List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II

[Harris 10]

While I think he has limitations, Bice would not look out of place on our list. Lovely kick.

Size and strength are two which could easily be fixed in an AFL system.

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

While I think he has limitations, Bice would look out of place on our list. Lovely kick.

EFA

 

[jay317]

Excellent source, something would have to change dramatically for it not to.

That's what we were told about Dusty...

 

[The Nostradamus]

Parker is almost certainly joining us!

hopefully with Konstanty coming with him

 

[New_Roo]

Excellent source, something would have to change dramatically for it not to.

Would either winning the GF or not winning the GF affect it


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Disco Dew]

Excellent source, something would have to change dramatically for it not to.

Oh I’ve seen this one before!

It’s ok though, I’m prepared to get hurt again

 

[DocSholl]

Size and strength are two which could easily be fixed in an AFL system.

Not in ours

 

[iloveireland]

Oh I’ve seen this one before!

It’s ok though, I’m prepared to get hurt again

Should be a mandatory tick box when renewing a NMFC membership

 

[Shinboner1]

Size and strength are two which could easily be fixed in an AFL system.

just dont tell bergman

 

[The Y Factor]

Houston is flat out not worth the price we would need to pay.
Not against the idea in theory but if we are giving up a likely top 3 pick it has to be for the right player.

Do you believe that North at the moment can attract double All Australian calibre players?

Do you believe that if a slight opportunity presented itself it would be anything less that full price?

Do you believe that North would back itself in to be better next year with another pick 2, Parker, Darling and Huston?

If you answer No, No and yes - then it’s a great deal.

 

[The Y Factor]

Oh I’ve seen this one before!

It’s ok though, I’m prepared to get hurt again

It’s trade season baby!! Let’s go!

For what it’s worth , every “in the know’ type I’ve spoken to are saying it’s a done deal.

I’m with you though - let’s see

 

[The Talent Scout]

Size and strength are two which could easily be fixed in an AFL system.

Curtis Taylor hates this!

 

[shinboner magic]

I’m a bit torn with this one, I think we overvalue picks but also want 200 games from a top five pick. Maybe a future first with their future first coming back.

That’s a guaranteed 100 games against a hopeful 200 gamer

 

[TurnoverMerchant]

While I think he has limitations, Bice would not look out of place on our list. Lovely kick.

With a lovely kick, I think he would look quite out of place on our list.

 

[North1411]

Houston is flat out not worth the price we would need to pay.
Not against the idea in theory but if we are giving up a likely top 3 pick it has to be for the right player.

We won't get him, they are just using us to pump up the price. Normal state of play for the last 10 years

 

[The Y Factor]

We won't get him, they are just using us to pump up the price. Normal state of play for the last 10 years

I don’t think the issue is how much he is getting - all offering good coin.

He wants to come home to Victoria and needs Port to be happy with the compensation.

Turns out, the clubs interested have bugger all currency.

So - drum roll …. North are in the conversation as one of the only clubs able to seal the deal with Port.

he may not want to come to us but let’s see where this ride takes us.

 

[North1411]

I don’t think the issue is how much he is getting - all offering good coin.

He wants to come home to Victoria and needs Port to be happy with the compensation.

Turns out, the clubs interested have bugger all currency.

So - drum roll …. North are in the conversation as one of the only clubs able to seal the deal with Port.

he may not want to come to us but let’s see where this ride takes us.

I understand your point, I was not talking about coin I was talking about trade value. We may get him, but I feel we are still being used for the other clubs to pony up their picks

 

[BlueandWhiteinmyBlood]

Ably supported by Lachie Hosie with two goals

North legend.

 

[Makeshift Park]

We won't get him, they are just using us to pump up the price.

 

[DrZaius]

Do you believe that North at the moment can attract double All Australian calibre players?

Do you believe that if a slight opportunity presented itself it would be anything less that full price?

Do you believe that North would back itself in to be better next year with another pick 2, Parker, Darling and Huston?

If you answer No, No and yes - then it’s a great deal.

Don't really care how many times he has been AA.
He is an above average HBF with an elite kick, but that's not someone you give up a top 3 pick for.

 

[Makeshift Park]

He is an above average HBF with an elite kick, but that's not someone you give up a top 3 pick for.

How many back flankers playing today would you prefer to have?

 

[DrZaius]

How many back flankers playing today would you prefer to have?

None that I would give up a top 3 pick for.

 

[The Y Factor]

I understand your point, I was not talking about coin I was talking about trade value. We may get him, but I feel we are still being used for the other clubs to pony up their picks

Yeah ok - probably yes ! but from what’s reported, they don’t have anything.

So that puts us in a legit play to leverage the opportunity to either improve our draft hand or snag a Top tier player.

 

[The Y Factor]

Don't really care how many times he has been AA.
He is an above average HBF with an elite kick, but that's not someone you give up a top 3 pick for.

That’s just your opinion.

So you believe no matter what we finish bottom 3 next year?

Even with a good draft and trade result?

 

[DrZaius]

That’s just your opinion.

So you believe no matter what we finish bottom 3 next year?

Even with a good draft and trade result?

It would be a miraculous turnaround to get anything more than 5-6 wins next year which would still most likely see us in the bottom 4.

Again, someone like Houston would barely move the needle for us. He had a good year but is being severely overrated.