Teams 2024 Rate My Pre-Season Team

[Ingy]

Bowes trained alone today supposedly, might have a plan B ready.

Hahaha I've only just added him! He must have heard that he's in my team.

Kents can't carry me on their shoulders, the bloody season hasn't even started lol

 

[vanders]

 

[WaynesWorld19]

View attachment 1925417View attachment 1925419

Feedback on Mackenzie ....I see he's not in your side

 

[Sydney Kicker]

View attachment 1925417View attachment 1925419

Nice team. Hard to criticise. Maybe you could go for some of the cheaper Superpremos. Bont, Dawson, Libba all guns but priced at top dollar. I'd replace at least one with someone young in the 580-620k range (Serong, Butters, Rozee etc).

 

[kenneje]

Byes
2 - Williams
3 - Green, Flanders, Sexton
5 - Daicos, Grundy
6 - Gibcus, Gawn

Feel finally settled on a structure, and quite happy with the premos I've selected.

Final decision is basically choosing 1 x undervalued premo, 1/2 x mid pricers & rookies.

Wines + Williams + Fyfe
Heeney + Williams + Hustwaite + Lazzaro
Yeo + Fyfe + Hustwaite + Lazzaro

 

[vanders]

Feedback on Mackenzie ....I see he's not in your side

I think he's an awkward price and he's the one most likely to have his role changed when Day comes back. He was sub a lot last year too so a bit worried he might get the vest again.
i also don't like picking too many guys from my own team

 

[Axly]

Another version I've been playing with.
Less GnR, MPM...

$74.2k Bank

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Of course arthroscopic surgery on a 200kg silverback is going to result in a coupla months on the pine.

Jacko F1 locked and loaded.

There's no way Dunstall is less than 250kgs

 

[Soggy2112]

 

[gutsroy]

I have one spot to fill.
Do I take Luke Jackson or Sam Flanders?

For what it's worth (also VeinGlorious ), Ryan Daniels sticking by the original timeframe on Sean Darcy's return (4, vs 6-8 Tom Morris):

 

[turtles]

I think we are going to have a multiple winners this year; just fast-forwarded through 9 Supercoach youtubers teams could have sworn they were all identical. this is an amalgamation;

100%;
Daicos
Young
Williams
Gibcus
Howe
Bont
McKercher
Sanders
Roberts
Clark
Wilson
Grundy
Fisher
H.Reid
Sexton
Naismith/Livingston

89%;
Heeney
Z.Reid
Wines
Hustwaite
Jordon
Cadman
Martin

78%
Green

67%
Gawn
Sheezel

56%
Butters (if not they all have libba or dawson instead) so butters/libba/dawson 100%

44%
Houston
Lazzaro

 

[kyri]

I think we are going to have a multiple winners this year; just fast-forwarded through 9 Supercoach youtubers teams could have sworn they were all identical. this is an amalgamation;

great write up. seems to be the preseason cookie cutter team. mine is extremely similar.

im gonna guess the 67% that have gawn, the other 33% have english?

and same with z.reid, theyd have coffield or phillips instead.

surprisingly low % for houston and lazzaro.

 

[VainGlorious]

There's no way Dunstall is less than 250kgs

There’s a quarter of a tonne in excess shoulder hair alone.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Are we any the wiser with the Jackson / Hodor scenario ? ....are we bringing in Jackson ?

Probably preferable to Heeney ...as Heeney magnify's our Rnd 5 Bye issue, for Grundy, Naicos, and Jordon owners

 

[VainGlorious]

Jacko F1 locked and loaded.

For what it's worth (also VeinGlorious ), Ryan Daniels sticking by the original timeframe on Sean Darcy's return (4, vs 6-8 Tom Morris):

Wow.

What an emotional roller coaster.

Jacko.
No Jacko
Jacko
No Jacko
Jacko
No Jacko
Finkle
Einhorn
Finkle
Einhorn
Finkle
Einhorn

 

[VainGlorious]

Are we any the wiser with the Jackson / Hodor scenario ? ....are we bringing in Jackson ?

Probably preferable to Heeney ...as Heeney magnify's our Rnd 5 Bye issue, for Grundy, Naicos, and Jordon owners

I think I’m still going to start him.


Heed this warning and avoid if you are wanting to achieve a semi-respectable rank.

 

[Ken Tea]

Ryan Daniels is the one we trust the most in he West, he's usually bang on.

 

[gutsroy]

Is it that surprising that they would tend to converge on similar sides, though?

The Rd 0 stuff will have had all locking in Grundy, and no-one will want to be the one to get off Hawn given he went 170-odd just prior.
Naismith as a potential playing R3 picks himself unless that 20k is the difference between A and B.

Sexton, McKercher, Sanders,.... all pick themselves etc.

The one that is a little surprising for me is the bye players like Green, Daicos,... Good as they are, they're going into the race with a handicap.

No point worrying about it, just think to yourself about where you'd be OK zigging where others are zagging.

 

[gutsroy]

Wow.

What an emotional roller coaster.

Jacko.
No Jacko
Jacko
No Jacko
Jacko
No Jacko
Finkle
Einhorn
Finkle
Einhorn
Finkle
Einhorn



View attachment 1925652

Yeah, think i'm sticking with him.
Darcy surely eased back in, lower TOG, split etc.
Means no Heeney / Flanders, though.
Heeney 's early fixture is pretty tasty.

 

[croweater 41]

Pulled my finger out and picked 30 players seeing as someone put me in Div 3 (not so subtle brag)

I probably need to look at early byes a little closer and other byes also.

Fwd line is a mess this year as I am sure most have already come across. Tilly out for the Crows has me considering Burgess for a few weeks to make some quick $$ hopefully
View attachment 1919040
View attachment 1919041

Stupid sexy Flanders.

This is probably the 30 until Thursday and then Friday and then Saturday.... I have $7K left which I am not sure I am keen on.

 

[Hawkboy62]

Stupid sexy Flanders.

This is probably the 30 until Thursday and then Friday and then Saturday.... I have $7K left which I am not sure I am keen on.

View attachment 1925662
View attachment 1925663

Pity about round 3.

 

[turtles]

great write up. seems to be the preseason cookie cutter team. mine is extremely similar.

im gonna guess the 67% that have gawn, the other 33% have english?

and same with z.reid, theyd have coffield or phillips instead.

surprisingly low % for houston and lazzaro.

From memory 1 english, 1 Marshall and 1 jackson

 

[Petrify]

I think we are going to have a multiple winners this year; just fast-forwarded through 9 Supercoach youtubers teams could have sworn they were all identical. this is an amalgamation;
View attachment 1925596

I hate how similar this is to my team that I posted a few days ago, I don't even watch the kents!

 

[turtles]

Is it that surprising that they would tend to converge on similar sides, though?

The Rd 0 stuff will have had all locking in Grundy, and no-one will want to be the one to get off Hawn given he went 170-odd just prior.
Naismith as a potential playing R3 picks himself unless that 20k is the difference between A and B.

Sexton, McKercher, Sanders,.... all pick themselves etc.

The one that is a little surprising for me is the bye players like Green, Daicos,... Good as they are, they're going into the race with a handicap.

No point worrying about it, just think to yourself about where you'd be OK zigging where others are zagging.

Not surprising at all.
The pool of relevant players is only so big and there are players we all deem as must haves we build around.
Throw in round 0 and we seem to have the smallest pool of relevant players ever.

But looking at them, they are appear to be near identical in structure with about 3 on field differences interchanging from a handful of options.

Wines goes from 9.6% owned in SC to 89% in YouTuber SC, with one Matt crouch alternative.

They all have good looking teams that must be well researched, I too have many similarities but there seems to be a very prevalent echo chamber.

 

[croweater 41]

Pity about round 3.

That's also a concern.

But as I said this is where I am at today. I'll have seven different more versions before the start and about 18 more before round 3.