Position 2024 Rookies

[rocker_oz33]

Hore is the Bowey replacement as Melbourne want to keep Salem in the midfield.

Hore was a good scoring rookie a few years ago.

I always have a spot open for Marty dirty Hore ..
A spot just opened up ...

 

[BrutThough]

Want a cheap forward rookie. Anyone taking Collard?

No one should. He's the likely sub. With Sinclair likely back next week and Butler joining in with full training this week, he will do well to see rd2.

 

[TryAnHit]

I'm thinking of choosing Oscar McDonald for all those easy chip kicks in the backline... Scored a 70 against Port. Has Brisbane, North, Crows, Carlton, Port, Eagles in first 6. Worry is that he makes way for Chapman when he's back.

If I want to get Carroll, my choices are currently:

1) put Daicos in the mids for a week and trade Gibcus to Carroll at some point. Means taking one of McDonald/Pink/Hore.
2) blow up my whole team to get Yeo in (likely instead of Martin) and effectively do the same thing.
3) take Sharp/Wehr/Mannagh and rely on needing to do a corrective trade in the mids or forwards.

I went option 3 already planned out. See wehr vs north / Eagles. Then take his 30-50k price rise and move it onto carroll on the bubble.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Missed this one yesterday.

 

[2ballz]

Anyone else considering Buku Khamis for the last forward rookie spot? Don't want Cadman as already have Flanders/Sexton. Named CHB and scored 60 in pre-season. Any dogs fans got more info on his JS?

 

[Ljam]

Yes I think Khamis is a decent pick.

 

[Faz 2000]

Missed this one yesterday.

That'll have to do, then. Get out of my team Harry Husqvarna or whoever you are.

 

[Boyd oh Boyd]

Anyone else considering Buku Khamis for the last forward rookie spot? Don't want Cadman as already have Flanders/Sexton. Named CHB and scored 60 in pre-season. Any dogs fans got more info on his JS?

What's held him back in the past is his tank, so 96% TOG in the preseason match is a great sign. Some fans reckon he and Coffield will be fighting for the same spot once O'Donnell is back which is possible. Personally I think we can play them both and I've got him on the bench in my side.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Missed this one yesterday.

Surprised he's playing .

 

[ubeaut]

Any info on Dempsey from Geelong?
JS / role etc
Trying to finalise my fwds and missed Campbell last night..

 

[rocker_oz33]

Any info on Dempsey from Geelong?
JS / role etc
Trying to finalise my fwds and missed Campbell last night..

Rohan out for 4 to 6 Weeks .

Will play forward .

Like any other Wookie will have to play well.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Re Cadman .
Re Mannagh.

I wish the cats played first to see if mann was the sub ...

 

[Significant]

Re Cadman .
Re Mannagh.

I wish the cats played first to see if mann was the sub ...

I think I'll keep Mannagh even if he is the sub. Looks like he will perform and get up to speed quickly, solidifying his spot in the team.

 

[JT_the_Man]

Missed this one yesterday.

And just like that, Sharp in Cadman out.

 

[Spacedog]

Hore is the Bowey replacement as Melbourne want to keep Salem in the midfield.

Hore was a good scoring rookie a few years ago.

Isn’t Hore replacing Tomlinson who was dropped? I think Salem will still end up playing back

 

[Scythe94]

Isn’t Hore replacing Tomlinson who was dropped? I think Salem will still end up playing back

Unsure atm. They may end up using Hore to replace Bowey and the ghost of Tom McDonald to replace Tomlinson. Keep an eye on the teams tonight.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I think I'll keep Mannagh even if he is the sub. Looks like he will perform and get up to speed quickly, solidifying his spot in the team.

It's mann , 2E or MOC for the vest IMO.

I guess I can just hold and make the changing in 2 weeks .

 

[ForeverHardcore]

It's mann , 2E or MOC for the vest IMO.

I guess I can just hold and make the changing in 2 weeks .

Good thing if he’s sub and has a few low scores he’ll be a decent downgrade price still in a few weeks

I’m avoiding for this week

 

[rocker_oz33]

Unsure atm. They may end up using Hore to replace Bowey and the ghost of Tom McDonald to replace Tomlinson. Keep an eye on the teams tonight.

Can the ghost of T Mac even move or get into a trot....

 

[rocker_oz33]

Good thing if he’s sub and has a few low scores he’ll be a decent downgrade price still in a few weeks

I’m avoiding for this week

Given he's Low tog in the praccy match smells sub to me.
He's already cheap at 117...but a couple sub games to get up to speed of the game .
He-ll score decent imo.

 

[ubeaut]

QUOTE="rocker_oz33, post: 82669957, member: 41722"]
Rohan out for 4 to 6 Weeks .

Will play forward .

Like any other Wookie will have to play well.
[/QUOTE]
Cheers

Would you pick Dempsey over Mannagh?
Or the reverse?

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Given he's Low tog in the praccy match smells sub to me.
He's already cheap at 117...but a couple sub games to get up to speed of the game .
He-ll score decent imo.

Yeah will be a beauty
Sad we didn’t draft him

 

[rocker_oz33]

QUOTE="rocker_oz33, post: 82669957, member: 41722"]
Rohan out for 4 to 6 Weeks .

Will play forward .

Like any other Wookie will have to play well.

Cheers

Would you pick Dempsey over Mannagh?
Or the reverse?
[/QUOTE]

Wow you butchered that quote up lol.

Mannagh likey to be the sub but not confirmed.

I'm hoping Dempsey gets a good run of games ..

Or find 20k get Windsor type ..

 

[Blackhawk42]

Anyone else considering Buku Khamis for the last forward rookie spot? Don't want Cadman as already have Flanders/Sexton. Named CHB and scored 60 in pre-season. Any dogs fans got more info on his JS?

Swapped Campbell to him before the Tigers game started last night.

Have a feeling he'll do okay. The potential fwd/def swing will be handy too if all goes to plan.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Swapped Campbell to him before the Tigers game started last night.

Have a feeling he'll do okay. The potential fwd/def swing will be handy too if all goes to plan.

I like him ...

But Bevo kinda puts me off