Rumour 2024 Hypothetical trade and FA Thread

[The Spirit of Cricket]

Keep holding out. The longer this goes on the more desperate the 2 1st rounders will be. Pick 14 absolute max.

We won't hold out over a ~5 pick slide in the 40s. Seems likely we add in our F2 for their F3.

This'll get done very soon

 

[Maybloomer]

For all the bagging Cornes cops he actually knows his stuff

Dan rioli is not worth pick 6 let alone pick 23 added to it.

Shai Bolton is not worth pick 10 and pick 18

Liam Baker pick 14

Crazy offers going on.

Saints got Pick 8 for Battle and wouldn't even buy him a meal and drinks at their B&F.

 

[TONYC3163]

We won't hold out over a ~5 pick slide in the 40s. Seems likely we add in our F2 for their F3.

This'll get done very soon

Yep, it will be pick 14 plus something.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

Keep holding out. The longer this goes on the more desperate the 2 1st rounders will be. Pick 14 absolute max.

Please don't post that absolute scumbag on our board.

 

[hawkmang]

Here we are again in the trade period doldrums

 

[Sturty]

WHERE IS OUR BARRASS TRADE

 

[kazzooka]

Our future second and their future third, should only end up being a 1 or 2 pick downgrade

We shouldn't trade our future pick (unknown) for their future pick (unknown).

Only possible movements are our pick getting better than expected and there's getting worse than expected.

If they want our future 2nd for they should give us an early 3rd now.

While best case scenario has our future 2nd as pick 36 and their future 3rd as pick 37.

As unlikely as it is, there is a chance our future 2nd is pick 19 and their future 3rd is pick 54.

 

[bigmaxi]

Saints got Pick 8 for Battle and wouldn't even buy him a meal and drinks at their B&F.

This is what i do not understand, it values Battle at pick 8. Great that we get that kind of pick for free but compared to what is being floated around for a bunch of other players it seems a little out of whack!

 

[kazzooka]

We won't hold out over a ~5 pick slide in the 40s. Seems likely we add in our F2 for their F3.

This'll get done very soon

At best it's a 1 pick slide, at worst it's a 35 pick slide. That's a risk if both picks are futures.

Then you have compensation, academy and fs that could impact as well.

Don't mind giving a little more with a pick swap but make both or 1 of the picks this year.

But West Coast have other deals to do and they need that pick 14. We can just wait until they are desperate or they will miss out on Liam Baker.

 

[Roddy]

WHERE IS OUR BARRASS TRADE

I had a very strong feeling it would not be some easy gimme, like seemingly everyone else thought. But yeah, it's testing the patience....

 

[kazzooka]

This is what i do not understand, it values Battle at pick 8. Great that we get that kind of pick for free but compared to what is being floated around for a bunch of other players it seems a little out of whack!

It doesn't value Battle at Pick 8. It values battle at Band 1.

Where a band 1 pick falls is dependent on ladder position.

 

[Dewnior]

Geelol trying to push Smith to ND / PSD.

F$&kers. Someone needs to keep them honest. Doubt Saints will.

 

[TylerDurden]

Geelol trying to push Smith to ND / PSD.

I'd prefer we trade our F1 for Barrass and keep this year's 1st.

No chance.
Will be 14 and chump change.

 

[number23]

If he gets walked to the PSD… just saying the Hawks do pick before the Cats*

View attachment 2135852



















*Wont happen though but fooking hell I'm here for it

If only we had a first rounder after trading for Barrass.

Jay Clark was adamant that no one will pick up Bailey Smith without having interviewed him.

We have...

If only we had a first rounder after trading for Barrass.

 

[ahhhhhh]

It was just mentioned that we may be looking at delisted Sun Hewago Paul Oea. However, it was unsure whether that was for AFL or VFL.

Something.....

 

[Hawkspot]

If only we had a first rounder after trading for Barrass.

Jay Clark was adamant that no one will pick up Bailey Smith without having interviewed him.

We have...

If only we had a first rounder after trading for Barrass.

Giants have the pick before Geelong. Offer our F1 and maybe swap 33 for their 37 for it draft night, draft Smith.

Wouldn’t mention it until that pick, so there was no way for Geelong to move in front of it.

It will never happen, but it would be funny.

 

[Hawkthorn33]

Geelol trying to push Smith to ND / PSD.

F$&kers. Someone needs to keep them honest. Doubt Saints will.

Would we dare?

 

[Ned Ryerson]

The one year we need a ****wit like Dodo to threaten Geelong with snapping up Baz and he is gone.

 

[TylerDurden]

The one year we need a ****wit like Dodo to threaten Geelong with snapping up Baz and he is gone.

Perhaps he can be the mediator in the final hour. His specialty.

 

[Steven Tyler]

Are people really expecting trades to ge done in the first week?

 

[Ned Ryerson]

Are people really expecting trades to ge done in the first week?

Inconsequential ones - yes. Substantial ones? No.

The sooner the trade period, including free agency, is constrained to 4-5 days the better.

 

[kirbatron]

GC have offered 6 for rioli & tiges want more

heavens to betsy

 

[The Spirit of Cricket]

At best it's a 1 pick slide, at worst it's a 35 pick slide. That's a risk if both picks are futures.

Then you have compensation, academy and fs that could impact as well.

Don't mind giving a little more with a pick swap but make both or 1 of the picks this year.

But West Coast have other deals to do and they need that pick 14. We can just wait until they are desperate or they will miss out on Liam Baker.

I'd rather trade our F2 than Collingwoods 2nd we have for this year

 

[Iceman!]

GC have offered 6 for rioli & tiges want more

heavens to betsy

Wait is this legit? I had assumed for the past couple months that the 6 for Rioli talk was 6 for Rioli + something else going back?

That is putrid LMFAO

 

[Hawk88]

So how does it work for Bailey if he does go into the draft?

Can he nominated his length of contract and salary terms? If so Saints just need to do the best thing ever and just draft him and then trade him the following year lol

Personally i think Geelong will end up giving more because you cant risk a player you have said you will trade for risk the draft. They will 100% blink first right before the end of the trade period

Will just be a 3rd rounder or a swap of picks though but allows doggies to save some face