Ballarat Bob
All Australian
- Feb 5, 2020
- 698
- 1,280
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Hope Sheather gets up ok ...has been in the system was starting to show a bit.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
You'd have to think soTiming due to mid season draft?
Why notYou'd have to think so
May as well take the advantage we haveWhy not
The Mods made the decision to close the thread due endless speculation & theorising without any conclusion. It served no purpose until we have further comment from either the player himself or Sydney Swans.Ticky009 would make sense to unlock the Paddy thread. Weird you locked it tbh
Concur , it's not going to achieve anythingThe Mods made the decision to close the thread due endless speculation & theorising without any conclusion. It served no purpose until we have further comment from either the player himself or Sydney Swans.
Now that we have something I'll open up the thread again.
PLAYER | INJURY | ESTIMATED RETURN |
Luke Parker | Suspension | Round 14 |
Dane Rampe | Neck | 1-2 weeks |
Joel Amartey | Hamstring | 2-4 weeks |
Callum Mills | Calf | 2-4 weeks |
Matt Roberts | Knee | 4-6 weeks |
Logan McDonald | Ankle | 7 weeks |
Peter Ladhams | Ankle | TBC |
Tom McCartin | Concussion | TBC |
Marc Sheather | Foot | TBC |
Paddy McCartin | Concussion | Season |
Sam Reid | Hamstring | Season |
PLAYER | INJURY | ESTIMATED RETURN |
Dane Rampe | Neck | Test |
Luke Parker | Suspension | Round 14 |
Joel Amartey | Hamstring | 1-3 weeks |
Callum Mills | Calf | 1-3 weeks |
Matt Roberts | Knee | 3-5 weeks |
Logan McDonald | Ankle | 6 weeks |
Peter Ladhams | Ankle | TBC |
Tom McCartin | Concussion | TBC |
Marc Sheather | Foot | TBC |
Paddy McCartin | Concussion | Season |
Sam Reid | Hamstring | Season |
PLAYER | INJURY | ESTIMATED RETURN |
Nick Blakey | Toe | Test |
Callum Mills | Calf | 1-2 weeks |
Matt Roberts | Knee | 2-4 weeks |
Logan McDonald | Ankle | 3-5 weeks |
Peter Ladhams | Ankle | TBC |
Tom McCartin | Concussion | TBC |
Paddy McCartin | Concussion | Season |
Sam Reid | Hamstring | Season |
Marc Sheather | Foot | Season |
Paddy has to (retire). If not, the AFL should step in.The Tom McCartin situation is getting ridiculous. If he’s still got concussion from like 10 weeks ago, then he simply should not be playing AFL.
I know it’s not a popular view, but I’m starting to think we should be ruthless and get rid of both the brothers in the off season. Even better, they should take it out of the club’s hands and retire. It would be the right thing to do.
Paddy has to (retire). If not, the AFL should step in.
Tom is contracted until 2027. It could become a significant issue for the club if (and it’s only an if) he becomes inactive. Four years of a fairly highly paid player drawing from the salary cap, but not playing.
That’s obviously a worst case scenario. But one that does trouble me.
He didn't even get a knock. I suspect we are only getting some of the info. No certainty to play again imoThe Tom McCartin situation is getting ridiculous. If he’s still got concussion from like 10 weeks ago, then he simply should not be playing AFL.
I know it’s not a popular view, but I’m starting to think we should be ruthless and get rid of both the brothers in the off season. Even better, they should take it out of the club’s hands and retire. It would be the right thing to do.
I don't think anyone wants tom to retire but assuming he misses this week, that's 7 out of 14 games he's missed this year whilst experiencing concussion symptoms. It's not greatYou can't put the expectation on a 23 year old to retire and give up his livelihood...
If a "normal" person gets injured on the job you don't just pack it in and give up a paycheck.