List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm not getting excited about this SDK rumour. But I would absolutely take him.

Logue has been injured for 12 months. Comben has a long injury history. Wil Dawson is a project.

If all three work out and are healthy at the time then we'll figure it out and play one up forward.
 
Ralph saying that Harley Reid’s management wants $2m for his 4th season from West Coast as compensation for unders for the first 3 for a single year extension.

Ralph also said Essendon will offer $18m over 10 years to his management.

This is going to cook the Eagles 😂

Dunno which paragraph is more insane.

One major injury and you run the risk of crippling your salary cap for a decade. Going to be wild when he comes out of contract
 
Ralph saying that Harley Reid’s management wants $2m for his 4th season from West Coast as compensation for unders for the first 3 for a single year extension.

Ralph also said Essendon will offer $18m over 10 years to his management.

This is going to cook the Eagles 😂
Sounds like ralphy is making shit up tbh
 

Log in to remove this ad.

It’s how the system is supposed to work. It is barely compensation considering our situation where our list, bereft of experience will take further cuts to its average games played.
Exactly, im not sure why its so hard for people to grasp. The system was designed for more balance across the league. The thinking lower teams with cap space could make plays on players from the top teams. If top teams are taking from bottom teams then the bottom teams need MASSIVE overs to make up for it.
 
He said it was a terrible deal for Geelong, so of course we would take it.

But it's a terrible deal for Geelong, so they wouldn't offer it.

Is this clear enough?
Exactly! If SDK were a North player being discussed there would be nuffies on this board saying he alone is worth two top-ten picks.
 
Ralph saying that Harley Reid’s management wants $2m for his 4th season from West Coast as compensation for unders for the first 3 for a single year extension.

Ralph also said Essendon will offer $18m over 10 years to his management.

This is going to cook the Eagles 😂
1.8m a year, bloody hell.
Not sure how they could afford that, not even sure we could for one player. The star power factor would be worth a fair bit to a club, but you still have to make it work with a quality team under a salary cap.
Then the trade cost would be huge.
 
Ralph saying that Harley Reid’s management wants $2m for his 4th season from West Coast as compensation for unders for the first 3 for a single year extension.

Ralph also said Essendon will offer $18m over 10 years to his management.

This is going to cook the Eagles 😂

Wait, 18 mil over 10 year is a bargain buy because inflation is such that every 3 years would go up by quite a large chunk.

Harley would earn so much more if he did a 10 year with 3 contract signings...
 
1.8m a year, bloody hell.
Not sure how they could afford that, not even sure we could for one player. The star power factor would be worth a fair bit to a club, but you still have to make it work with a quality team under a salary cap.
Then the trade cost would be huge.

Im not sure where they are pulling these numbers from...jeez.

Last time there was a 10 year, it was alistair lynch.
 
I was just about to inquire about the legitamacy of this one...

If it's 6 years then with the $$$ per year, definitely band 1 compo.

Man, pick 3 for mckay had many calling bs on the free agency, imaging getting possible pick 2 or 3 for zooooohaaaaa...
I don’t think length of contract impacts compensation. It would actually be better for it to be a shorter contract length on more money per year if we were after band 1 compensation
 
Dunno which paragraph is more insane.

One major injury and you run the risk of crippling your salary cap for a decade. Going to be wild when he comes out of contract

It's the bombers we are talking and i wonder who's the coach, oh yeah that dude.

They think they are not only in the window but an imminent dynasty hence getting in a batch of 'star' players will be the icing on the cake even though it's a scone...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I don’t think length of contract impacts compensation. It would actually be better for it to be a shorter contract length on more money per year if we were after band 1 compensation

And also age of the player right? Mackay was 25 when he gone into free agency...
 
I'm not getting excited about this SDK rumour. But I would absolutely take him.

Logue has been injured for 12 months. Comben has a long injury history. Wil Dawson is a project.

If all three work out and are healthy at the time then we'll figure it out and play one up forward.

As long as comben is at chb, the chance of major injury would be less as he is in a position where he has match fitness and familiarity that also suits his skills.
 
Pick 1 of what? The PSD?

Certainly not worth anywhere near that these days.

He just hasn't put on the body size to be a KPP.

He's a 1 goal a game flanker when he plays forward and a poor mans version of Nick Blakey (minus the pace) when he plays on a half back flank.
So basically where zane is now.
 
Ralph also said Essendon will offer $18m over 10 years to his management.
If this is the sort of contractual offer that Essendon are making, I’d be asking for 4 firsts including two top 5 selections.

like an absolute insane price.

And if I was the Eagles I would take it.

Edit - can someone point to a big fish trade where the player traded in (who cost multiple firsts) made the difference in a flag side?
 
If this is the sort of contractual offer that Essendon are making, I’d be asking for 4 firsts including two top 5 selections.

like an absolute insane price.

And if I was the Eagles I would take it.

Edit - can someone point to a big fish trade where the player traded in (who cost multiple firsts) made the difference in a flag side?

Well maradonna to napoli...but thats about all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top