Half the games Acres showed he can play and the other half not so much.Acres was brought in to mitigate the loss of our two established wingers, and he's done that pretty well.
Can we upgrade that position? Sure can, and clearly it has been a key part of our list management strategy for the past few drafts.
My tip is that Acres gets another contract, but that's far from certain.
For me he's in the same basket as the likes of Hughes, Banfield, Colyer and others. They are AFL standard players with some significant flaws and limitations. Depth? Teasers? Scapegoats?
As you said he is ok as a depth player.
When Johnson gets fit, I would rather him over Acres.