Game Day 2024 Trade Period - Lian Yu - that liminal space between trade and draft.

[CapitalA]

I'm not against trading it for next year to get the picks for Chad.

Kinda depends what the eagles get for Barrass, if they get two F1st then we can't compete anyway.

 

[Midnite65]

It would be fun to have both Port and Pies F1, assuming our choices are off the table already

Magpies could still be decent next year. Will be hungry again, Houston is an elite user of the ball off half back, allows Daicos to play midfield and if they get Membrey cheap gets Frampton nowhere near the forward line.

 

[Azz 27]

**** looks like Bolton will be one of the last trades right on the buzzer. Him and Smith. Any others I can’t think of??

Parker, Daniels, Macrae, Soldo maybe

 

[Suma Says]

Kinda depends what the eagles get for Barrass, if they get two F1st then we can't compete anyway.

Completely irrelevant if Chad chooses Freo. Just like it was irrelevant that we effectively offered pick 11 for Baker in the 10+11+18 for Shai/Baker proposal. Like it was irrelevant that we put offers to Geelong for Kelly etc etc

 

[lukedean16]

Once a player nominates a club the trade gets done, especially if they are out of contract LOL

You do know that a team has to have picks for them to nominate in the first place?

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Completely irrelevant if Chad chooses Freo. Just like it was irrelevant that we effectively offered pick 11 for Baker in the 10+11+18 for Shai/Baker proposal. Like it was irrelevant that we put offers to Geelong for Kelly etc etc

I don't understand why this is difficult. Literally we have just had two perfect examples in Baker and Houston, have another one in Smith that gets done tomorrow. It doesn't matter if WC have picks 1 through 10 so long as we have our 2025 first and Warner picks us.

Why does it keep getting parroted.

 

[FUS_RO_DAH]

Kane Cornes ongoing vendetta against Gossage is deeply, deeply entertaining to me.
Also extremely typical of Gossage to defend West Coast
10/10 all round

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

You do know that a team has to have picks for them to nominate in the first place?

Yes, we'll have access to up to three first round picks

 

[Hamann188]

I don't understand why this is difficult. Literally we have just had two perfect examples in Baker and Houston, have another one in Smith that gets done tomorrow. It doesn't matter if WC have picks 1 through 10 so long as we have our 2025 first and Warner picks us.

Why does it keep getting parroted.

Yeah this has been my thinking all trade period Snuff.

If he picks Fremantle, it get's done. Pretty Simple.

 

[Mr Cheese]

We will not get 14 back.

Why not? Equates to 10 & 14 roughly. I'd also expect salary. 10 & 11 alone clearly isn't happening. This sits midway and allows Richmond to "win" the trade. Perfect really.

On SM-G988U1 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[freocuz]

What if WC agreeing to being exploited included agreement Richmond would not let a Bolton trade proceed that resulted in Freo holding a higher first round pick than WC?

Not likely, but not absolutely impossible.

But if Richmond stop it proceeding on that basis, we would have two picks higher than WC.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[mike91]

I don't understand why this is difficult. Literally we have just had two perfect examples in Baker and Houston, have another one in Smith that gets done tomorrow. It doesn't matter if WC have picks 1 through 10 so long as we have our 2025 first and Warner picks us.

Why does it keep getting parroted.

I see your impatience has hit my levels. Though credit to you, I've given up explaining this now. Actually ridiculous.

On SM-G781B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fat Nyfe]

Maybe it’s cos I haven’t paid much attention to GC but I thought Lukosious was supposed to be a very good player

 

[Dump Truck]

Our bobcat operator is a massive west coast fan. He yelled "F#$%" super loudly, parked it and said he's going to the pub.

We haven't seen him since, so I think he's genuinely that furious about this trade.

Update:
He's called in a sick day. Said he had migraines. Our boss said that trade would give him migraines too if he followed that mob.

 

[arsesmart]

Maybe it’s cos I haven’t paid much attention to GC but I thought Lukosious was supposed to be a very good player

Handled correctly and given the right role, Lukosius could be an absolute weapon.

 

[Paracleet]

But if Richmond stop it proceeding on that basis, we would have two picks higher than WC.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Obviously that's true. What I meant was they would on compromise on pick shuffles that result in us moving lower, not on us keeping 11. More currency, but later first pick. I.E They would agree to say 10 and 11 and two seconds back, but not 10 and 18 (which is more in value terms even on the new scale).

All this would be predicated on us not being prepared to walk away in the real non posturing world.

 

[Alfonz]

I don't understand why this is difficult. Literally we have just had two perfect examples in Baker and Houston, have another one in Smith that gets done tomorrow. It doesn't matter if WC have picks 1 through 10 so long as we have our 2025 first and Warner picks us.

Why does it keep getting parroted.

I agree, but the thinking would be that Warner is not particularly set on either club and might make his choice based on which club has more draft capital to get the deal done with the least amount of fuss. Especially if WC are offering significantly more money.

 

[The Lobbster]

Why not? Equates to 10 & 14 roughly. I'd also expect salary. 10 & 11 alone clearly isn't happening. This sits midway and allows Richmond to "win" the trade. Perfect really.

On SM-G988U1 using BigFooty.com mobile app

CTD said the 10,11,18 offer for Baker was real but with something back.

At the rate shouldn’t we go 10,11,18 for Bolton + 14 (Baker) + whatever else?

I don’t think it gets done with either parties first offer and I can’t see them giving Bolton 14 for 10,11. That doesn’t even get close to a good deal for Richmond

 

[malpaso]

Maybe it’s cos I haven’t paid much attention to GC but I thought Lukosious was supposed to be a very good player

I reckon he could be away from the dew-filled micro stadium of GC but it remains to be seen.. He's certainly better than Marshall and they also lost Dixon.

 

[theGav56]

It's a bit harder for me to ignore all that and just poke fun at them. Too high probability they draft Allan and he is a gun.

That is possible but they still undersold pick 3 by a f2 at a minimum I reckon.

And their prize recruit of Owies would be gettable as a DFA.

 

[The Feeder Club]

CTD said the 10,11,18 offer for Baker was real but with something back.

At the rate shouldn’t we go 10,11,18 for Bolton+14+ whatever else?

I don’t think it gets done with either parties first offer and I can’t see them giving Bolton 14 for 10,11. That doesn’t even get close to a good deal for Richmond

10, 11, 18 for Bolton,14, salary payments

 

[Belnakor]

Maybe it’s cos I haven’t paid much attention to GC but I thought Lukosious was supposed to be a very good player

He tended to be very inconsistent so GC got fed up with him

 

[Silencer83]

**** looks like Bolton will be one of the last trades right on the buzzer. Him and Smith. Any others I can’t think of??

Rioli the other Richmond trade yet to play out. Surely they are licking their lips at how easily GC is giving away picks in other trades.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I agree, but the thinking would be that Warner is not particularly set on either club and might make his choice based on which club has more draft capital to get the deal done with the least amount of fuss. Especially if WC are offering significantly more money.

Well it doesn't matter what we have because WC have access to two top 4 picks. We'll have enough for an OOC player like we had enough for Jackson

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I see your impatience has hit my levels. Though credit to you, I've given up explaining this now. Actually ridiculous.

On SM-G781B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Haha, I'm about to lose my politeness on it though, particularly when some new dude is laugh reacting my post...