Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

[theiaofseed]

Im struggling to reconcile this year vs last.

We excelled in the 22 draft whilst the incumbent players traded in didn’t excel.

This year we have targeted and trade in 4 players, each with a defined role and hold our first pick.

Our first pick this year must be an elite to mitigate the risk.

The fear is we are inheriting scraps at the expense of further improving through the draft.

FFS we lost a future third that's it.

 

[Bugs1977]

Not sure, but I hope the club looks at options to move one of the picks in the 40's to a F3rd. That way we hold a pick in all of the first 3 rounds.

Has to be the play and hopefully MM already has deal a set up

 

[Rocket72]

4, and our F1.

It’s the best offer on the table unless north offer 2 and 3/F1.

No way will they accept that without locking in Curtin, IMHO

 

[Hawks_Footy]

Hawks need to find a F3 if we want to offer the Eagles 4 + F1.. with picks 44 & 47 in this draft we should be able to pull it off with a side pushing for top 4 next year

 

[derp de derp]

FFS we lost a future third that's it.

I’m absolutely stoked with how today played out.

 

[Rocket72]

If NM doesn’t offer 2 of 2-3-F1, then our 4+F1 is the best offer on the table.

Can’t see that getting it done

 

[tommyk72]

D+


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[tommyk72]

Soft touch Hawks.

I suppose pick 61 may be useless for us, but losing a F4 is frustrating.

Isn’t a future fourth probably equivalent to pick 55+?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[Ned Ryerson]

View attachment 1834835

THIS CLUB IS STUFFED!



(naaaah, not really)

Mind you it’s the best club in the world, mate!

 

[theiaofseed]

I’m absolutely stoked with how today played out.

"The fear is we are inheriting scraps at the expense of further improving through the draft"

Why mention this, youre not rebuilding a side by using a third round pick.

 

[The Seaword]

After 3 picks being inserted by Suns(3), the picks come in 3 steps. Croft bid should move the last 2 picks by 4 spots. So yes it will gain some point but not so much.

We have total of 3244 points and pick 4 is 1034 points, which means we have 1200 points to match bid. This is enouhh to match bids from pick 9(1469 Pts) onwards, given we will have 20% discount.
Since picks will move up we should gain another 200 points, so enough for bids on Dear as well.

PS : we can't trade for pick 1 given we don't have F3 & f4 and need special permission from AFL HQ

Port Adelaide’s first pick is 73

 

[eldorado]

At the very least, I much prefer Massimo to Bramble

Chol over Kosi? Marginally so...

Pity to lose Ryan, but we're at the stage where we need to start getting games into Ramsden.

Lose Brocky, so Ginnivan makes sense

Gunners purely for the romance, and the guidance with Ramsden, DGB.

Kept 1st round pick this year and next


I'm reasonably happy.

Solid B

 

[Bugs1977]

hes 33 in a month. doesn't mean he isn't a champion.. just age catches up to all.

Rumour has it that Breust's career games played will be extended by how many times there's been trade proposal about him. At that rate he'll be playing with Will Day's grandkids.

 

[eldorado]

Mind you it’s the best club in the world, mate!

You know Mark McKenzie, yeah? LEG-END!

 

[VandoHawk]

The fear is we are inheriting scraps at the expense of further improving through the draft

Yes at the expense of checks notes Pick 33...which would have been eaten by a McCabe bid anyway.

We kept Pick 4, will bring in another late first with McCabe alongside picking up the 'scraps' which include 3 players who have previously kicked 40+ goals in a season.

 

[Adrian Dodoro]

surely we are all just living in sleepy mark's dream

 

[DrkNyt]

Anyone else have a good feeling about getting Harley Reid?

 

[Scrads]

For everyone saying we need to find an F3 from somewhere... That could come back to us in the deal from WC. I think the best offer we can physically make is:

Pick 4 + F1 + Pick 47 for Pick 1 + F3 + 58

EDIT: can't give them back Pick 44!

 

[Billyc]

Anyone else have a good feeling about getting Harley Reid?

No. The beggars have too many gifts

 

[VandoHawk]

Anyone else have a good feeling about getting Harley Reid?

With what assets lol?

If they knocked back 4 + F1 + Brocky I'm not quite sure subtracting Brockman from that deal makes it more enticing.

 

[MasterSamurai]

Not worried about next year's draft hand. Could easily trade out certain players to acquire back second and third round picks. In fact, I'm sure, that's what'll happen.

 

[FB19]

FFS we lost a future third that's it.

Excuse me…what about the almighty f4???

 

[Ned Ryerson]

Yes at the expense of checks notes Pick 33...which would have been eaten by a McCabe bid anyway.

We kept Pick 4, will bring in another late first with McCabe alongside picking up the 'scraps' which include 3 players who have previously kicked 40+ goals in a season.

 

[Judd2Sewell]

Isn’t a future fourth probably equivalent to pick 55+?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

SYL revealed that North had a 3 year deal ready for Massimo, so I don't think getting him for nothing was a possibility in the end.

In hindsight it's not a bad deal if the above is true. Pick 61 this year may have been redundant for us anyway.

Personally I don't see "it" with Massimo, but he's probably an upgrade on Bramble so at the least we've improved our depth.

 

[FB19]

Port Adelaide’s first pick is 73

Don’t laugh if our first pick in 2016 was 73 we would have Nick Larkey instead of Harry Morrison and Lewis at 76. Now that would have been picking the eyes out of it!