List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II

[Kangaroos4eva]

The melts have begun and we still have weeks before the trade season starts. Love it!

Bring this one out every trade season.

 

[DrZaius]

That’s just your opinion.

So you believe no matter what we finish bottom 3 next year?

Even with a good draft and trade result?

It would be a miraculous turnaround to get anything more than 5-6 wins next year which would still most likely see us in the bottom 4.

Again, someone like Houston would barely move the needle for us. He had a good year but is being severely overrated.

 

[kool kangas]

It would be a miraculous turnaround to get anything more than 5-6 wins next year which would still most likely see us in the bottom 4.

Again, someone like Houston would barely move the needle for us. He had a good year but is being severely overrated.

but what about if Houston is combined with Parker, Darling, Konstanty and maybe 1 other coming across as well?

 

[Scottroo]

People seriously over rate draft picks.

For every Sheezal there’s a Tsatas or dare I saw, Will Phillips.

 

[DrZaius]

but what about if Houston is combined with Parker, Darling, Konstanty and maybe 1 other coming across as well?

We brought in Logue, Shiels & Tucker in one off-season and it didn't do much for us. They may improve us somewhat but thinking that adding two players at the end of their careers, a guy who hasn't even played a game yet, and a HBF will jumpstart our performances by a significant amount is wishful thinking IMO.

If we trade a top 3 pick it should be for a match winner.

 

[King Hansen]

We brought in Logue, Shiels & Tucker in one off-season and it didn't do much for us. They may improve us somewhat but thinking that adding two players at the end of their careers, a guy who hasn't even played a game yet, and a HBF will jumpstart our performances by a significant amount is wishful thinking IMO.

If we trade a top 3 pick it should be for a match winner.

Lucky Houston is a match winner then.

 

[tales129]

We brought in Logue, Shiels & Tucker in one off-season and it didn't do much for us. They may improve us somewhat but thinking that adding two players at the end of their careers, a guy who hasn't even played a game yet, and a HBF will jumpstart our performances by a significant amount is wishful thinking IMO.

If we trade a top 3 pick it should be for a match winner.

 

[Junk yard]

We brought in Logue, Shiels & Tucker in one off-season and it didn't do much for us. They may improve us somewhat but thinking that adding two players at the end of their careers, a guy who hasn't even played a game yet, and a HBF will jumpstart our performances by a significant amount is wishful thinking IMO.

If we trade a top 3 pick it should be for a match winner.

The way we've picked for the last ten years I think we should be happy with a dual all Australian at the peak of his powers.

 

[iloveireland]

That’s just your opinion.

So you believe no matter what we finish bottom 3 next year?

Even with a good draft and trade result?

I think it’s likely, and you have to trade future picks based on likely outcomes.

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

 

[bennymate]

Parker is almost certainly joining us!

Excellent source, something would have to change dramatically for it not to.

 

[THE_GUN]

View attachment 2118850View attachment 2118852

You guys would be crazy to not offer Balta crazy overs next year as a free agent
CHB problems solved for the next 6-7 years and could swing foward when required. Would be a perfect fit

was discussing this with a north mate just 2 weeks ago and he said he would love it but North wouldnt do it