2024 (Tenacious) Annual Carlton Board Phantom Draft

[TENACIOUS]

https://s.afl.com.au/staticfile/AFL Tenant/AFL/Files/Father-son-bidding-system.pdf

Pick	Club	Player (click on player below, will take you to post)	Poster
1	Richmond	Jagga Smith	Bletch
2	Brisbane *	Levi Ashcroft	Sheephead
3	Richmond	Sam Lalor	Bletch
4	Carlton	Harvey Langford	Soapy V
5	Adelaide	Sid Draper	GoBlues!
6	Melbourne	Finn O’Sullivan	Blugazi
7	North Melbourne	Alix Tauru	Blue and Silver
8	Gold Coast *	Leo Lombard
9	St Kilda	Josh Smillie	Ninja Worrier
10	St Kilda	Xavier Lyndsay	Ninja Worrier
11	Melbourne	Murphy Reid	Blugazi
12	Essendon *	Issac Kako	TENACIOUS
13	Richmond	Tobie Travaglia	Bletch
14	Richmond	Taj Hotton	Bletch
15	West Coast	Joe Berry	TerryWallet
16	Port Adelaide	Luke Trainor	Pablito
17	Fremantle	Bo Allan	WalshistheGOAT
18	Greater Western Sydney	Cooper Hynes	bradfisher14
19	Greater Western Sydney	Oli Hannaford	bradfisher14
20	Brisbane *	Sam Marshall
21	Western Bulldogs	Harrison Oliver	Coona Blues
22	North Melbourne	Jobe Shanahan	Blue and Silver
23	Sydney	Harry Armstong	Wickzki
24	Richmond	Jack Whitlock	Bletch
25	Greater Western Sydney	Alex Dodson	bradfisher14
26	Sydney	Jesse Dattoli	Wickzki
27	Richmond	Jonty Faull	Bletch
28	Richmond	Jasper Algar	Bletch
	Round 2
29	Western Bulldogs	James Barrat	Coona Blues
30	Essendon	Christian Moraes	TENACIOUS
31	West Coast	Hamish Davies	TerryWallet
32	Port Adelaide	Angus Clarke	Pablito
33	Fremantle	Zak Johnson	WalshistheGOAT
34	St Kilda	Tom Gross	Ninja Worrier
35	Hawthorn	Harry Charleston
36	West Coast *	Malaki Champion	TerryWallet
37	Western Bulldogs	Jack Ough	Coona Blues
38	Carlton *	Ben Camporeale	Soapy V
39	Port Adelaide	Jaxon Artemis	Pablito
40	Greater Western Sydney	Lochie Jaques	bradfisher14
41	Sydney	Matt Whitlock	Wickzki
42	Geelong	Clancy Dennis	ferrisb
43	Essendon	Harry O’Farrell	TENACIOUS
44	St Kilda *	Adrian Cole	Ninja Worrier
45	Western Bulldogs	Kayle Gerreyn	Coona Blues
46	Port Adelaide	Phoenix Hargrave	Pablito
	Round 3
47	Collingwood	Ned Bowman	Bamboo Harvester
48	Essendon	Thomas Sims	TENACIOUS
49	Essendon	Pass	TENACIOUS
50	Collingwood	Sam Davidson	Bamboo Harvester
51	Greater Western Sydney	Pass	bradfisher14
52	Carlton	Pass	Soapy V
53	Geelong	Xavier Ivisic	ferrisb
54	Collingwood	Noah Mraz	Bamboo Harvester
55	Sydney	Luke Urquhart	Wickzki
56	North Melbourne	Nathaniel Sulzberger	Blue and Silver
57	Adelaide *	Tyler Welsh	GoBlues!
58	Essendon	Pass	TENACIOUS
59	Fremantle	Benny Barrett	WalshistheGOAT
60	Carlton	Pass	Soapy V
61	Carlton	Pass	Soapy V
62	Hawthorn	Kade Herbert
63	Carlton	Boyd	Soapy V
64	Greater Western Sydney	Pass	bradfisher14
65	Geelong	Pass	ferrisb
66	Hawthorn	Pass
67	North Melbourne	Pass	Blue and Silver
68	Adelaide	Pass	GoBlues!
69	Melbourne	Archer Day-Wicks	Blugazi
70	Gold Coast	Pass
71	Gold Coast	Pass
72	Brisbane	Pass	Sheephead
73	West Coast	Keighton Matofai	TerryWallet

Pre Season Draft / DFA
(fill up you senior lists)

Pick	Club	Player	Poster
1	Collingwood	Tim Membrey
2	Carlton	Ethan Phillips	Soapy V
3	Greater Western Sydney	Ben Paton	bradfisher14
4	Geelong	Jack Martin	Coona Blues
5	Brisbane	Sam Day	Sheephead
6	Collingwood	Adam Tomlinson	Bamboo Harvester
7	Carlton	Coby Burgiel	Soapy V

Rookie Draft

Pick	Club	Player	Poster
1	Richmond	Josh Dolan	Bletch
2	North Melbourne	Nash King	Blue and Silver
3	West Coast	Pass	TerryWallet
4	Adelaide	Lucas Impey	GoBlues!
5	Melbourne	Rhys Unwin	Blugazi
6	Gold Coast	Sam Durdin
7	St Kilda	Brad Crouch	Ninja Worrier
8	Essendon	Gabriel Stumpf	TENACIOUS
9	Fremantle	Noah Cumberland	WalshistheGOAT
10	Collingwood	Will Hayes	Bamboo Harvester
11	Carlton	Liam McMahon	soapy
12	Western Bulldogs	Jacob Newton	Coona Blues
13	Hawthorn	Jack Gunston
14	Greater Western Sydney	Josh Fahey	bradfisher14
15	Geelong	Lachlan Blackiston	Coona Blues
16	Port Adelaide	Charlie West	Pablito
17	Sydney	Ollie Warburton	Wickzki
18	Brisbane	Darragh Joyce	Sheephead
19	Richmond	Pass	Bletch
20	North Melbourne	Riley Bice	Blue and Silver
21	Adelaide	Pass	GoBlues!
22	Melbourne	Sam Toner	Blugazi
23	Gold Coast	Pass
24	St Kilda *	Lennox Hoffman	Ninja Worrier
25	Essendon	Waylon Davies-Motlop	TENACIOUS
26	Fremantle	Pass	WalshistheGOAT
27	Collingwood	Oleg Markov	Bamboo Harvester
28	Carlton	Asher Eastham	Soapy V
29	Western Bulldogs	Max Knobel	Coona Blues
30	Hawthorn	Pass
31	Greater Western Sydney	Lachie Keeffe	bradfisher14
32	Geelong	Marcus Herbert	Coona Blues
33	Port Adelaide		Pablito
34	Sydney	Joel Hammling	Wickzki
35	Brisbane	Darcy Craven	Sheephead
36	North Melbourne	Toby Pink	Blue and Silver
37	Essendon		TENACIOUS
38	Collingwood	Ash Johnson	Bamboo Harvester
39	Carlton *	Lucas Camporeale	Soapy V
40	Greater Western Sydney	Jacob Wehr	bradfisher14
41	North Melbourne *	River Stevens	Blue and Silver
42	Greater Western Sydney *	Logan Smith	bradfisher14
43	Essendon		TENACIOUS
44	Sydney	Aaron Francis	Wickzki

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

Going for a smokey here, Melbourne select Sam Toner from Dandenong Stingrays. An overage forward he kicked bags of goal once he got to the CTL.

SToner

 

[TENACIOUS]

Essendon - Waylon Davies-Motlop - 171 Small Forward.

Soapy V Blues are up

 

[Soapy V]

Carlton - Asher Eastham 188cm Gippsland Power

A move from Attack to Defence put this kid on the radar for me. Reads the ball well, very good mark and looks a natural interceptor. He was able to read the ball in flight and peel off to take excellent intercept marks. Eastham will find improvement once he builds a better running capacity to roam further up the ground and help connect the lines. It'll make him a more consistent four-quarter performer, too.

I hope he adds a few centimetres

Eastham most often catches the eye with exciting glimpses or short purple patches of form. His highlight reel is terrific, featuring overhead marks at full stretch and classy finishes on goal.

Consistency is the knock on him but has good traits to build on. Tested impressively at the Draft Combine, posting 2.98 seconds on the 20m sprint and 8.25 seconds on the agility test.

My take is he is a late developer and worth the punt

 

[TENACIOUS]

Coona Blues Dogs then Cats are up

 

[TENACIOUS]

Could you please advise if you have any further picks, then what is on the above list


Brisbane: Sheephead
Collingwood: Bamboo Harvester
Essendon: TENACIOUS
Fremantle: WalshistheGOAT
Geelong: Coona Blues
GWS: bradfisher14
Melbourne: Blugazi
North Melbourne: Blue and Silver
Port Adelaide: Pablito
Sydney: Wickzki
West Coast: TerryWallet
Western Bulldogs: Coona Blues

 

[Blugazi]

No more for Melb I believe

 

[Coona Blues]

Let’s give Western Bulldigs Max Knobel 206cm Victorian (Gippsland Power) 20 yo lad delisted from Freo

and


Geelong add from their reserves Marcus Herbert 24yo emerging midfielder as is their way regarding players from their state league lineup

 

[Sheephead]

I think BRI are done.

 

[TerryWallet]

WC are done.

 

[Ninja Worrier]

I think I may have left St Kilda short but don't really care

 

[TENACIOUS]

Looks like we are done!

Thank you to all of you who contributed and look forward to next year when Carlton would have had pick 18!

 

[Wickzki]

Looks like we are done!

Thank you to all of you who contributed and look forward to next year when Carlton would have had pick 18!

Sydney had another selection (if not two) but committed to their two depth KPDs and instead of Warburtonn may end up with a DFA like Cunningham.


Thanks for running this again mate. Good job. Nice drafting.

So who do people think did well other than their own?

 

[bradfisher14]

So who do people think did well other than their own?

Swans and Bombers the two best for me.

 

[TENACIOUS]

Sydney had another selection (if not two) but committed to their two depth KPDs and instead of Warburtonn may end up with a DFA like Cunningham.


Thanks for running this again mate. Good job. Nice drafting.

So who do people think did well other than their own?

Bombers still had 2 also. Let me know who you would like to select and I’ll chuck them in

 

[Wickzki]

Bombers still had 2 also. Let me know who you would like to select and I’ll chuck them in

Swans reportedly promised the two veteran defenders that they delisted they'd rookie them so makes it simple.

 

[TENACIOUS]

Swans reportedly promised the two veteran defenders that they delisted they'd rookie them so makes it simple.

Who were they I’ll add them on

 

[Wickzki]

Who were they I’ll add them on

Hamling and Francis

I would've let them both go but will keep them realistic given the public promises.

 

[beowulf]

Carlton - Asher Eastham 188cm Gippsland Power

A move from Attack to Defence put this kid on the radar for me. Reads the ball well, very good mark and looks a natural interceptor. He was able to read the ball in flight and peel off to take excellent intercept marks. Eastham will find improvement once he builds a better running capacity to roam further up the ground and help connect the lines. It'll make him a more consistent four-quarter performer, too.

I hope he adds a few centimetres

Eastham most often catches the eye with exciting glimpses or short purple patches of form. His highlight reel is terrific, featuring overhead marks at full stretch and classy finishes on goal.

Consistency is the knock on him but has good traits to build on. Tested impressively at the Draft Combine, posting 2.98 seconds on the 20m sprint and 8.25 seconds on the agility test.

My take is he is a late developer and worth the punt

As a late developer, Eastham might miss out on the draft. If he does, I'd be inviting him to play VFL in the hope of promoting him at the Mid-year draft. It is a tactic we've tried a bit over the last couple of years: McMahon and Will White come to mind. Granted, we bombed out with Tyson Sruk and Michael Rudd, but I still like the idea as a concept.

 

[ferrisb]

Will take Riley Bice.

A footballer first, good user, run and carry back man.

Athletically might struggle, but I will back him to overcome limitations and get to implement his skills.

Left footer too, which is always nice.

Next pick will be Toby Pink, unless someone else takes him

I can't see this name and not think it's Bailey Rice trying to get redrafted incognito...

 

[ferrisb]

Essendon Pick - Gabriel Stumpf - KPF

Mobile tall forward with lightning speed off the mark and strong hands overhead.

I can't believe no one stumpfed up for him in the national draft...

 

[Bletch]

Bletch: Smith, Lalor, Travaglia, Hotton, J Whitlock, Faull, Alger, Dolan.
Tiggers: Lalor, Smillie, Hotton, Faull, Trainor, Armstrong, Sims, Alger.

Happy with a 50% hit rate!

 

[Wickzki]

Using our phantom draft as a measurement:

Accumulative Draft Value

positive points if you drafted them after they were selected in the National Draft

negative points if you drafted them before they were selected in the national draft

NO points awarded or penalised for a successful bid match as where someone else ranked them is out of your team's control.

First Round

1 - Richmond - Jagga Smith -2
2 - Brisbane - Levi Asshcroft - 0 (match bid)
3 - Richmond - Sam Lalor +2
4 - Harvey Langford - -2
5 - Adelaide - Sid Draper 0
6 - Melbourne - Finn O'Sullivan +3
7 - North Melbourne - Alix Tauru -3
8 - Gold Coast - Leo Lombard 0 (match bid)
9 - St Kilda - Josh Smilie +2
10 - St Kilda - Xavier Lindsay -1
11 - Melbourne - Murphy Reed -6
12 - Essendon - Isaac Kako (match bid)
13 - Richmond - Tobie Travaglia +5
14 - Richmond - Taj Hotton +2
15 - West Coast - Joe Berry 0
16 - Port Adelaide - Luke Trainor -5
17 - Fremantle - Bo Allen +1
18 - GWS - Cooper Hynes -2
19 -GWS - Oli Hannaford +1
20 - Brisbane - Sam Marshall (bid match) 0
21 - Western Bulldogs - Harry Oliver +2
22 - North Melbourne - Jobe Shanahan -8
23 - Sydney - Harry Armstrong 0
24 - Richmond - Jack Whitlock -9
25 - GWS - Alex Dodson -28
26 - Sydney - Jesse Dattoli +4
27 - Richmond - Jonty Faull +13
28 - Richmond - Jasper Algar -30

First Round Leaderboard

Sydney 4
Western Bulldogs 2
St Kilda 1
Fremantle 1
Adelaide 0
Brisbane 0 (2x match bid)
Adelaide 0
Gold Coast 0 (match bid)
Essendon 0 (match bid)
West Coast 0
Carlton -2
Melbourne -3
Port Adeladie -5
North Melbourne -11
Richmond -19
GWS -29


Correct teams

Brisbane Levi Ashcroft*, Sam Marshall*
Adelaide Sid Draper
Essendon Isaac Kako*
Gold Coast Leo Lombard*
GWS Oli Hannaford
Sydney Jesse Dattoli
Richmond Sam Lalor, Taj Hotton, Jonty Faull, Jasper Alger

Total: 7 non-bid matched correct teams. 11 in total


The Alger pick, although accurate team, is what has hurt Richmond in the "closest to the pin" but that's outstanding selecting 4 first round picks.

I'll work on finishing all drafts over the weekend.