List Mgmt. 2023 List Management thread

[Snuffaluphagus]

Mod notice after Mr Bob did a lot of annoying work in moving days of posts out of here. As we are heading into offseason, this thread is for 2023 list management only. Getting upset on previous trades can be taken to the vent thread. Lets keep this thread on track in the part of the year it's actually relevant

 

[ubiquitous226]

Yeah I’ve looked into this just now and I don’t think we will get one,
Two comparable deals in recent years were Luke Dunstan and Tim O Brien, both 2 year deals.
Both didn’t get any compo picks.
Sydney would need to be paying 31 yo Joel some serious money to trigger one

The only third round pick compensation examples I could find were Jake Kelly, Isaac Smith, Cam Ellis-Yolmen and Alex Fasolo.

Now that's interesting because Isaac Smith was 2 years for a 31 year old, but the rest were all 3 years and younger.

 

[Cobbler]

Sharp I like simply because he fills an immediate need. Is young. Has some mates on our side. If NOTHING else he’s going to create a contest for whoever else it is that may fit the wing position.

I’d like to see Stanley give it a massive shake this year. He moves like an AFL player.

Him and Sharp battling for a spot will be good. NOD needs to have a cracking preseason.

Wing spots up for grabs. If we genuinely think we’re a chance at the top 4 then perhaps we actually need to magnet shuffle and someone like Brayshaw moves to the thing and Brodie back into the middle

 

[freo_leo29]

The only third round pick compensation examples I could find were Jake Kelly, Isaac Smith, Cam Ellis-Yolmen and Alex Fasolo.

Now that's interesting because Isaac Smith was 2 years for a 31 year old, but the rest were all 3 years and younger.

Smith would've got special favour for being a 3x prem player I reckon


Surely we can talk up how hammer is a prem player

 

[freo_leo29]

As a collector we have to get sharp to help fill our 2019 draft collection, especially as we are losing 1 this year

 

[Ge3ks]

Brayshaw moves to the thing

...wing.

 

[Big Animal]

Sharp I like simply because he fills an immediate need. Is young. Has some mates on our side. If NOTHING else he’s going to create a contest for whoever else it is that may fit the wing position.

I’d like to see Stanley give it a massive shake this year. He moves like an AFL player.

Him and Sharp battling for a spot will be good. NOD needs to have a cracking preseason.

Wing spots up for grabs. If we genuinely think we’re a chance at the top 4 then perhaps we actually need to magnet shuffle and someone like Brayshaw moves to the wing and Brodie back into the middle

I'd like to see that. He can run all day and is great two way. Brodie would help us doing better at stoppages if Fyfe unavailable. It's not like we would be taking Brayshaw away from the ball. Just keep him an outside player which he is anyway when you have Fyfe, Brodie and Serong as options. Also an instant improve on Henry. Need to find space for Ras anyway. We didn't pick him top 10 to sit him on the sidelines for too long.

 

[greatgatsby]

We talk blithely about losing Hamling (and I agree we should have only offered him one year) but are we really confident the kid Davies will make it as an AFL player. Seems a long way off it at the moment.

 

[mike91]

Apparnetly Oliver's "attitude" is being questioned

 

[Purple Jesus]

We talk blithely about losing Hamling (and I agree we should have only offered him one year) but are we really confident the kid Davies will make it as an AFL player. Seems a long way off it at the moment.

Losing Hammer would be a massive mistake this year.

 

[ubiquitous226]

The only third round pick compensation examples I could find were Jake Kelly, Isaac Smith, Cam Ellis-Yolmen and Alex Fasolo.

Now that's interesting because Isaac Smith was 2 years for a 31 year old, but the rest were all 3 years and younger.

The best like for like are probably Nathan Brown, Tim O'Brien and Jarrad Waite who all got no compensation.

 

[The Feeder Club]

We talk blithely about losing Hamling (and I agree we should have only offered him one year) but are we really confident the kid Davies will make it as an AFL player. Seems a long way off it at the moment.

Draper is the left field one that could be anything but may be nothing

 

[Joao]

We talk blithely about losing Hamling (and I agree we should have only offered him one year) but are we really confident the kid Davies will make it as an AFL player. Seems a long way off it at the moment.

Not really, but there's a decent chance he could do a serviceable job if he has a good pre-season.

I have plenty of confidence that Ryan could do a job though.

 

[s_wd6]

Not really, but there's a decent chance he could do a serviceable job if he has a good pre-season.

I have plenty of confidence that Ryan could do a job though.

I have confidence in Ryan until I remember watching him vs JUH. That was painful.

 

[eastfreo75]

The Suns whole senior list is basically first and second round picks with a few academy players thrown in.

They can't be compared to other top five teams imo. Their depth of youth is insane on that list.

Gold Coast will need to open spots. Might be Sharp for free.

 

[Joao]

I have confidence in Ryan until I remember watching him vs JUH. That was painful.

Like any defender, there are good matchups and less good ones.

 

[Dayts]

Hammer out DGB in.
Moneyball play and local.

 

[Polo342]

Hammer out DGB in.
Moneyball play and local.

Would actually love this!!

 

[freo_leo29]

Denver would cost too much this year

Next year I'm all for it

 

[Ge3ks]

Losing Hammer would be a massive mistake this year.

We were between a rock and a hard place. It would have been reckless of the club to offer him 2-3 years like Sydney have.

If it weren't for Sydney losing one or both McCartins and North losing McKay and Logue, then Joel would not be in demand and likely would have been content with a year at Freo.

All up, we are only losing some depth. We have cover. The big loser here is Peel.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I'm not copping that no-compo rubbish. If someone is getting him to move across the country, we are getting some kind of compo for him. Sydney are throwing bucketloads of money around, they would be overpaying and the money required for him to chose North would be nutty I imagine

 

[Dockeroo]

I'm not copping that no-compo rubbish. If someone is getting him to move across the country, we are getting some kind of compo for him. Sydney are throwing bucketloads of money around, they would be overpaying and the money required for him to chose North would be nutty I imagine

The good thing is it will either be pick 45 or else nothing. That would be a useful selection after all the bidding is done

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

The good thing is it will either be pick 45 or else nothing. That would be a useful selection after all the bidding is done

Perfect pick to chuck in a live trade with a team as well to move up the order

 

[Dockeroo]

Losing Hammer would be a massive mistake this year.

We couldn’t have given him a 2 year deal. That would be insanity in our current list management position.

 

[freo1997]

We couldn’t have given him a 2 year deal. That would be insanity in our current list management position.

Which idiot signed Worner…

Crazy ****ing Belly for two more years.

Guy is a hack. So is Worner.

 

[Docker82]

Which idiot signed Worner…

Crazy ******* Belly for two more years.

Guy is a hack. So is Worner.

It's about not signing a 30 year old death player for two years. No club in the AFL would