Teams 2024 Rate My Pre-Season Team

[pincrusher]

Okay someone talk me off the ledge, what needs fixing here. I just have this feeling about Gryan. Had the same feeling about Noah Anderson last year and that worked out.

View attachment 1925089

Is Miers a personal fav?

Think he's a very very speculative pick at best

Not overly, but I just feel like he might go to that next level. No Duncan for a chunk of the year and the Cats are getting older.

If I were you I would pay a visit to the Geelong board and find out what position Miers has been playing preseason. If he isn't training with the mids, it's a hard no at that price, regardless of his talent.

 

[pincrusher]

I have one spot to fill.
Do I take Luke Jackson or Sam Flanders?

Jacko for mine, with Darcy out for the first few and Flanders with an early bye. I have both FWIW.

 

[Mavefromdelburn]

Jacko for mine, with Darcy out for the first few and Flanders with an early bye. I have both FWIW.

Hmm yeah thanks.
Here are my two team options, whatcha reckon?

1)


2)

 

[VainGlorious]

Thoughts on my current team brainstrust?

Structure and rooks all look pretty decent. Good starting lineup.

I have not played for 10 years, and I live in the UK now so I'm a bit removed.

Please review my team

All looks ok there, barring Coleman. He’s done an ACL

12k leftover and this is about as balanced as an unbalanced person can get I hope. Hate it, too many rookies on the field, injury prone spuds and fading premos everywhere, and for what reason have I got 4 Roos?

View attachment 1925232

Very nice, Mr Magoo.

There’s value in the Roos, is why.

 

[VainGlorious]

Hmm yeah thanks.
Here are my two team options, whatcha reckon?

1)
View attachment 1925250

2)
View attachment 1925251

2)

 

[VainGlorious]

Thoughts and opinions appreciated...


N Daicos H Sheezel N Wanganeen Milera

H Young C Salem E Yeo

T Pink N Coffield

M Bontempelli C Serong M Rowell

O Wines Ĝ Wardlaw S Berry

R Sanders H Hustwaite

J Clark M Carroll S Mannagh

T English B Grundy S Naismith


Z Fisher E Tsatas N Fyfe

H Reid A Sexton F Macrae

D Wilson B Nyuon


Cheers

Ingy!

Good to see you there friend.

Your forward line scares me, but otherwise it’s all hunky dory.

Don’t be a stranger, ya hear?

Speaking of being a stranger, where in the actual flying back-arsed **** is that splendid specimen No eye deer ?

Any eye deer where he is?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Ingy!

Good to see you there friend.

Your forward line scares me, but otherwise it’s all hunky dory.

Don’t be a stranger, ya hear?

Speaking of being a stranger, where in the actual flying back-arsed * is that splendid specimen No eye deer ?

Any eye deer where he is?

Pissed on a boat out fishing probably.

 

[VainGlorious]

Pissed on a boat out fishing probably.

That’s highly unsanitary. Why not just piss off the boat?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

That’s highly unsanitary. Why not just piss off the boat?

 

[Rustymagoo]

Hmm yeah thanks.
Here are my two team options, whatcha reckon?

1)
View attachment 1925250

2)
View attachment 1925251

2

 

[rf04]

$5k spare. Looking for ideas for better bench options than Simpson and Khamis (happy to switch jackson for heeney to facilitate). Thanks in advance.

 

[VainGlorious]

View attachment 1925292

Sorry, mate, I should’ve added an


Have another gif.

 

[Veer Right]

$5k spare. Looking for ideas for better bench options than Simpson and Khamis (happy to switch jackson for heeney to facilitate). Thanks in advance.
View attachment 1925298

Khamis > Campbell
Simpson > Lazzaro

 

[gutsroy]

Jackson szn....

 

[VainGlorious]

Jackson szn....

Of course arthroscopic surgery on a 200kg silverback is going to result in a coupla months on the pine.

Jacko F1 locked and loaded.

 

[rf04]

Khamis > Campbell
Simpson > Lazzaro

thanks - that doesnt look too shabby. Never been a fan of Lazarro - always seems to be behind others in the pecking order at North but seems like a popular choice ATM so not too concerned there. Campbell went well but not sure about his JS - which is no different to a lot of the rookie options i guess

 

[gutsroy]

Of course arthroscopic surgery on a 200kg silverback is going to result in a coupla months on the pine.

Jacko F1 locked and loaded.

Yeah, 100%, opens up good options and means Flanders can be grabbed after his first bye, and Heeney skipped for those with misgivings.
Big Sean doing us a favour and a half.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Yeah, I wish there were more SuperCoach podcasts that were as high quality as yours, Wayne.

Hey mate, we need two more campaigners for BFLONELYKENTSCLUB league

 

[RevDog]

Thoughts? $60k odd in the bank.

 

[gutsroy]

View attachment 1925321
View attachment 1925322

Thoughts? $60k odd in the bank.

Would go B Howes over E Phillips given you have the cash.
Would not go both Gulden and Green, would swap one out for another MID premo in the range you like.
If Curtin plays, don't see him in a role that would justify the outlay, Duursma similarly.
Would go Lazzaro and Reid over those two.
But back yourself in if they're your picks.
Nice side.

 

[Sydney Kicker]

View attachment 1925321
View attachment 1925322

Thoughts? $60k odd in the bank.

I'd only take one of Gulden and Green given they have such terrible byes. Replace one with a Port or Freo premo. Get Sexton on field. Curtin expensive for the bench and not sure he even plays R1 - Adelaide posters should be able to give you a steer here.

 

[Shinboner1]

 

[Ingy]

Ingy!

Good to see you there friend.

Your forward line scares me, but otherwise it’s all hunky dory.

Don’t be a stranger, ya hear?

Speaking of being a stranger, where in the actual flying back-arsed * is that splendid specimen No eye deer ?

Any eye deer where he is?

Cheers mate.

Just for you, I've installed Jackson at F1

Forward line is now:

L Jackson Z Fisher E Tsatas
N Fyfe H Reid A Sexton

D Wilson B Nyuon.

Cost me NVM, Bowes is now D6.

Between Bowes and Coffield I should be able to get a decent onfield score each week, so I'm probably better balanced now.

Thanks Tony Bluevein

 

[No eye deer]

Ingy!

Good to see you there friend.

Your forward line scares me, but otherwise it’s all hunky dory.

Don’t be a stranger, ya hear?

Speaking of being a stranger, where in the actual flying back-arsed * is that splendid specimen No eye deer ?

Any eye deer where he is?

Here I am!
Feeling all warm and fuzzy that I have been missed!
A bit late to the party and I really have No Eye Deer this season. Haven’t spent any time whatsoever on my team.

Pissed on a boat out fishing probably.

Haha!
I wish!
Just finished week one of a three month shutdown at work.
12 hour days, six days a week.

FWIW this is my first draft, hurriedly whipped together.
275k left.
Looking at other teams, it seems I need to shore up my Defence….
Any advice most welcome!

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Cheers mate.

Just for you, I've installed Jackson at F1

Forward line is now:

L Jackson Z Fisher E Tsatas
N Fyfe H Reid A Sexton

D Wilson B Nyuon.

Cost me NVM, Bowes is now D6.

Between Bowes and Coffield I should be able to get a decent onfield score each week, so I'm probably better balanced now.

Thanks Tony Bluevein

Bowes trained alone today supposedly, might have a plan B ready.