Analysis 2024 National Draft

Who should Carlton take at Pick 3 if available?


  • Total voters
    348

Remove this Banner Ad

Can we take a moment to appreciate the position we are in here. We traded up to 3 to acquire another gun mid to complement Cripps and Walsh. Yet a team like St. Kilda who need an elite mid desperately are likely to miss out on a decent mid if the phantoms play out that way. I was hesitant at first to admit trading up for 3 was the right idea, but it’s these kind of bold calls that can pay dividends. Kudos Austin.

As for Jagga.. he has a beautiful sidestep to weave out of traffic and seems to have terrific special awareness. Clean hands and a fraction of a second quicker than most to analyse the situation and move the ball on. The Butters comparisons are reasonably accurate. Moves very similarly and is slippery in congestion. He’ll fit in beautifully and has future captain vibes.
StKilda would be insane to not take Murphy Reid or Xavier Lindsey at 8. Just dumb if they don’t.
 
Jack Nicholson Reaction GIF

Haha, can’t wake to trade in Harley Reid end of next season. What an acquisition that will be.

Jagga Reid Walsh Cripps Cerra Hewitt

Dream Team
 
I see loads of Daicos in Jagga. I believe his impact could be the same in a professional environment.

Hoping we call out his name in a few nights time.

I'm hoping we call out his name in 2 nights time because I don't think he will last until Pick 38.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

The Top 6 are very good and hard to split but I still see Langford as becoming the best player in the draft. He is just a smart composed footballer that does it all well and with a lethal left food.

Good and big enough that he could player CHB if needed.
 
Anyone else notice that most of the top prospects lack an opposite foot? Are coached not teaching this stuff anymore? What happened to the once a week session where all kicking drills were done on your weaker side?

It does my head in.

These kids spend 15-20 hours per week with a footy in their hand, how are they not even dedicating an hour or two to become competent on their non dominant side.

It helps you get out of so many jams and makes you harder to tackle when the opposition know you can go either way.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
I see loads of Daicos in Jagga. I believe his impact could be the same in a professional environment.

Hoping we call out his name in a few nights time.

Yes. There is stacks of Daicos in Jagga. They play very alike. The difference is in the kicking. Daicos kicking is amazing. 55m goals on the right and 48m goals on the left at 18yo. Absolutely searing kick.

Jagga a great player but Daicos' kicking makes him elite.
 
I see him as a slightly less damaging Daicos. Doesn't have the same kicking penetration and lacks goal threat.
You say that but his second half way way better and his interview on Gettable showed that he's infinitely coachable. Daicos had a lot of seagull possessions first few years. Jagga's footy IQ is right up there with Nick's. Plus he has leadership and maturity beyond his years. I see no reason why he can't get close if he adapts quickly and puts in the work.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Yes. There is stacks of Daicos in Jagga. They play very alike. The difference is in the kicking. Daicos kicking is amazing. 55m goals on the right and 48m goals on the left at 18yo. Absolutely searing kick.

Jagga a great player but Daicos' kicking makes him elite.
Jagga is a beautiful kick of the footy and I think with time and work on his craft he can be as lethal by foot like Daicos
 
Jagga is a beautiful kick of the footy and I think with time and work on his craft he can be as lethal by foot like Daicos
His kicking is one of his biggest knocks. Elite accumulator, extremely inconsistent ball user however.

I believe adding some size will help with his kicking considerably though. His decision making is nearly always superb.
 
His kicking is one of his biggest knocks. Elite accumulator, extremely inconsistent ball user however.

I believe adding some size will help with his kicking considerably though. His decision making is nearly always superb.
From what I’ve watched and seen I think his a beautiful kick of the footy, wouldn’t say that his weakness. But that’s just my opinion
 
Anyone else notice that most of the top prospects lack an opposite foot? Are coached not teaching this stuff anymore? What happened to the once a week session where all kicking drills were done on your weaker side?
Given Daicos will probably win multiple Brownlows and is a generational talent, I’m pretty happy with Daicos lite.

Jagga is just as classy under 40m. Just doesn’t have the goal kicking freak dual sided longer kicking.
 
You say that but his second half way way better and his interview on Gettable showed that he's infinitely coachable. Daicos had a lot of seagull possessions first few years. Jagga's footy IQ is right up there with Nick's. Plus he has leadership and maturity beyond his years. I see no reason why he can't get close if he adapts quickly and puts in the work.

I was super pleased to hear that from Jagga. Had the intelligence to listen to advice. And had the natural ability to change his game up for the better, Big tick for that.

Also i sought of thought all year that Jagga had an advantage on his peers by being out of school this year and helped him have a better year. But hearing him saying it actually was a hard year, sort of starting uni on his own, while his mates were all still together at school and playing footy. He wasn't whinging, but just sorta put a different angle on his year.

A lot of guys will go through that next year while Jagga is sorta on his way in life now already.
 
You say that but his second half way way better and his interview on Gettable showed that he's infinitely coachable. Daicos had a lot of seagull possessions first few years. Jagga's footy IQ is right up there with Nick's. Plus he has leadership and maturity beyond his years. I see no reason why he can't get close if he adapts quickly and puts in the work.

I really like Jagga, and I think he is a damaging midfielder. But I don't think you can coach a player to have Nick Daicos' kicking. Not a knock of Smith, its like saying a prospect's tank is just bit shy of Nick Reiwoldt's.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Analysis 2024 National Draft

Back
Top