020 induced rookie shortage.

View attachment 1033485



*Could also bring in Danger/Dunkley FWD instead of Bont and have one less FWD rookie
View attachment 1033486

That midfield in your second team is epic.

Hate to say it, but I think Nicnat is over-priced. 2020 was perfect for a guy who has a limited tank and sure enough he was the AA ruckman. With the return to 20 min quarters, his 50 min supply of go-go beans will not be enough. His average will fall I reckon

 

[Ingy]

Personally I'm expecting I'll go with Grundy but not Gawn. Gawn's price is just ridiculous, Grundy on the other hand is arguably underpriced if anything.

Relative to Gawn's, it is, relative to what he actually produced this year, it definitely isn't, relative to what you'd expect from him next year, it's about right IMO

 

[Shinboner1]

GAWN has basically playing nobodies for the first 6 rounds of the season.
He will dominate and throw up huge numbers.
Don't get caught out by not starting him; worth it just for the capt option.

 

[Mt Isa Mustang]

First look after 10 minutes review.
Lots of disgusting mid pricers. No Gawn, Lloyd or Neale..
70k in bank.

After 3 consecutive finishes in the top 500 happy to throw up something different this year.

 

[MagicGnome97]

Managed to come up with this after a proper session of teambuilding. Thoughts?

 

[Andrew Birch]

Managed to come up with this after a proper session of teambuilding. Thoughts?View attachment 1033637

Pros:
12 keepers
Most of the premo's coming off very good seasons
plenty of VC & C options

Cons:
Almost 30% of the cap on just 4 players is overkill.
Hately is too speculative a starting pick for mine and Preuss has a difficult early draw & unproven as a #1 ruck.
17 first year rookies being named for Rd1 is unlikely this year.