Yes but form changes, hence the “ongoing” clause.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Preview 2022 Rd 20 Carlton vs Adelaide Saturday July 30 7:30PM @ Adelaide Oval - Team Post #586
- Thread starter The Old Dark Navy's
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #1,302
drink a hot soy latte for every "could really have used sos today"..........
The local Crows fans are panicking at the prospect of TDK, Charlie and McKay; their backline is pretty shaky.
Also getting the vibe that O’Brien (theirs) is in a bit of a slump and the duo of TDK and Pittonet will give them plenty of grief.
Their midfield works hard but lack polish; Laird is probably the most damaging but is arguably a better HBF than midfielder.
Their forward line can be dangerous with their 3 talls, but it’s almost the wish.com version of our setup.
Mostly interested in how our new tall setup works (first time in a while we’ve had 3 genuine KP players in both defence and attack).
Will be in the Crows members tonight; Blues by 37. Curnow to kick 4. Durdin 3. Walsh BOG.
Also getting the vibe that O’Brien (theirs) is in a bit of a slump and the duo of TDK and Pittonet will give them plenty of grief.
Their midfield works hard but lack polish; Laird is probably the most damaging but is arguably a better HBF than midfielder.
Their forward line can be dangerous with their 3 talls, but it’s almost the wish.com version of our setup.
Mostly interested in how our new tall setup works (first time in a while we’ve had 3 genuine KP players in both defence and attack).
Will be in the Crows members tonight; Blues by 37. Curnow to kick 4. Durdin 3. Walsh BOG.
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #1,304
if you see someone in sandals getting booted out of the saca committee rooms, say g'day to numbers for me.........
Silvagni and Newnes in Adelaide, Dow and S.Durdin playing “ressies”
with a teaspoon of cement, shaken and not stirred
It does but Jack has sacrificed his own game for the greater part of the season playing as 2nd ruck, but would be surprised if he is not back next week.
Silvagnigate
GOLD!
- Sep 15, 2011
- 5,623
- 9,371
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Liverpool FC, Lakers, Longhorns
Asking a player to sacrifice his own game to play in another role (Jack in ruck) and then to tip him out when he’s not had a fair crack in his own role seems unfair to me.
Jack helps the connection between midfield & forward. One of the footy shows rated him top 3 across league behind Hawkins & Cameron for this. I think him being out will hurt our scoring. His not being in the forward line will lead to less defensive pressure in the F50.
Finally he is one of only two players IMO (the other being Walsh) who gives 100% every game.
That being said Pittonet had to come back in and I’m stumped if there is another role for Jack in the team with TDK staying in. Others he can perform but he hasn’t been in those roles so no opportunity to push out those in them.
Understandable move but leaves me feeling very flat. Especially after his On the Couch appearance.
Jack helps the connection between midfield & forward. One of the footy shows rated him top 3 across league behind Hawkins & Cameron for this. I think him being out will hurt our scoring. His not being in the forward line will lead to less defensive pressure in the F50.
Finally he is one of only two players IMO (the other being Walsh) who gives 100% every game.
That being said Pittonet had to come back in and I’m stumped if there is another role for Jack in the team with TDK staying in. Others he can perform but he hasn’t been in those roles so no opportunity to push out those in them.
Understandable move but leaves me feeling very flat. Especially after his On the Couch appearance.
- Jul 18, 2021
- 138
- 796
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
Carlton by 86
Yes please
You reckon that's bad, my relos in Italy rang me asking why Silvagni got dropped and they dont follow Aussie rules
- Nov 27, 2016
- 18,524
- 36,105
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #1,314
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #1,315
take it over greek coffee full of grit and god knows whatever unmentionables.........
- Moderator
- #1,316
- Mar 20, 2017
- 10,770
- 36,242
- AFL Club
- Carlton
But setterfield plays on a wing and Silvagni doesn't and never has. Hopefully never will. I shudder to imagine Silvagni chasing Langdon up and found a wing all day.
Setterfield is probably an inside mid who we have re-purposed as a winger. He either makes it there or he probably comes off our list. He's had a few goes but struggled, last week was the first time that he showed all of the things that we need him to show. Hoping that he can do it for a few weeks in a row and against good opposition. We desperately need him to.
Might be best to see what they bring and what we need from them in isolation.
Jack will be back no worries. If setterfield can really click we'll be a much better team.
racist
I do! Only cos its Greek mudI don't drink mud
- Sep 9, 2015
- 592
- 1,750
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Many ThanksView attachment 1460188
VFL Teams Rd19: Grundy heads gun list of inclusions
Magpie superstar to throw down challenge to angry Sharks as Blues, Giants and Bulldogs call in the cavalrywww.afl.com.au
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #1,321
my favourite cafe is shut today, staff took leave to support each other with regard to the silvagni omission........You reckon that's bad, my relos in Italy rang me asking why Silvagni got dropped and they dont follow Aussie rules
- Moderator
- #1,322
TDK is not a genuine key position. He is a ruckman now playing mostly forward. It’s worth a look but I believe our best combo will end up being tdk/silvagni
150 point win should see us move above the swans
Go Blues
Go Blues
morningbrown
Club Legend
- Mar 9, 2021
- 2,141
- 4,684
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Fate in our own hands with today's results. 6th place up for grabs. Get it done lads.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
