- Mar 29, 2019
- 10,560
- 17,206
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Damn, I was thinking of going tomorrow
-
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Training 2024 training updates.
- Thread starter Jen2310
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Any hints at training about potential line-up changes for Friday night?
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
sr36
TheBrownDog
I doubt there will be much change.
Lippa into the 22 for JDG. Long or Sullivan? Who as sub? That's about it I would have thought.
- Mar 28, 2023
- 13,245
- 25,802
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Such a pity there wasn't a VFL game last week to get some form into Joe, Harvey etc. Richards hasn't played since the ordinary Hawks game.
That's how they structured last week's 6 day break isn't it? Maybe they liked it as a point of difference.
Jen2310
Premium Platinum
- Thread starter
- #6,234
Yeah, I assumed it was done that way last week because of Pendles 400th. Plus the AFLW were scheduled to train on the thurs.
But generally even on 5, 6 day breaks, main sessions havent generally changed. Last week was the first time for as long as I can recall, it was 3 days before the game
On the plus side, whoever comes in should be fresh.
- Mar 28, 2023
- 13,245
- 25,802
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I guess, or completely underdone
Jen2310
Premium Platinum
- Thread starter
- #6,238
Training - Main session, Round 22.
I didn't know whether there was gonna be training, but decided to get up and go down to check. To see whether the 6 day break would change the scheduling, turns out, I was right.
MIA:
Begg
Jordy
Checkers
Mitchell
All injured so no expectations to see them.
Rehab:
Steene
Smit
Both doing running sessions. Smit looks to be travelling well, coming from his concussion protocols. Shame he won't be available to play this week.
Steene was getting work done in between his running sessions. So its a bit of slow progress for him, as he builds up the strength in his foot area.
Maynard came over to the rehab group half way through the session, did some running then went inside. I imagine just a bit of management.
Coxy also didn't do the match play stuff, just the drills. Went inside. Management too I imagine, given the 6 day break.
They split off into line groups and did some 1 v 1 fight simulations between the talls.
The rucks did some stuff in the middle. This was just more DC and Cox.
Mids did some ball movement and stoppage crafts.
Match sim - There was no obvious signs of what they'll do. But from evidence, Frampton will keep his spot.
*Maynard, Cox didn't participate
Black:
White:
I didn't know whether there was gonna be training, but decided to get up and go down to check. To see whether the 6 day break would change the scheduling, turns out, I was right.
MIA:
Begg
Jordy
Checkers
Mitchell
All injured so no expectations to see them.
Rehab:
Steene
Smit
Both doing running sessions. Smit looks to be travelling well, coming from his concussion protocols. Shame he won't be available to play this week.
Steene was getting work done in between his running sessions. So its a bit of slow progress for him, as he builds up the strength in his foot area.
Maynard came over to the rehab group half way through the session, did some running then went inside. I imagine just a bit of management.
Coxy also didn't do the match play stuff, just the drills. Went inside. Management too I imagine, given the 6 day break.
They split off into line groups and did some 1 v 1 fight simulations between the talls.
The rucks did some stuff in the middle. This was just more DC and Cox.
Mids did some ball movement and stoppage crafts.
Match sim - There was no obvious signs of what they'll do. But from evidence, Frampton will keep his spot.
*Maynard, Cox didn't participate
Black:
- Lippa
- IQ
- Elliott
- JDaicos
- Schultz
- Noble
- Pendles
- Mcstay
- DC
- Frampton
- Sidey
- Hill
- Crisp
- Moore
- Beau
- WHE
- NDaicos
- Howe
White:
- DeMattia
- Kreuger
- Allan
- Macrae
- TJ
- Ryan
- Reef
- Bytel
- Richards
- Sullivan
- Eyre
- HH
- Markov
- Johnson
- Dean
- Long
- Parker
Jen2310
Premium Platinum
- Thread starter
- #6,239
In terms of the match ups:
Black forwards: Mcstay. WHE. Hill. Jamie. Schultz. Beau v White defenders: Dean. Reef. Eyre. Parker. TJ. Markov
Black Defenders: JDaicos. Noble. IQ. Frampton. Moore. Howe v White Forwards: HH. Harry ( :O) Richards. Johnson. Kreuger
Midfield: Back - Nick. Lippa. Crisp ( Pendles, Sidey wings) DC ruck v White: Long. Allan. Fin (Sullivan. Bytel wings) Kreuger ruck
Black forwards: Mcstay. WHE. Hill. Jamie. Schultz. Beau v White defenders: Dean. Reef. Eyre. Parker. TJ. Markov
Black Defenders: JDaicos. Noble. IQ. Frampton. Moore. Howe v White Forwards: HH. Harry ( :O) Richards. Johnson. Kreuger
Midfield: Back - Nick. Lippa. Crisp ( Pendles, Sidey wings) DC ruck v White: Long. Allan. Fin (Sullivan. Bytel wings) Kreuger ruck
localfootylegend23
Team Captain
- Jul 4, 2023
- 511
- 607
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- MCC lacrosse
Quaynor has been horrible recently, hate to be so negative but he isnt giving us any run, has a habit of standing in packs with bigs and not guarding in front or behind where the dangerous smalls lurk, always out of position. maybe he is just trying to lock down under coaches messeges but its not great right now. Noble wasn't much better tbh
Ned long matched on cripps looked like a schoolboy playing senior footy for the first time, had 0 idea what he was doing and we would have lost most of center clearances he attended. Did a couple of okay things ball in hand but looked like he was out of his depth for most of the night.
Our kicking to our forwards has been average, so many intercept marks against, not sure they are battling to bring it to ground as much as they should. Having cox down there helped though, wonder if freddy comes back in to chop mcstay out a little.
Now we are losing guys like JDG and titch for the rest of the year the young fellas need to step up, perfect opportunity for them in the next 3 weeks
Ned long matched on cripps looked like a schoolboy playing senior footy for the first time, had 0 idea what he was doing and we would have lost most of center clearances he attended. Did a couple of okay things ball in hand but looked like he was out of his depth for most of the night.
Our kicking to our forwards has been average, so many intercept marks against, not sure they are battling to bring it to ground as much as they should. Having cox down there helped though, wonder if freddy comes back in to chop mcstay out a little.
Now we are losing guys like JDG and titch for the rest of the year the young fellas need to step up, perfect opportunity for them in the next 3 weeks
jmac70
On the porch
For someone who hates to be negative, you’re very good at it.
"Our young players are terrible"...
But also "Play the young fellas"...
Hard to see where you're heading with this tbh.
But also "Play the young fellas"...
Hard to see where you're heading with this tbh.
agree with some of Q comments ..have written elsewhere about his performances this year.
Long comments not so much ..
Long broke even (1v1 re his direct opponent) at CB & clearance all game apart from last 18 mins. Long only played 59% of game-time.
For the record, we won CB clearance (12 v 11) but lost stoppage (23 v 31) across the night, with Carlton's +stoppage differential coming in last 18 mins Q4 and also early Q1.
In that last Q dominance, Cripps beat all of Long, Crisp and Pendles at CB and stoppage.
Long conceded 2 free kicks against Cripps in Q4, both for holding. One from CB and one from the wing, both v.harsh IMV, since both players were grabbing/ scragging & jostling for position.
With the 2nd one, Cripps in fact initiates, grabs Long's jumper & pulls him off balance, yet still winds up with the free.
A few minutes later he does the same to Crisp who manages to hold his ground ..'play on' called
Umpires umpire differently for name players in the comp vs newbies
Long did ok defensively against the bigger bodied mids of Carlton but offered nothing offensively. Still only 10 games into his career but he does look very limited. Don't have a real handle on his ceiling as yet but he could develop into a role player to absorb some of the heat & physicality at stoppage and help shield Nick (for example) from the obvious buffeting he'll continue to receive.
Swans' mids a different proposition this week. I'd stick with Long to play a similar role but wouldn't (for example) let Lipinski anywhere near CB. All of Pendles, Long & Lipinski at CB would make us ponderous.
Last edited:
NMBB
Norm Smith Medallist
- May 3, 2021
- 7,985
- 12,792
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Simple fact - we won (don't care how close). Before the game Blose were 3rd, we were 12th? After we kicked the 1st goal we were never headed - in front for
efa
Last edited:
sr36
TheBrownDog
Pace and sticking tackles is going to matter against them. McCreery is the best bet, but not sure if we will be willing to lose his ability to stop transition in his defensive forward role.
31550
Premium Platinum
- Feb 5, 2022
- 2,533
- 3,967
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I would be looking at bringing in Reef, rotating Beau and Reef between mid and HF.
Gaspard
Team Captain
- Apr 27, 2021
- 410
- 1,331
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
We have to recognize that McCreery is too fumbly to be a first line midfielder. He has many excellent characteristics, but taking clean possession when in tight is just not one of them. A real midfielder, like Lachie Neale, never fumbles. McCreery is an outstanding pressure forward. Play him there. He is a passable midfielder, who only gets and extracts the ball about half the time when it comes to him in a pack.
sr36
TheBrownDog
Yes he fumbles a lot. I get the impression though that it's not his hands as much as a mindset of scanning to look for options or exits before he's got it under control. I'm hoping his ball handling comes good.
Last edited:
Beau offers grunt and speed - which are the primary considerations in covering our mid deficiencies.
He won’t be fumbling HB receives out of stoppage as he bursts through packs.
Agree his ground ball game is not at Neales’ level.
hands aren't the cleanest for sure but everything that make him an elite pressure forward - super quick, explosive, strong /physical, aggressive tackler - would translate to make him an excellent defensive CBA player (in short bursts).
with the 6-6-6, clean CB exit can quickly lead to scoring momentum, something we've been on the receiving end of this year eg. Q4 on the weekend. if you're trying to defend a lead or stop the oppo's momentum, breaking even in CB is critical ..McCreery with his skill-set can be a point of difference (defensively) for us in there ie. clean hands aren't necessarily a massive negative.
