Ford Fairlane
Moderator
- Feb 21, 2002
- 81,991
- 202,388
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Port Adelaide Magpies
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2024 AFL Draft - November 20-21 (Picks 13, 29, 36, 50, 94, 112, 130)
- Thread starter Holden Hillbilly
- Start date
- Tagged users None
If we did trade for GWS's 16 and 21, that's their Perryman and Cumming compensation picks, two players we were linked heavily to in free agency. Just a weird turn of events that would be.
Acemanjam
Debutant
- Jun 22, 2024
- 106
- 152
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Depends on whether or not I thought GWS would pinch him at 15. Would probably want a handshake deal prior. Would be surprised if Freo yoinked him, but it's still a risk.
- Jan 20, 2015
- 3,224
- 6,166
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
We have 4 picks. The only key defender I would take prior to our third pick is Trainor. Would be happy to take him with our second.
We are taking someone who can spend 5 minutes in the ruck. Thats why its Whitlock or Gerryn
- Mar 10, 2014
- 10,016
- 11,684
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Man Utd, Celtic, Tanunda
Scully was 204cm tall.
We cut him because he wasn't an "aggro" type of player!
At least according to our forwards coach.You'd normally allow at least 3 to 4 years development before making that kind of a call.
But ........ we are Port Adelaide, so ...
Not sure why people would think that Whitlock would be any different?
Scully was poor overhead and had little forward craft, we took him with a late pick punt, but those who watched him a junior knew that he was poor overhead, he also came to the sport later hence his lack of craft. Whitlock is leagues ahead of him in quality and why your best quality kps come early in the draft.Scully was 204cm tall.
We cut him because he wasn't an "aggro" type of player!
You'd normally allow at least 3 to 4 years development before making that kind of a call.
But ........ we are Port Adelaide, so ...
Not sure why people would think that Whitlock would be any different?
Scully however was a bit stiff, maybe another year of dev was warranted, club probably new there were better talls to draft this year.
- Jan 20, 2015
- 3,224
- 6,166
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
If we do the trade with gws, I think that the ideal draft for me would be Reid, Trainor, Gerreyn and Clark. Covers all positions and a little bit of skill, power and class across them.
Scodges
Club Legend
- Sep 22, 2023
- 1,250
- 1,522
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
][emoji6
][emoji[emoji6]
][emoji[emoji6][emoji6]]" data-quote="Powerade [emoji[emoji6][emoji6]][emoji[emoji6]]" data-source="post: 0"
class="bbCodeBlock bbCodeBlock--expandable bbCodeBlock--quote js-expandWatch">
We are taking someone who can spend [emoji6
] minutes in the ruck. Thats why its Whitlock or Gerryn
] minutes in the ruck. Thats why its Whitlock or Gerryn
Why would we when we have Soldo & Visentini who can ruck in their own right. Then throw in Finlayson, who’s actually pretty good when his head is switched on. I’d be grooming Lord in that group as well.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
- Sep 29, 2012
- 10,593
- 11,695
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
I'd take, thinking Ports priorities are tall
1. Whitlock or Shanahan OK with either.
2. Whitlock ( the other one. He's going to have to get use to that
) or Mraz.
3. Mraz or Moraes.
4. Gerreyn. This is on the assumption Dodson went between our 2nd and 3rd picks. This is on the assumption Moraes is gone.
5. Josh Dolan for nothing would be a steal for mine.
1. Whitlock or Shanahan OK with either.
2. Whitlock ( the other one. He's going to have to get use to that
) or Mraz.3. Mraz or Moraes.
4. Gerreyn. This is on the assumption Dodson went between our 2nd and 3rd picks. This is on the assumption Moraes is gone.
5. Josh Dolan for nothing would be a steal for mine.
Why are people running with this when it’s been disproven. The only explanation that’s been offered to back up “small forwards win flags” is that 7 players compromised of small forwards, half forward flankers and mids / forwards have kicked more goals than 2 players playing kf on a few grand finals. Which is as nonsensical as it sounds.
If our kf line going forward is some version of Mitch / luko and maybe Marshall , sure, we can absolutely argue the best fit for any grouping of those is a taller kpf who can ruck..
… but trying to thread the needle of drafting that exact player with a high draft pick when said player likely even if they work out isn’t going to be rucking for us for 3-5 years anyway seems like an unnecessary complication to add to something that is already complicated and risky.
Ford Fairlane
Moderator
- Feb 21, 2002
- 81,991
- 202,388
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Port Adelaide Magpies
- Moderator
- #2,862
Yep if it's Shanahan you grab him there and bank on someone like Hannaford, Gross, Urquhart, Ough, Kennedy being there at 29. Or even go tall again then and take one of those mids at 36. The talent pool is still solid then.
Mind you Twomey hasn't linked Freo with any tall, more interested in mids.
Be fascinating to see what we do if Reid is there at 13. Or Bo Allan. Cal Twomey in his last Top 30 suggested West Coast weren't as locked onto him as people think.
Clarke won't get to 50
Are you trying to make me cry?I'd take, thinking Ports priorities are tall
1. Whitlock or Shanahan OK with either.
2. Whitlock ( the other one. He's going to have to get use to that
3. Mraz or Moraes.
4. Gerreyn. This is on the assumption Dodson went between our 2nd and 3rd picks. This is on the assumption Moraes is gone.
5. Josh Dolan for nothing would be a steal for mine.
Agree I think Shanahan and Hannaford/Gross is a chance.
If Hamish Davis is available at 36 then I'd take him with Dennis at 50.
Only one of Reid and Shanahan will be available imo. Have to take whichever one is available which will simplify the decision. In the remote chance both of are available, have to take Reid because I like tall prospects later in the draft better than midfielders
He's the #1 key forward now with Daniher gone. He hasn't played that role while Joe was there. Let's see how he does in that role now.
Hipwood imo is no better than Marshall except Hipwood gets better ball delivery. I'm not sure he starts for us if we are fully fit.
cosmicwinduptoy
Senior List
- May 20, 2023
- 250
- 511
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Name one player we have cut in the last decade that has gone on to do anything.Scully was 204cm tall.
We cut him because he wasn't an "aggro" type of player!
You'd normally allow at least 3 to 4 years development before making that kind of a call.
But ........ we are Port Adelaide, so ...
Not sure why people would think that Whitlock would be any different?
Riley Bonner
somehow managed to play most of the season lol
Ford Fairlane
Moderator
- Feb 21, 2002
- 81,991
- 202,388
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Port Adelaide Magpies
- Moderator
- #2,869
Riley Bonner
And infuriate an entirely new supporter base while he did it.
- Mar 13, 2014
- 578
- 1,468
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
With McEntee being elevated to the main list we only have 4 list spots left for the national draft. I doubt Dolan lasts to our pick in the Rookie draft.I'd take, thinking Ports priorities are tall
1. Whitlock or Shanahan OK with either.
2. Whitlock ( the other one. He's going to have to get use to that
3. Mraz or Moraes.
4. Gerreyn. This is on the assumption Dodson went between our 2nd and 3rd picks. This is on the assumption Moraes is gone.
5. Josh Dolan for nothing would be a steal for mine.
It will be another stupid trade from our club . We will neither have Berry , Shahnan or Murphy .
Not many clubs are interested in him . Even he will be available at even pick 21
Similar threads
