Trades 2024 Round 2 Trades

[rocker_oz33]

Yeah, think I'll go Terry Berry, can get to him fairly easily. Dimma seems to be pumping his tyres up.
Bye Rd slightly unsaucy.

Biggest tradeout the week for Scoops:
Out: 4 bastard pine trees on the old.man's property.
s**t wood, non-natives, spiky, horrible bastards to chop down and chop up.
Gunna massacre a couple more of the pricks later on before watching us cop another touch up tanite.

Kill them scoops .

Enjoy a cold one after wards.

 

[Elixuh]

Laz to T Berry
Gibcus to Hore

Next week I’ll bring in Massimo for Reid.

 

[rocker_oz33]

True, but I don't want to field 21 players

It's only best 18..


Are you the type of judge that brings a keg of beer to the party when they said BYO.
Everyone else brings a slab ..

 

[JuddgementDay]

It's only best 18..


Are you the type of judge that brings a keg of beer to the party when they said BYO.
Everyone else brings a slab ..

 

[rocker_oz33]

Fisher > Billings locked in

For the other, is it better to trade Lazzaro or Gibcus to Tom Berry

If I trade Gibcus, then I'm moving in from someone who definitely needs to be moved on, but I lose any d > m link which may be handy next week.

Alternatively, if I trade Lazzaro, I may miss a spike game from a player with JS and don't get to see a second game of data...

Decisions....

I don't know your team .
I guess you have enough players

Gibcus dead .
Lazz playing .

I'm keeping Laz and will move him next week for someone you can football better.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Fisher > Billings locked in

For the other, is it better to trade Lazzaro or Gibcus to Tom Berry

If I trade Gibcus, then I'm moving in from someone who definitely needs to be moved on, but I lose any d > m link which may be handy next week.

Alternatively, if I trade Lazzaro, I may miss a spike game from a player with JS and don't get to see a second game of data...

Decisions....

No harm keeping Lazzaro another week, his price isn't changing.

Gibcus has to go.

You'll get you DPP link back after round 6.

 

[rocker_oz33]

 

[ubeaut]

Any advice on trades please guys?
I'm stuck ATM

 

[THE_GUN]

Probably not, just the fact I don't like KPP. Might be one of those that got away picks given how good GWS look this year.

That was also my thinking last year until Tex Walker totally destroyed that theory and was wishing i went with my gut

Hogan has always been a good scorer in SC and the way i look at it if he makes me $150k-$170k and a Keeper like Toby Green / J.McCrae drop in price or a gun mid gets DP it will be an easy trade to gain an extra keeper whilst getting a regular score

 

[Elixuh]

No harm keeping Lazzaro another week, his price isn't changing.

Gibcus has to go.

You'll get you DPP link back after round 6.

But T Berrys is, seems the better value for cash generation?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

But T Berrys is, seems the better value for cash generation?

Seems the best option this week.

 

[54Dogs]

Would like Berry but with too many Rd 3s already prob need to pass. Will grab Dempsey next week if he looks good again. Would also like another look at Mass but prob need to move Gibcus or Reid this week

 

[Lord De Goey]

That was also my thinking last year until Tex Walker totally destroyed that theory and was wishing i went with my gut

Hogan has always been a good scorer in SC and the way i look at it if he makes me $150k-$170k and a Keeper like Toby Green / J.McCrae drop in price or a gun mid gets DP it will be an easy trade to gain an extra keeper whilst getting a regular score

He’s averaged over 90 once and it was 6 years ago?

 

[Elixuh]

Would like Berry but with too many Rd 3s already prob need to pass. Will grab Dempsey next week if he looks good again. Would also like another look at Mass but prob need to move Gibcus or Reid this week

Could move to hore who doesn’t have a bye until rd 6 and Bowey injury

Then move Reid to mas next week

 

[doggies ftw]

With no real need to make any trades this week (already have Heeney, missed the boat on Flanders, Rowell, green etc and will have to wait til after byes) only Reid not playing who can wait til next week when other options come up.

Do I trade Lazz to Berry for cash gen, or keep the trade (meaning one week down with no trades ) Lazz will likely make money over the next few weeks too you’d think but not as much or as quick as Berry - is that worth a trade?

 

[Elixuh]

Is it better to keep Laz and trade out Clark from Geelong? Moving Wilson mid and then trading in T Berry.

 

[54Dogs]

Could move to hore who doesn’t have a bye until rd 6 and Bowey injury

Then move Reid to mas next week

Already have Hore and Howes, not excited by any other low end guys

 

[AFDogs]

View attachment 1934505
Any advice on trades please guys?
I'm stuck ATM

Similar situation to me. How much cash you got in the bank?

Gibcus > Hore. Could do Laz > Berry also. But you might want to back Laz in for another week.

 

[blueiris]

I am not sure about “forgetting” anything. That score was the reason why many jumped on him.

“Contextualising” may be the better term. Preseason ultimately means nothing if you can’t replicate it when it matters.

So it comes down to, do you hold and hope or do you recognise the role isn’t there?

From my perspective it’s better to move on earlier rather than holding and hoping it may eventuate. Especially when it’s early in the season, cash generation is paramount, and there appears to be so many options around.



Maybe. But seeing the mistakes that are there and the various options available to rectify, the most creative and sensible thing to do might be to jump on someone a week earlier than you otherwise may have.



No, he’s not for this week.

Next week though I don’t see an issue with it. You don’t always have to wait for someone to be ‘on the bubble’.

That’s not always possible and you can shoot yourself in the foot and miss out on a good cash generator if you sit and wait.

Answerth could be a handy pod with both Coleman and McKenna out for awhile

 

[DT_35]

Will probably go:
Fisher > Billings
Gibcus > Massimo

Watch for next week:
Dempsey, Steele, Bonner, Hore, Fyfe

On the block next week:
Reid (inj), Martin, Clark

Thoughts(

 

[marcmurphy3]

Will probably go:
Fisher > Billings
Gibcus > Massimo

Watch for next week:
Dempsey, Steele, Bonner, Hore, Fyfe

On the block next week:
Reid (inj), Martin, Clark

Thoughts(

I'm doing the same but boosting to go Martin to Serong

 

[BuckleysBrigade]

As a fellow Amon owner (who watched the game closely), happy to share my analysis (to be taken with a grain of salt)...

Mass definately did take a few of his chips as I suspect both players will be looked for exiting from defence (4 rebound 50's each). However, it was a weird game in that despite Essendon winning, the Hawthorn backline didn't see a lot of the ball. A lot of the game was played between the arcs or in the Hawthorn forward half, with McGrath (and Martin) getting plenty of the ball but turning it over a lot, only for Hawthorn to give it back or kick a behind (28 scoring shots for the Hawks and +6 inside 50's). When Essendon did go forward, it was being walked out of the front half of stoppages and centre clearances, meaning they were having shots from 50 out rather than it being kicked into (or staying in) their forwardline. This can be seen for all of the Hawthorn defenders. Sicily averaged over 26 touches last season and had just 11 this game. Scrimshaw has averaged between 17-20 touches the last 3 years and only had 9. Hardwick averaged 20 last year and had 13, etc, etc. I suspect in most games in '24, the ball will spend a lot more time in Hawthorn's backline than it did last weekend (unfortunately I think in plenty of games the ball will 'live' down there).

Even if the above analysis is off the mark, Essendon kicked 17 goals 5. That is highly unusual accuracy. Amon took 60% of the kick outs on the weekend but with so few behinds, it only translated to 2 extra kicks from a SC perspective and he still scored 89. With a more normal scoreline of say 12 goals 10, he would have had another 3-5 extra effective kicks and scored 100+. We have Melbourne this week who are both a better team (more time in our backline) and a more inaccurate one (more kick ins).

I still think that Amon will likely average 95-110, play every game (with 1 bye) and be an underpriced keeper in our backlines with DPP.

Wonderful insight, thanks for taking the time. You’ve actually managed to put a positive spin on last week’s sh!thousery

 

[Elixuh]

Wonderful insight, thanks for taking the time. You’ve actually managed to put a positive spin on last week’s sh!thousery


View attachment 1934550

Too soon. Vale big Kev.

 

[rye]

Gibcus --> hore
(if dropped) Clark --> berry

 

[THE_GUN]

Everyone ripping their hair out to find a way to get Peeney in…

Then Parker and Adams and eventually Mills come back and the kent goes back to the forward pocket and spuds the rest of the year- seen this episode before…

OR !!!

He smashes until then and gets to $650k as well as DPP and you can flick him to somebody like Oliver/Neal/Green etc who's price might drop.