Any thoughts on Nick Haynes as back up for a year or two?
List Mgmt. 2024 List Management discussion
- Thread starter M Malice
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Four; Matt Maguire
Correct; I posted without seeing your post from previous post.
Added
dlanod
Moderator
- Sep 14, 2006
- 54,102
- 86,475
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- GWS; CCMariners; NQCowboys; Ravens
- Moderator
- #2,481
He's aiming for a multiyear deal and I doubt it'll be on minimum wage. I don't think it's worth it unless your list is sparse on average (at this stage) talent, and I also don't think it's a smart allocation of our cap.
LIONS IN LEVI TALKS
NEGOTIATIONS continue on an agreement for father-son prospect Levi Ashcroft, with the AFL's new rules and uplift in total player payments making it potentially a landmark deal for an undrafted player.
As previously done with the likes of Collingwood's Nick Daicos, Essendon's Joe Daniher and Ashcroft's older brother Will at Brisbane, father-son prospects are able to essentially agree to longer contracts than the AFL's standardised first deals when they commit to nominating as a father-son in their draft campaign.
Daicos, in 2021, and Will Ashcroft the following season, both agreed to two extra years with their respective clubs as four-year deals, worth approximately $550,000-$600,000 in the third and fourth years. Daicos has since had his deal extended to be close to $1 million a season through to his free agency at the end of 2029.
The AFL's changed rules last year as part of the new collective bargaining agreement mean that top-20 picks are now locked in on initial three-year deals and that extensions can't officially be lodged and approved until after round six the following year.
However, 'handshake agreements' can be discussed, with the younger Ashcroft situation looming as a test case for the game's era of 'new money'.
00:48
If Ashcroft was to commit to two more years on top of his standard first three seasons, then he would be tied to the Lions through to the end of 2029, which will progress past the current CBA through to the next one.
Agents across the board are also looking for clubs to top up players deals for their fourth and fifth seasons for the money the players will not earn due to being capped in their third seasons, with many top draft picks under the previous model often earning between $400,000-$500,000 for their third and fourth seasons.
It means some clubs would expect Ashcroft, tipped to be a likely top-five pick at November's draft, to be valued around the $700,000 mark for those fourth and fifth seasons.
Ashcroft, who has been managing a shoulder injury, will play in Vic Metro's championship decider at Marvel Stadium on Sunday against Vic Country. Will Ashcroft officially nominated for the Lions in early August of his draft season. – Callum Twomey
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1168815
mpal6
Norm Smith Medallist
mpal6
Norm Smith Medallist
Sorry no
mpal6
Norm Smith Medallist
I still believe in Joyce. He'll do the job and has the size/strength. For a depth key position, Joyce is pretty good value in my opinion.
EDIT: Remember we're talking about Joyce who for all intents and purposes is like 5 down in the depth chart. Harris, Payne, Gardiner, Doedee, Joyce. We can't really be expecting premium defender at those sort of levels.
Last edited:
mpal6
Norm Smith Medallist
all good, I thought you were having a moment switching between your GWS and Lions hats.
I agree with the delisting of Lyons. We let Matho go pretty much because he was taking midfield time away from developing youth. Same now with Lyons.
Dev on the other hand I'm keeping at least for next season, have him see out his contract. He is the only defensive mid on the list. Probably the only mid that could come in and play the Berry or even the Dunkley role inside. We've been much better in the middle with a cpl of hard heads banging into the opposition. Levi and Sam don't strike me as hard nuts, and even if we did draft one it may take a cpl of years for him to be ready. Tunstill is more expendable than Dev in my opinion.
100% agree. I do believe there is the ability for his tackling to really improve. Send him, and a few others, to the Bronco's preseason for some tackling drills. Learn how to stop grabbing and drive the shoulder in. If not that, Courtney Hodder has great technique a lot could learn from. Even Bruuuce could show him a few things. I think he's also gotta stop thinking he's a front rower too, trying to break thru tackles.
We will have Darcy Gardiner back next year. Very capable of playing that second tall role. Hoping the rise of Morris, the improvement of Henry Smith and the ability of Ryan has ended the Gardiner to the fwds experiment for ever.
I'm OK with Joyce. Not a super player sure but good enough at the moment to fill in for a game or two and cheap. I do think he can tighten a few things up and be more reliable in the firsts. I'm all for an upgrade but who and at what cost?
While Gardiner and Joyce could get us out of trouble if needed next year I agree it would be more than handy to have another tall back on the books.
3KZ is Football
🏆 🦍 RZSS Curator of Sticks and Stuff.
- Jun 17, 2008
- 27,422
- 38,081
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Fitzroy Football Club
EFA
Man, I'm still sad we lost Justin Clarke. What a beauty he was. The Andrews/Clarke combo would have been so good.
Had his education to fall back on at least. He's at Oxford now.
Whether it be through trade/FA or even as a delisted FA, we need to bring in at least one extra KPP player for a bit of depth at the end of the year. There’s no guarantee Dizz and/or Doedee make it back or certainly to the same level, but we can’t leave ourselves exposed next year to injuries in that position again.
The Flying Belgian
Third Tall
The point of the chin is where boxers often get knocked out. Don't know the physiology behind it.
Chin is furthest from the brain therefore far more leverage to the vulnerable parts and if it's a significant blow the actual force and whiplash effect is more damaging than a direct hit to the forehead.
Which is why the uppercut is the blow likely to do the most damage in boxing. It rattles the brain.
Cubs2Lions
Norm Smith Medallist
Denver Grainger-Barras | AFL
Follow Denver Grainger-Barras's progress through AFL
Maybe we should consider signing someone like Denver Grainger-Barras from Hawthorn as that young KPP depth player for in the next couple of years while we are in the premiership window.
Top 5 pick in the 2020 draft (195cm) but has struggled to play consistent footy with form/injury and would probably struggle to find a starting 22 spot in our side (with everyone available). However, he would not cost us via draft hand (NFA) and would be on cheap money if he moved here while having the potential to replace Lester in 1-2 years time, if Gardiner and Doedee don't perform as expected as we initially thought given their injury history or retire as well.
Only problem is KPDs are in such hot demand these days and clubs like Richmond and West Coast (and even Collingwood) would provide Grainger-Barras with an automatic selection in their AFL side next year and beyond so it would be highly unlikely we can snare him over here but we would do like trading from Hawthorn so you never know honestly
Last edited:
