Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

[smish]

The latter is being discussed but I am not sure that price can be agreed upon and how, if at all, it might affect a potential bundle.

Bundle?!

 

[Topiary]

Wouldn’t he cost too much? I recall Carlton talking their first a few years back. That aside papley in 1 pocket and the wizard in the other. That would be truly something.

It ain’t going to happen. Sydney would want two first rounders or at least one and a second.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Freo have sent a reminder to all list managers about the wisdom of trading your future 1st. I'd consider it but god it's a risk. Every chance it ends up as pick 4-6. I had assumed we would trade it for another first round pick this year.

“The lesson is never try”

 

[PenAndPaper]

Unless they want him off their books so they can grab Harry McKay, trade there that helps all parties.

Sydney grab two mature bookends, Amarty + McKay and McCartin+ Barras would be pretty handy KP stocks.

Hawthorn trade our Future First for Papely
Sydney trade McDonald and Papely for McKay and Barras
Carlton trade McKay for Hawthorn's Future First and Swans pick 6.
West Coast trade Barras for McDonald

Thell be getting buddy off their books and probably Rampe. They have no need to get Papley off the books.

 

[Steven Tyler]

Thell be getting buddy off their books and probably Rampe. They have no need to get Papley off the books.

Rampe re-signed till end of 2025

 

[westhawk]

If we're dealing in future 1sts, I'd rather Bailey Smith than Papley.

Would trade next years first for Smith in a heartbeat.

 

[user33]

Papley to Hawthorn is not happening, I know this is a hypothetical thread but there’s no realm of realism in that ever happening.

 

[user33]

Sam Edmund reporting that north would take mckercher and Curtin if they got a McKay compo pick at 3.

They would have to take a KPP at 3 because o'sullivan and the Sandy kid won't be there at the port pick most likely.

If this happens we are choosing between the wiz and duursma. I'm taking the wiz

Have it on decent authority that North won’t pass on Watson if they have two top picks. You can lock Colby to North now.

 

[Beandip]

If I'm looking for a detestable small forward, I'd prefer to focus on Ginnivan than Papley. Not sure why he's not playing at the moment and the whole ducking into tackles thing was a bit sour (though Moore does just as good a job of it) - but he is/was(?) a natural footballer with great goal sense.

 

[hawkinoz]

Freo have sent a reminder to all list managers about the wisdom of trading your future 1st. I'd consider it but god it's a risk. Every chance it ends up as pick 4-6. I had assumed we would trade it for another first round pick this year.

Freo were expected to make finals. We are expected to be out, even bottom 4, hence our F1 has high value. We need to drive that point to get picks that are equivalent to say a pick 5 in this year.

So our f1 should be equal to Blues 10 and their F1 + some change, that should be our starting point in negotiations.

Current draft pick order

 

[TylerDurden]

Have it on decent authority that North won’t pass on Watson if they have two top picks. You can lock Colby to North now.

Heard Clarko loves the Wizard.

 

[PenAndPaper]

Rampe re-signed till end of 2025

That is insane list management

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Have it on decent authority that North won’t pass on Watson if they have two top picks. You can lock Colby to North now.

Classic North.

They have no one to partner Larkey, will lose McKay to FA, and will take two small mids if they get the chance.

Watch them put their hands out for another priority pick next year.

 

[Topiary]

If I'm looking for a detestable small forward, I'd prefer to focus on Ginnivan than Papley. Not sure why he's not playing at the moment and the whole ducking into tackles thing was a bit sour (though Moore does just as good a job of it) - but he is/was(?) a natural footballer with great goal sense.

No.

 

[Sixpence]

Classic North.

They have no one to partner Larkey, will lose McKay to FA, and will take two small mids if they get the chance.

Watch them put their hands out for another priority pick next year.

They should get a priority pick this year, next year and the year after. Need them to be an AFL level team by the time they move to Tasmania.

 

[Hawkspot]

Classic North.

They have no one to partner Larkey, will lose McKay to FA, and will take two small mids if they get the chance.

Watch them put their hands out for another priority pick next year.

Why improve when you can just continue to be rewarded for being terrible?

They are a blight on the league, but they’ll be gifted so many top picks and compensation that they’ll inevitably be good. When they have a great team in 7 years everyone will bang on about their miraculous rebuild and ignore it though.

 

[killerspud]

Unless they want him off their books so they can grab Harry McKay, trade there that helps all parties.

Sydney grab two mature bookends, Amarty + McKay and McCartin+ Barras would be pretty handy KP stocks.

Hawthorn trade our Future First for Papely
Sydney trade McDonald and Papely for McKay and Barras
Carlton trade McKay for Hawthorn's Future First and Swans pick 6.
West Coast trade Barras for McDonald

sure why not - Chemist Warehouse have got a sale on lube

 

[A1fromDay1]

Classic North.

They have no one to partner Larkey, will lose McKay to FA, and will take two small mids if they get the chance.

Watch them put their hands out for another priority pick next year.

From the Herald Sun today

Along with Sanders, the club’s recruiting boss Brady Rawlings admitted the Roos were keen to bolster their key position stocks as well.

“We certainly need to look at that key defensive position,” Rawlings said on a club video.

“We are well aware we haven’t picked very tall over recent seasons.”

Given those comments there's noway they can select both McKercher & Watson with Curtin available

 

[TylerDurden]

From the Herald Sun today

Along with Sanders, the club’s recruiting boss Brady Rawlings admitted the Roos were keen to bolster their key position stocks as well.

“We certainly need to look at that key defensive position,” Rawlings said on a club video.

“We are well aware we haven’t picked very tall over recent seasons.”

Given those comments there's noway they can select both McKercher & Watson with Curtin available

It's BS. They're trying to spook WCE into not dealing with us on Reid.

 

[TheFourPillars]

From the Herald Sun today

Along with Sanders, the club’s recruiting boss Brady Rawlings admitted the Roos were keen to bolster their key position stocks as well.

“We certainly need to look at that key defensive position,” Rawlings said on a club video.

“We are well aware we haven’t picked very tall over recent seasons.”

Given those comments there's noway they can select both McKercher & Watson with Curtin available

That is so they get Reid force WCE to pick curtin

 

[hfc70]

Heard Clarko loves the Wizard.

Clarko love players shorter than himself

 

[danielG]

Classic North.

They have no one to partner Larkey, will lose McKay to FA, and will take two small mids if they get the chance.

Watch them put their hands out for another priority pick next year.

Why.. they can ship Zurhaar off as a Free Agent next year and wait for band one compo and another 2 x top 5 picks!! They’ve clocked the system!!
It’s vomit material really.

 

[Brant]

Why.. they can ship Zurhaar off as a Free Agent and wait for band one compo and another top 5 pick!! They’ve clocked the system!!

Sure have.
If only they could win games of football, they'd be a very successful football team.

 

[chopflop]

If we can't get wiz or mckercher, I would be making the move for pick 1

 

[HolyRioli]

Freo have sent a reminder to all list managers about the wisdom of trading your future 1st. I'd consider it but god it's a risk. Every chance it ends up as pick 4-6. I had assumed we would trade it for another first round pick this year.

The difference here is that Freo would've been projecting to at least match last years performance, and priced their future first pick accordingly (say pick 10+). Whereas I feel we'd be pricing our future first in 3-8 range, meaning it carries higher value. So in that regard, we're a little more risk aware of what we'd be giving up.