Preview 2023 Elimination Final - Carlton vs Sydney Friday 8th Sept 7.50PM @ MCG

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Team is in …


IN: Patrick Cripps, Sam Docherty, Marc Pittonet
OUT: Paddy Dow, Corey Durdin, Zac Fisher, Ollie Hollands


After starting the last game as sub, Caleb Marchbank has been elevated into the starting 22.








Backs:Brodie KempJacob WeiteringNic Newman
Half-backs:Alex CincottaMitch McGovernAdam Saad
Centreline:Blake AcresPatrick CrippsSam Docherty
Half-forwards:Jack MartinHarry McKayDavid Cuningham
Forwards:Lachie FogartyCharlie CurnowMatthew Owies
Followers:Marc PittonetAdam CerraSam Walsh
Interchange:Matthew CottrellTom De KoningGeorge Hewett
Caleb Marchbank
Emergencies:Paddy DowZac FisherOllie Hollands
Jesse Motlop
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Baggers!!!

Where can we meet, and have a brew b4 it and have a Bagger March of the True Believers to the 'G'? Is it Y&J's? Perce's old pub in Flinders St? Somewhere in Richmond? Or maybe The Royal Oak and then en masse onto a tram down Nicho ? Maybe it's in Lygon, a little 'Lygon St Limbo'? I feel there needs to be a Call To Arms to all Baggers?????
 
Baggers!!!

Where can we meet, and have a brew b4 it and have a Bagger March of the True Believers to the 'G'? Is it Y&J's? Perce's old pub in Flinders St? Somewhere in Richmond? Or maybe The Royal Oak and then en masse onto a tram down Nicho ? Maybe it's in Lygon, a little 'Lygon St Limbo'? I feel there needs to be a Call To Arms to all Baggers?????
Save it for the real final. The grand.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

No Brother! Let's start it here, let's create a story for the ages, an 'I was there moment'. '99 was all about this, we just kept winning, OMG before you knew it we were in the Big Dance.....
Can feel it here....
Start it now, small, not noisy, but obvious. Build on it.
 
No Brother! Let's start it here, let's create a story for the ages, an 'I was there moment'. '99 was all about this, we just kept winning, OMG before you knew it we were in the Big Dance.....
Can feel it here....
Start it now, small, not noisy, but obvious. Build on it.
Ehh technically we actually didn't keep on winning. We got absolutely belted by Brisbane in the first final and because of the luck of the silly system and MCG commitments, west coast were forced to come down to play us in the second week.
 
Ehh technically we actually didn't keep on winning. We got absolutely belted by Brisbane in the first final and because of the luck of the silly system and MCG commitments, west coast were forced to come down to play us in the second week.
Who wants to ruin a good memory with facts? I was obviously talking about everything that happened AFTER the Brisbane debarcle.....
 
👏 ❤️

Same here. First ever final for my boys; and it’s been a couple decades since my last final.

Making the road trip down Thursday night. Can’t contain my excitement.
I’m really happy for you all I had three devices going got tickets for the whole family like you guys I was looking forward to a final with the boys forgot my Ticketek password as I usually use Face ID thing
I was devastated but we are going to put up streamers at home make it an event at home.
What a great moment and memories you will get we will get to final someday soon.
My Sons are proud at school I’m so happy for them and all the blues supporters.
This is what footy is about so glad our kids can finally revel in success and strut some bagger arrogance in the play ground
 
I’m really happy for you all I had three devices going got tickets for the whole family like you guys I was looking forward to a final with the boys forgot my Ticketek password as I usually use Face ID thing
I was devastated but we are going to put up streamers at home make it an event at home.
What a great moment and memories you will get we will get to final someday soon.
My Sons are proud at school I’m so happy for them and all the blues supporters.
This is what footy is about so glad our kids can finally revel in success and strut some bagger arrogance in the play ground
Sorry to hear you and the kids missed out. Feel for any Blues fan that couldn’t get a ticket. Chin up though - maybe get another opportunity the following week 🙂
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Is JSOS a chance to come back or is he still injured? Very excited for next Friday night.


Jack SilvagniKneeCleared of any significant damage to his knee.
A knee sprain will rule him out of at least Week 1 of finals: he has not suffered any further injury. (Update: 25 August
 
While I am concerned with Fisher's defensive strength, think these comments are a tad over the top

Most sides have an attacking HB, who is less defensive

You need to weigh up all players in the back 7 and while someone like Cincotta is there to primarily shut down an opponent and is stronger defensively, he does lose his opponent far too often

I think it's more of a toss up between Cincotta and Fisher, which will come down to the sum of all parts as a defensive 7

I have Cincotta just ahead based on the last outing, but have Fisher ahead over the last month

Saad Weitering Newman Kemp and McGovern are all locks - leaving max 2 defenders to be picked - one of which is likely to be Docherty at least as a rotation even of Doch plays some time on a wing. Leaves the choice of one defender out of : Cincotta/Boyd/Fisher

hmmm - tough call? not really.
 
Saad Weitering Newman Kemp and McGovern are all locks - leaving max 2 defenders to be picked - one of which is likely to be Docherty at least as a rotation even of Doch plays some time on a wing. Leaves the choice of one defender out of : Cincotta/Boyd/Fisher

hmmm - tough call? not really.

Really can't see Doc playing in the back 7 again, defensive mid would be the closest to that defensive line

Stated I would have Boyd in the side

So, toss up between Cincotta and Fisher

Cincotta, tougher, quicker, more negating than rebounding but gets lost at times way too easily

Fisher, lacks defensive strength, but a better reader and rebounder

Both have strengths and weaknesses, pick your poison
 
How do I get a couple tickets for game
Can you get than one seats per membership


 
Really can't see Doc playing in the back 7 again, defensive mid would be the closest to that defensive line

Stated I would have Boyd in the side

So, toss up between Cincotta and Fisher

Cincotta, tougher, quicker, more negating than rebounding but gets lost at times way too easily

Fisher, lacks defensive strength, but a better reader and rebounder

Both have strengths and weaknesses, pick your poison

Fair ratings - not sure Docherty wont play a mix of HBF and mid - for this coming game...

Also not sure Fisher is a better rebounder- I think players are given 'designated' roles - interesting to me that both Cincotta and Kemp ( along with Saad) have all beeen less prominent in running the ball forward since Boyd was suspended. I think the defensive rebound and multiple options in overlap and forward movement has gone backwards or not been as good as it was. Defensive structure and mix NQR - I woudl play Boyd and Cincotta if Docherty isnt playing at least a rotating role back there. Vos may have other ideas - no doubt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top