List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread

[The Nostradamus]

Petracca. 3rd hand info, but surprised if true that not previously mentioned on here

Would cost our top 3 pick plus our future first

Maybe with a future second coming back our way

 

[R00StaR]

Would cost our top 3 pick plus our future first

Maybe with a future second coming back our way

He's 29 before the start of next season, no way im giving up any first rounders.

Might get 3 years out of him, id much prefer Smillie, FOS, Smith or Draper for 13 years.

 

[Hojuman]

He's 29 before the start of next season, no way im giving up any first rounders.

Might get 3 years out of him, id much prefer Smillie, FOS, Smith or Draper for 13 years.

Stop making sense.

 

[tazaa]

If Melbourne decide to blow it all up and rebuild before Tassie comes in then that makes sense.
If they’re getting rid of Petracca it means Olivers also going.

But I find it very hard to believe we’re looking at Petracca and Melbourne will trade him. Hes their most valuable asset. Him out and they’re bottom 4 standard instead of top 4.
You just don’t trade players at that level.

 

[My Left Foote]

Stop making sense.

 

[Hojuman]

View attachment 2070430

Hope Petracaa's cooking better than his dancing !

 

[My Left Foote]

Oliver last year, Petracca this year some people on this board will believe anything.

 

[The Nostradamus]

He's 29 before the start of next season, no way im giving up any first rounders.

Might get 3 years out of him, id much prefer Smillie, FOS, Smith or Draper for 13 years.

Im just stating what dees would be after to trade him not whether we should do it

 

[My Left Foote]

Hope Petracaa's cooking better than his dancing !

I won't hear a bad word said about David Bryne's dancing.

 

[Hojuman]

I won't hear a bad word about David Bryne's dancing.

Well, hopefully for David Byrne's family.....
he can cook.

 

[R00StaR]

Im just stating what dees would be after to trade him not whether we should do it

 

[King Corey]

If Melbourne decide to blow it all up and rebuild before Tassie comes in then that makes sense.
If they’re getting rid of Petracca it means Olivers also going.

But I find it very hard to believe we’re looking at Petracca and Melbourne will trade him. Hes their most valuable asset. Him out and they’re bottom 4 standard instead of top 4.
You just don’t trade players at that level.

They're incredibly smart list managers, draft manipulators (in a good way) and traders.

Rather than being pricks for the sake of it * style, they tend to look a few moves ahead and dazzle sides with seemingly great offers in the here and now (Don't we know about it..).

If they initiate a trade, be bloody wary imo.

Logically they could regroup inside 1-2 seasons like a Geelong circa 2020 because they have a balanced list with several guns.

If they do look like blowing it all up like you said hypothetically, it'd be odd and need further scrutiny. You don't dismantle a premiership list 3 seasons later without very strong indicators your core is cooked.

 

[krakouers]

They're incredibly smart list managers, draft manipulators (in a good way) and traders.

Rather than being pricks for the sake of it * style, they tend to look a few moves ahead and dazzle sides with seemingly great offers in the here and now (Don't we know about it..).

If they initiate a trade, be bloody wary imo.

Logically they could regroup inside 1-2 seasons like a Geelong circa 2020 because they have a balanced list with several guns.

If they do look like blowing it all up like you said hypothetically, it'd be odd and need further scrutiny. You don't dismantle a premiership list 3 seasons later without very strong indicators your core is cooked.

Hate to say it, but any consideration of getting rid of Petracca would require an extremely detailed Medical… there may be a concern there

 

[tazaa]

They're incredibly smart list managers, draft manipulators (in a good way) and traders.

Rather than being pricks for the sake of it * style, they tend to look a few moves ahead and dazzle sides with seemingly great offers in the here and now (Don't we know about it..).

If they initiate a trade, be bloody wary imo.

Logically they could regroup inside 1-2 seasons like a Geelong circa 2020 because they have a balanced list with several guns.

If they do look like blowing it all up like you said hypothetically, it'd be odd and need further scrutiny. You don't dismantle a premiership list 3 seasons later without very strong indicators your core is cooked.

If Gawn is cooked and banged up and he’s 33 next year - he may drop off.
Viney has hit 30 years of age this year but looks like he’s running in quicksand and Oliver is one bender away from f***ing it all up - then what core is there to continue to challenge?
Steven May is still a gun but is also 33 next year.
Lever is 29 next year.
Rivers is a gun but is he good enough to build around? Langdon is 29 next year.

The fact they wasted these prime years 2021-23 by not finding a genuine tall forward is criminal.

Oh well. 1 flag is still a flag. But to think the Brown trade cost them more than 1 is something.

 

[King Corey]

If Gawn is cooked and banged up and he’s 33 next year - he may drop off.
Viney has hit 30 years of age this year but looks like he’s running in quicksand and Oliver is one bender away from f***ing it all up - then what core is there to continue to challenge?
Steven May is still a gun but is also 33 next year.
Lever is 29 next year.
Rivers is a gun but is he good enough to build around? Langdon is 29 next year.

The fact they wasted these prime years 2021-23 by not finding a genuine ball forward is criminal.

Oh well. 1 flag is still a flag. But to think the Brown trade cost them more than 1 is something.

Fwiw I'd take that Faustian deal.

We pay overs for Jesse Hogan and get a premiership before abruptly combusting.

Where do I sign?

 

[Makeshift Park]

Fwiw I'd take that Faustian deal.

We pay overs for Jesse Hogan and get a premiership before abruptly combusting.

Where do I sign?

As far as Faustian pacts go, that sounds pretty attractive tho.

Surely if it was really the devil you were doing business with, it'd have to be something like "you get a certain premiership, yes, but your premiership coach has to be James Hird".

 

[Sphynx]

It would be a smart move from Melbourne.

They are probably done.

In the same way, I’d only be offering our F1.

Pick 2 not even on the table.

He’s just had a near death injury with no certainty of return to his best and is 29 next season.

 

[Samsquanch]

The media hasn’t linked us to any players, that must mean we have given up

Reality is, we no longer leak like excited year 8 students who just found out a secret and can't wait to tell all and sundry what they know.

Or, in other words, the Scott / Joyce curse is over.

 

[Shinboner1]

TT meeting with St Kilda

 

[Junk yard]

TT meeting with St Kilda

Contract stipulation regarding throwing and or burning female dwarves?

 

[krakouers]

TT meeting with St Kilda

Referring to this?

 

[hilly]

Is it true

On SM-S901E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Ligma]

Petracca. 3rd hand info, but surprised if true that not previously mentioned on here

hasn’t been tweeted by Sam Fluff so must be true

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

Referring to this?

It was always going to be one of the Saints, Bombers or Pies saying “to hell with morality and optics” and reaching for that poisoned chalice.

 

[Devski]

Interesting prospect.

Given the history regarding the clubs handling of his injuries, and the writing on the wall in regards to Melbourne's performance, I wouldn’t be overly surprised if he’s looking at his options.

If he is, I think it’s a good fit. He’s a good leader who knows the work standard required for a flag. We have money and draft capital.

I’m confident Todd would still have the resources to read the room at Melbourne in terms of due diligence and negotiations.

Could be a good showing provided someone hasn’t pulled this out of their star chamber