List Mgmt. 2024 AFL Draft - November 20-21 (Picks 13, 29, 36, 50, 94, 112, 130)

[Ford Fairlane]

Thanks to Lore for this great resource

 

[PortAdelFC1997]

I am sold on Gerreyn too after watching a few more of his videos. I know it’s only wafl colts but he reminds me so much of Brendan Lade. Big and strong, solid skills, good contested mark and deft touch with his ruck work. Will fill out into a massive guy in time looking at him. He is the forward/second ruck we need to complement our more mobile athletic types in Georgiades, Marshall and lukosious.

Is he a better kick than Lord?

 

[Addy23]

Is he a better kick than Lord?

Yes

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Never mind Lord, if people said he is a better kick than Lade, I would pick him on principle.

 

[Macca19]

Hi Macca. Are you going to drop your mock draft or draft list on here?

I’ll put a rankings once i’m comfortable with it. Still have a bunch of players to look at more closely

 

[Brian McGee]

Yes

Looks heaps more mobile around the ground too.

 

[HinkleysHeroes]

Yes

Then the first things I noticed was a mark in front of goal with the kick on goal not shown after the mark. Then in the GF his first mark forward followed by a kick that went Oof.

 

[Addy23]

Then the first things I noticed was a mark in front of goal with the kick on goal not shown after the mark. Then in the GF his first mark forward followed by a kick that went Oof.

I think what gets missed out is that he's played a lot of ruck time too this year. I think if we train/develop him as a pure forward there's a large upside. I've said it for ages that we need a goal kicking coach like Schulz. The lack of one is not a reason to pick someone like Gerryne.

 

[Haggas]

Based on rankings and how it could fall this is how I'm hoping it turns out for us.
16. Lindsay winger that can play multiple positions.
32. Davis would love for him to fall to us big body that can play multiple positions also.
38. Gerreyn ruck that can play forward.
45. likely after bids we move forward and take Nicholls SA Key forward/Defender

1	Richmond	Finn O'Sullivan
2	Brisbane (F/S)	Levi Ashcroft
3	North Melbourne	Harvey Langford
4	Carlton (WC)	Sam Lalor
5	Adelaide	Sid Draper
6	Melbourne	Jagga Smith
7	Richmond (GC)	Josh Smillie
8	St.Kilda	Murphy Reid
9	St.Kilda (Compensation)	Alixzander Tauru
10	Melbourne (Ess)	Harry Armstrong
11	Richmond (Frem)	Tobie Travaglia
12	Richmond (Coll)	Luke Trainor
13	Gold Coast (Academy)	Leonardo Lombard
14	Essendon (NGA)	Isaac Kako
15	West Coast (Carl)	Bo Allan
16	Port Adelaide (WB)	Xavier Lindsay
17	Fremantle (Haw)	Joe Berry
18	GWS Giants	Taj Hotton
19	GWS Giants (Compensation)	Jobe Shanahan
20	W.Bulldogs (Geel)	Jack Whitlock
21	Richmond (PA)	Cooper Hynes
22	Brisbane (Academy)	Samuel Marshall
23	Sydney	Matt Whitlock
24	Richmond (Bris)	Jonty Faull
25	GWS Giants (Compensation)	Jesse Dattoli
26	Sydney (NM Priority)	Harrison Oliver
27	Richmond (NM Priority)	Tom Gross
28	Richmond	Oliver Hannaford
29	W.Bulldogs (NM)	Alex Dodson
30	West Coast	Christian Moraes
31	Carlton (F/S)	Ben Camporeale
32	Port Adelaide (GC)	Hamish Davis
33	Fremantle (St.K)	Noah Mraz
34	St.Kilda (Frem)	James Barrat
35	Hawthorn (Coll)	Jack Ough
36	GWS Giants (Academy)	Logan Smith
37	W.Bulldogs	Lachie Jaques
38	Port Adelaide (Haw)	Kayle Gerreyn
39	Essendon (Syd)	Harry O'Farrell
40	Sydney (NM)	Angus Clarke
41	Geelong (WC)	Thomas Sims
42	St.Kilda (NGA)	Adrian Cole
43	Essendon (Adel)	Joshua Dolan
44	W.Bulldogs (GC)	Xavier Ivisic
45	Port Adelaide (Ess)	Charlie Nicholls
46	Collingwood	Nathan Sulzberger
47	Carlton (F/S)	Lucas Camporeale
48	West Coast (NGA)	Malakai Champion
49	Adelaide (F/S)	Tyler Welsh
50	Collingwood (Haw)	Archer Day-Wicks

 

[Rash]

Here is my Mock Draft for the first 20 (Live Trading included):

1. Sam Lalor- Richmond
2. Levi Ashcroft- Brisbane
3. Finn O'sullivan- Richmond
4. Sidd Draper- Carlton
5. Harvey Langford- Adelaide
6. Jagga Smith- Melbourne
7. Alixzander Tauru- North Melbourne
8. Leonardo Lombard- Gold Coast
9. Issac Kako- Essendon
10. Josh Smillie- St Kilda
11. Murphy Reid- Stkilda
12. Harry Armstrong- Melbourne
13. Tobbie Travaglia- Richmond
14. Luke Trainor- North Melbourne
15. Bo Allan-West Coast
16. Taj Hotton- Port Adelaide
17. Joe Berry- Fremantle
18. Xavier Lindsay- GWS
19. Sam Marshall- Brisbane
20. Cooper Hynes- GWS

 

[Port2Power]

So far we have 6 list spots available (5 main + 1 rookie)

The first 4 picks will be used on whatever the club needs.

But the 5th pick is what Im more curious about. Pick 94 will be moving up to around the 60s after bid matching etc.

If no one bids on Benny Barrett (possibility) Im hopeful we get him as a Cat B.

Use the 60s pick (5th pick) on Rome Burgoyne and take the remaining rookie spot into rookie draft to get maybe SA locals Jay Polkinghorne or Charlie West (highly unlikely he'll be there) or Louie Montgomery F/S

So in the end we would have 7 new draftees rather than 6 in a strong and deep draft.

5 on the main list + Cat A rookie (best talent) + Cat B rookie (Barrett)

 

[Haggas]

So far we have 6 list spots available (5 main + 1 rookie)

The first 4 picks will be used on whatever the club needs.

But the 5th pick is what Im more curious about. Pick 94 will be moving up to around the 60s after bid matching etc.

If no one bids on Benny Barrett (possibility) Im hopeful we get him as a Cat B.

Use the 60s pick (5th pick) on Rome Burgoyne and take the remaining rookie spot into rookie draft to get maybe SA locals Jay Polkinghorne or Charlie West (highly unlikely he'll be there) or Louie Montgomery F/S

So in the end we would have 7 new draftees rather than 6 in a strong and deep draft.

5 on the main list + Cat A rookie (best talent) + Cat B rookie (Barrett)

Pretty likely all 3 won't get bid on

 

[PortAdelFC1997]

15. Bo Allan-West Coast

Surely West Coast has other needs besides him?

I won't stand for this if they select Allan. WC will pay if they draft the kid.

 

[Haggas]

PortAdelFC1997

Surely West Coast has other needs besides him?

I won't stand for this if they select Allan. WC will pay if they draft the kid.

Elaborate?

 

[Haggas]

Surely West Coast has other needs besides him?

I won't stand for this if they select Allan. WC will pay if they draft the kid.

Also why do you care so much about who West Coast take?

 

[PortAdelFC1997]

PortAdelFC1997

Elaborate?

I like Bo Allan and therefore don't want any other team to draft him before our pick.

 

[Haggas]

I like Bo Allan and therefore don't want any other team to draft him before our pick.

WC need everything haha. I think Lindsay or Hotton will be just as good

 

[Rash]

Based on rankings and how it could fall this is how I'm hoping it turns out for us.
16. Lindsay winger that can play multiple positions.
32. Davis would love for him to fall to us big body that can play multiple positions also.
38. Gerreyn ruck that can play forward.
45. likely after bids we move forward and take Nicholls SA Key forward/Defender

1	Richmond	Finn O'Sullivan
2	Brisbane (F/S)	Levi Ashcroft
3	North Melbourne	Harvey Langford
4	Carlton (WC)	Sam Lalor
5	Adelaide	Sid Draper
6	Melbourne	Jagga Smith
7	Richmond (GC)	Josh Smillie
8	St.Kilda	Murphy Reid
9	St.Kilda (Compensation)	Alixzander Tauru
10	Melbourne (Ess)	Harry Armstrong
11	Richmond (Frem)	Tobie Travaglia
12	Richmond (Coll)	Luke Trainor
13	Gold Coast (Academy)	Leonardo Lombard
14	Essendon (NGA)	Isaac Kako
15	West Coast (Carl)	Bo Allan
16	Port Adelaide (WB)	Xavier Lindsay
17	Fremantle (Haw)	Joe Berry
18	GWS Giants	Taj Hotton
19	GWS Giants (Compensation)	Jobe Shanahan
20	W.Bulldogs (Geel)	Jack Whitlock
21	Richmond (PA)	Cooper Hynes
22	Brisbane (Academy)	Samuel Marshall
23	Sydney	Matt Whitlock
24	Richmond (Bris)	Jonty Faull
25	GWS Giants (Compensation)	Jesse Dattoli
26	Sydney (NM Priority)	Harrison Oliver
27	Richmond (NM Priority)	Tom Gross
28	Richmond	Oliver Hannaford
29	W.Bulldogs (NM)	Alex Dodson
30	West Coast	Christian Moraes
31	Carlton (F/S)	Ben Camporeale
32	Port Adelaide (GC)	Hamish Davis
33	Fremantle (St.K)	Noah Mraz
34	St.Kilda (Frem)	James Barrat
35	Hawthorn (Coll)	Jack Ough
36	GWS Giants (Academy)	Logan Smith
37	W.Bulldogs	Lachie Jaques
38	Port Adelaide (Haw)	Kayle Gerreyn
39	Essendon (Syd)	Harry O'Farrell
40	Sydney (NM)	Angus Clarke
41	Geelong (WC)	Thomas Sims
42	St.Kilda (NGA)	Adrian Cole
43	Essendon (Adel)	Joshua Dolan
44	W.Bulldogs (GC)	Xavier Ivisic
45	Port Adelaide (Ess)	Charlie Nicholls
46	Collingwood	Nathan Sulzberger
47	Carlton (F/S)	Lucas Camporeale
48	West Coast (NGA)	Malakai Champion
49	Adelaide (F/S)	Tyler Welsh
50	Collingwood (Haw)	Archer Day-Wicks

i do not rate linsday whatsoever

 

[Addy23]

Based on rankings and how it could fall this is how I'm hoping it turns out for us.
16. Lindsay winger that can play multiple positions.
32. Davis would love for him to fall to us big body that can play multiple positions also.
38. Gerreyn ruck that can play forward.
45. likely after bids we move forward and take Nicholls SA Key forward/Defender

1	Richmond	Finn O'Sullivan
2	Brisbane (F/S)	Levi Ashcroft
3	North Melbourne	Harvey Langford
4	Carlton (WC)	Sam Lalor
5	Adelaide	Sid Draper
6	Melbourne	Jagga Smith
7	Richmond (GC)	Josh Smillie
8	St.Kilda	Murphy Reid
9	St.Kilda (Compensation)	Alixzander Tauru
10	Melbourne (Ess)	Harry Armstrong
11	Richmond (Frem)	Tobie Travaglia
12	Richmond (Coll)	Luke Trainor
13	Gold Coast (Academy)	Leonardo Lombard
14	Essendon (NGA)	Isaac Kako
15	West Coast (Carl)	Bo Allan
16	Port Adelaide (WB)	Xavier Lindsay
17	Fremantle (Haw)	Joe Berry
18	GWS Giants	Taj Hotton
19	GWS Giants (Compensation)	Jobe Shanahan
20	W.Bulldogs (Geel)	Jack Whitlock
21	Richmond (PA)	Cooper Hynes
22	Brisbane (Academy)	Samuel Marshall
23	Sydney	Matt Whitlock
24	Richmond (Bris)	Jonty Faull
25	GWS Giants (Compensation)	Jesse Dattoli
26	Sydney (NM Priority)	Harrison Oliver
27	Richmond (NM Priority)	Tom Gross
28	Richmond	Oliver Hannaford
29	W.Bulldogs (NM)	Alex Dodson
30	West Coast	Christian Moraes
31	Carlton (F/S)	Ben Camporeale
32	Port Adelaide (GC)	Hamish Davis
33	Fremantle (St.K)	Noah Mraz
34	St.Kilda (Frem)	James Barrat
35	Hawthorn (Coll)	Jack Ough
36	GWS Giants (Academy)	Logan Smith
37	W.Bulldogs	Lachie Jaques
38	Port Adelaide (Haw)	Kayle Gerreyn
39	Essendon (Syd)	Harry O'Farrell
40	Sydney (NM)	Angus Clarke
41	Geelong (WC)	Thomas Sims
42	St.Kilda (NGA)	Adrian Cole
43	Essendon (Adel)	Joshua Dolan
44	W.Bulldogs (GC)	Xavier Ivisic
45	Port Adelaide (Ess)	Charlie Nicholls
46	Collingwood	Nathan Sulzberger
47	Carlton (F/S)	Lucas Camporeale
48	West Coast (NGA)	Malakai Champion
49	Adelaide (F/S)	Tyler Welsh
50	Collingwood (Haw)	Archer Day-Wicks

This would be terrible for us. Lindsay has limited upside. Davis and Gerryne are fine picks but I'd rather Charlie West over Nicholls although I don't think we should take 2 KPFs given midfield is a need.

Based on those rankings and who's gone after our picks, it should be Hotton, Jack Ough, Kayle Gerryne and Day-Wicks

 

[Ford Fairlane]

16. Port Adelaide -- Joe Berry

Murray Bushrangers/Vic Country

FWD, 181cm

Berry's creativity, scoreboard impact and precise ball use has made him a first-round lock, and he has a host of clubs interested in this range. It's the type of player Port Adelaide would have loved in finals, able to make the most of half-chances and execute under pressure. Berry adds immediate competition in a shallow small forward unit at the Power, who have also shown interest in Cooper Hynes and Luke Trainor.

 

[Rash]

Are we interested in Hotton?

 

[RangaInTeal]

Are we interested in Hotton?

Seems a Port pick within this régime, Rozee, Sinn, highly touted juniors who stalled in their draft year. If he hold form, Hotton and Hargrave will be with us in 2025.

 

[Rash]

Seems a Port pick within this régime, Rozee, Sinn, highly touted juniors who stalled in their draft year. If he hold form, Hotton and Hargrave will be with us in 2025.

I really hope we pick hotton. If we pick linsday over him i'll spew.

 

[Haggas]

Seems a Port pick within this régime, Rozee, Sinn, highly touted juniors who stalled in their draft year. If he hold form, Hotton and Hargrave will be with us in 2025.

Kade Herbert would fit that bill

 

[Macca19]

Not seeing it with Berry personally, but he’s definitely a Parker type pick

 

[Haggas]

This would be terrible for us. Lindsay has limited upside. Davis and Gerryne are fine picks but I'd rather Charlie West over Nicholls although I don't think we should take 2 KPFs given midfield is a need.

Based on those rankings and who's gone after our picks, it should be Hotton, Jack Ough, Kayle Gerryne and Day-Wicks

I Agree Mids is a need maybe we look at a big bodied mid with a later pick if we miss out on Hamish Davis like Phoenix Hargrave, Jack Ough, Luke Urquhart or Lucca Grego