2023 Trade Time Talk - Henley Beach Café Returns

[FR0GGY]

Lots of coulds, woulds and maybe’s..

can we wait till 2025 before we finally get that talented young mid in?.. who will then take 2 to 3 years before he starts hitting his straps?..

There’s more coulds, woulds and maybes with him projecting above our f1 is there not?

 

[Bearded Clam]

There’s more coulds, woulds and maybes with him projecting above our f1 is there not?

Who? tyler?..

are you suggesting we may end up coming bottom 3 next year?..

The last 2024 draft predictor that came out a couple of weeks back had him at pick 3..

Yes… lots and lots of water to go under the bridge still.. he definitely could slide..

but what if he comes out all guns blazing next season and becomes a clear number 1?..

as I said.. we just dont fxxkn know.. which makes shifting picks from this year into next year fraught with danger.. we could end up simply having to shift them again next year.. thus kicking the can further down the road.

 

[FR0GGY]

Who? tyler?..

are you suggesting we may end up coming bottom 3 next year?..

The last 2024 draft predictor that came out a couple of weeks back had him at pick 3..

Yes… lots and lots of water to go under the bridge still.. he definitely could slide..

but what if he comes out all guns blazing next season and becomes a clear number 1?..

as I said.. we just dont fxxkn know.. which makes shifting picks from this year into next year fraught with danger.. we could end up simply having to shift them again next year.. thus kicking the can further down the road.

Well given we aren’t going to pick up early mid next year nor this year we’re kinda stuffed. Can’t see us outbidding bulldogs and from what I’ve read it’s a bit average after 5/6?

 

[MRB37]

Haynes would be great back up if we got a Bowes like deal out of it.

Problem partly is supposedly Haynes has said be wants a 2 year extension to 2026 if he's to agree to any trade.

 

[crow2crow]

Problem partly is supposedly Haynes has said be wants a 2 year extension to 2026 if he's to agree to any trade.

not happening

 

[fuic08]

Problem partly is supposedly Haynes has said be wants a 2 year extension to 2026 if he's to agree to any trade.

Yeah maybe of the 2nd year is for 100k

 

[MRB37]

not happening

Exactly. I don't think any team would do that, which is gonna make it tough for GWS to move him if it's true.

 

[ams4crows]

If pick 15 came with Haynes and 60% salary you'd think about it at least

 

[Sanders]

If pick 15 came with Haynes and 60% salary you'd think about it at least

Yeah but he wouldn’t.

What’s in it for him? He’s not going to move to be an unwanted rental somewhere

 

[Crow till I die]

Then move on quickly I'd hope.

I am guessing north are thinking draft pick

 

[Mostyn]

Seriously?

Haynes is completely cooked.

Haynes is not a key position player.

Why take him on for a pick & clog our list when we have plenty of picks, but need ready to go players.

We are better off spending our cap space on decent players not completely cooked ones... or front loading current young player contracts if we can't land anyone.

He only has one year left on his deal.

I can't imagine them giving up pick 15 so that someone takes it, but to get a decent pick for one year of a bad deal would be good business.

Who cares what he offers as a player. This would just be buying a pick, which I'm fine with.

 

[Mostyn]

We have a shortage of list spots & a plethora of picks, so this strategy is crazy for our position.

We don't have a shortage of list spots.

We've already opened up a few spots, and can still move players out (Sholl) and players onto the rookie list (Hamill).

 

[Mostyn]

I know this has been posted, but if you go to their feed they've gotten pretty much everything right so far.

 

[Sanders]

I know this has been posted, but if you go to their feed they've gotten pretty much everything right so far.

He’s not just right, he’s been first too

Presumably he works for one of the big agencies

 

[Bearded Clam]

I know this has been posted, but if you go to their feed they've gotten pretty much everything right so far.

So basically..

If they have gotten “pretty much everything right so far”..

Then we arent getting Phillipou!..

Casue thats what they are saying in that tweet.

 

[George Kramer]

I am guessing north are thinking draft pick

I hope you’re not bumping your own troll fake trade account?

 

[Crow till I die]

I hope you’re not bumping your own troll fake trade account?

Self praise is the best praise.

 

[Mostyn]

He’s not just right, he’s been first too

Presumably he works for one of the big agencies

Yeah, feels like the PA at one of the management groups.

 

[baldandbroke]

I hope you’re not bumping your own troll fake trade account?

He’s not just right, he’s been first too

Presumably he works for one of the big agencies

My instant thought as soon as someone says a Twitter account has cred!!

 

[footy4ever]

2021 - Dawson

2022 - Rankin

2023 - Burgess?

 

[1990crow]

Now be honest, how much of Burgess have you actually watched?

Because he's a fair bit better than the emoticon you've used there especially with the veratility to play multiple roles.

Come on. He has been a reserves player for 2 years.
Could he do a role? Sure.
Will he be a factor in us improving?

Probably not.

 

[1990crow]

The proof of the pudding will be in the eating, he's an excellent pick up at what will be a very cheap pick up with the versatility he offers up.

Like I said. Could play a role.
Losing Doedee, Murray most of the year ACL, losing McAdam.

Only Burgess in so far.

Whilst I think some of our youth should improve, I don't necessarily think it will translate into guaranteed top 8.

 

[Danger in Texas]

The proof of the pudding will be in the eating, he's an excellent pick up at what will be a very cheap pick up with the versatility he offers up.

Excellent is overblowing it a bit

For sure a good, smart pickup given we need an experienced depth tall, but like 1990 said, it’s not necessarily moving the needle

 

[dogs105]

Opinions be like ..............

Yep. It's interesting to look back when Jordan Dawson was first mentioned. A few loved him, but a lot were "meh".

 

[footy4ever]

Now be honest, how much of Burgess have you actually watched?

Because he's a fair bit better than the emoticon you've used there especially with the veratility to play multiple roles.

But still couldn't get a spot in a team that was 4th from the bottom. I reckon the emoji is spot on.