List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread

[FootySmartSimpson]

Got ya.

He was delisted by Adelaide, therefore, I thought free agency compensation was voided.

Absolutely ******ed that a team can be compensated after just 3 years of service from a player imo.


On SM-G991B using BigFooty.com mobile app

This Geelong you are talking about the AFL, sorry, Gold Coast gifted pick 7 the year after a premiership because they didn’t have any first rounders.

Accomodations will be made.

 

[Sphynx]

I just can’t see why you would leave your best mates when you can see improvements

Reality is, he’s unsigned at Round 16 of his contract year.

It’s probably right at the pointy end of discussions as we speak.

There’s been some late examples in recent years of re-signings, but very few.

If he’s still unsigned at the start of August, we need to accept it, just move on and start planning for next season without him.

I’d like to think we are a pretty battle hardened supporter group these days to players that want to go elsewhere.

I’d like Cam to stay, but won’t lose any sleep if he doesn’t. Just as I didn’t with McKay, as I think we are in the box seat to get overs if he does which could be viewed as a net positive in 12 months time (as it has with McKay). And to be brutally honest, we have a lot more medium forwards than we had key backs this time last year.

I’m uneasy about the 5 years on big coin as it is for him also.

 

[R00StaR]

Reality is, he’s unsigned at Round 16 of his contract year.

It’s probably right at the pointy end of discussions as we speak.

There’s been some late examples in recent years of re-signings, but very few.

If he’s still unsigned at the start of August, we need to accept it, just move on and start planning for next season without him.

I’d like to think we are a pretty battle hardened supporter group these days to players that want to go elsewhere.

I’d like Cam to stay, but won’t lose any sleep if he doesn’t. Just as I didn’t with McKay, as I think we are in the box seat to get overs if he does which could be viewed as a net positive in 12 months time (as it has with McKay). And to be brutally honest, we have a lot more medium forwards than we had key backs this time last year.

I’m uneasy about the 5 years on big coin as it is for him also.

If he does go and triggers band one (given we should be matching anything less) it would make things interesting.

Would we/ or WC entertain picks 2 and 3 for Reid? We didnt do it last year, but he's removed any doubts there might have been.

Would we use one pick and split the other as mentioned in the hypothetical Geelong/ SDK trade.

Or simply walk away with 2 of FOS, Smillie, Lalor.

 

[The Talent Scout]

If we got band 1 for Zurhaar it will be peak big footy melts.

I can tell you now West Coast and Richmond supporters will cause bigfooty to melt, remember 2021 or 2022 when bigfooty crashed because the Eagles took a half back flanker instead of a pure midfielder, Campbell Chesser, I think everyone was reading the Eagles draft thread it was so funny, one of the best nights I've had reading a forum in my life, the posts by Eagles supporters was legendary and may never be matched!

 

[DuckYeah]

If we got band 1 for Zurhaar it will be peak big footy melts.

If its band 1, but in sorry Cam but i’ll be making the same decision as I did with magoo. If its band 2 then i’ll be forcing a trade (if he wants to leave)

 

[giantroo]

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

If he does go and triggers band one (given we should be matching anything less) it would make things interesting.

Would we/ or WC entertain picks 2 and 3 for Reid? We didnt do it last year, but he's removed any doubts there might have been.

Would we use one pick and split the other as mentioned in the hypothetical Geelong/ SDK trade.

Or simply walk away with 2 of FOS, Smillie, Lalor.

If this fanciful scenario played out, and we again walk away with 2 more mids, the club is just f*cked in the head.

One mid to round out the side, but TWO could only mean the removal of not only Rawlings, but Thursfield and Viney as well…

I think there is more of a chance of Essendon winning the GF than this occurring just as a disclaimer.

But we could trade for list needs (KPF or elite small + change) or you know, actually draft a KPF.

If band 1 occurs, I would hope Rawlings gets his dealing on and we trade down for multiple picks.

 

[Danni_Benson]

Ralph saying that Harley Reid’s management wants $2m for his 4th season from West Coast as compensation for unders for the first 3 for a single year extension.

Ralph also said Essendon will offer $18m over 10 years to his management.

This is going to cook the Eagles

Not looking promising for WCE if he only wants to sign 1yr extension.

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

Not looking promising for WCE if he only wants to sign 1yr extension.

 

[Fart Cummings]

I wonder what would it be like if North got Reid, same kind of contracts be thrown around? speculation he would go to a bigger club? I think maybe not.

 

[DuckYeah]

View attachment 2030410

Wow, I thought when I read 18 x 10 million is was bullshit.. wow wee

 

[Sphynx]

I wonder what would it be like if North got Reid, same kind of contracts be thrown around? speculation he would go to a bigger club? I think maybe not.

I’m sure there would be speculation, but I doubt there would be this style blood in the water.

 

[gokangas]

As soon as someone says it's not about the money, it's about the money.

 

[Merlin007]

View attachment 2030410

Only my opinion as an old industrial relations hack, but the AFLPA really sold out draftees with the $$ limits to the mandatory three year contracts for draftees.

It's easy to get improvements for existing members when you're selling out people who are yet to join

 

[Merlin007]

View attachment 2030410

Good to see Zurhaar is happy with the club offer. We don't need the bad blood of a lowball drama

 

[Sphynx]

As soon as someone says it's not about the money, it's about the money.

100%

Generally a typical delay/holding tactic

 

[Sphynx]

Only my opinion as an old industrial relations hack, but the AFLPA really sold out draftees with the $$ limits to the mandatory three year contracts for draftees.

It's easy to get improvements for existing members when you're selling out people who are yet to join

I have yet to see it confirmed, but Eagles seem to think there’s some sort of redraw function for the 3rd year in the TPP.

Which seems completely at odds with Ralph’s article

 

[giantroo]

 

[The acurate one]

1.8 mil per season for 10 years. lol
I wouldn't pass him the ball fyi, tell him you're getting paid that much, get it yourself.
Makes the Polec deal, seem sensible.

 

[King Corey]

Bingo, maybe the worst of the lot

I felt for crows fans then and posted as much on their board.

After extracting pretty good returns for Lever and Cameron, they went down to the West Lakes pokies and pissed it all up for Gibbs.

 

[koshari]

I felt for crows fans then and posted as much on their board.

After extracting pretty good returns for Lever and Cameron, they went down to the West Lakes pokies and pissed it all up for Gibbs.

Carlton on traded the picks and eventually landed lauchie obrian, matt kennedy and TDK. So basically completed their midfield depth while also providing a tall to pair up with pittonet.

Whilst O'Brien was a bust delisted with a year to run on his contract the other 2 were hits.

The ruthlessness of chopping obrion with a year to run is the sort of list management we need with the likes of ccj.

 

[Passmore]

Personally I'd rather him spend his career at WC than *.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

 

[Kanga Glory]

Interesting the comments about zurhaar is happy with the North offer just wanting to see improvement

 

[lockheed]

For some context, the salary cap will be $17.7 M in 2025.

The average player's salary goes up from $441,464 in 2023. It's expected to be $519,000 in 2027.

 

[giantroo]

Rival clubs circling Barrass as West Coast negotiations stall

The Eagles defender is contracted until 2027.

www.sen.com.au