- Moderator
- #679
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Respect your opinion mate, but don’t speculate, state. What are the other factors? Or is it more media fluff. There’s knocks on a lot of kids. Flogging them silently on here isn’t fair.There are flight concerns with Phillipou, but with Hewett, it's other factors as to why he could slide
Respect your opinion mate, but don’t speculate, state. What are the other factors? Or is it more media fluff. There’s knocks on a lot of kids. Flogging them silently on here isn’t fair.
Exactly. Let’s move on mate.And discussing here isn’t respectful to Hewett
Exactly. Let’s move on mate.
What does the * mean? I'm very confused. Is it Essendon?Rumour from D&T Board that * have met with Philipou 3 times in the last week.
Not sure he's going to be lasting to #11.
I agree with the type of player you are describingNot sure we need x-factor.
What we need is a good kick of the football who has some pace and a decent tank, who is able insert themselves into the play and is not a defensive liability...maybe I’m describing x-factor here?
This is why I’m in the McKenzie camp.
Will he though?Looks like Hollands will be gone by our pick.
Question: would you use pick 10 on Simmo?Huge call incoming:
Oliver Hollands is a right footed clone of Kade Simpson.
Get.
Knowing the career he had there’s no doubt we would.Question: would you use pick 10 on Simmo?
Think getting Elijah to the club in a couple of years could be a factor.Does this mean we get his brother as well so it s a two for one deal ?
Phillipou has probably more chance of experiencing AFL games sooner with Carlton (due to his forward abilities) than another inside mid stuck at the end of the queue playing VFL behind Carroll, Dow, even Kemp? etc.There are flight concerns with Phillipou, but with Hewett, it's other factors as to why he could slide
Yes. * is shorter than typing 'scum'What does the * mean? I'm very confused. Is it Essendon?
no its *What does the * mean? I'm very confused. Is it Essendon?
Could someone compare Hollands to Camporeale in 1995
You don't really think that Hollands is just a winger do you?Adding the sixth or seventh best TAC midfielder isn’t going to drastically improve our transition game.
My observation was actually that Hollands minor point of difference at junior level is going to be obsolete.
Adding Acres and putting another pre-season into Carroll is enough for next season IMO. I’m sure I have asked the question before, but how often do specialist wingman get taken in the Top 10? Most actually get taken with later picks - Langdon, Hunter, Amon etc, or move to a purely outside role to fit team requirements eg Walsh, McCluggage, Brayshaw.
Nothing alike, Campo had better vision, composure and footskills
I’ve started looking more at the Hotton tape. Looks very handy and could play anywhere. Where do you see him fitting into the Carlton team?
From memory Campo was a but older when we drafted him (turned 20 in his first season) so you would be comparing him to Hollands at the end of 2023.Nothing alike, Campo had better vision, composure and footskills
Surely the concern is that at his listed 181cm height he will have limited marking ability against men?Hotton fits perfectly into our squad, dangerous as a marking forward or HHF and can rotate through the middle
Has Archie Perkin attributes, but can also play as a rebound defender
YepQuestion: would you use pick 10 on Simmo?