List Mgmt. 2025 List Management 📃

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Sounds great. Kemp in those few games looked much more dangerous forward then SOS ever has. Probably doesn't provide us much defensively but in that role, you want a guy to be genuinely dangerous. SOS on the other hand is much more disciplined than Kemp, which bodes well for defence. Feel the switch might maximise each players strengths while hiding their weaknesses.
 
Sounds great. Kemp in those few games looked much more dangerous forward then SOS ever has. Probably doesn't provide us much defensively but in that role, you want a guy to be genuinely dangerous. SOS on the other hand is much more disciplined than Kemp, which bodes well for defence. Feel the switch might maximise each players strengths while hiding their weaknesses.
JSOS kicked 4 goals against Port in his last full game
 
I’m not sure that’s true.
He kicked goals against a terrible West Coast, and struggled against the Saints.

True but signs were good. When he becomes third option next to Charlie & McKay he could really surprise especially with a pre season preparing for this role

I’m a Jack fan but Kemp has a bit more agility and X factor IMO
 
True but signs were good. When he becomes third option next to Charlie & McKay he could really surprise especially with a pre season preparing for this role

I’m a Jack fan but Kemp has a bit more agility and X factor IMO
Yeah, I thought there were good signs for sure.
But saying he showed more than Jack ever has is hyperbole at best.
 
Love this. I am a big believer in maximising your list and what you have first. You can find gold if you are prepared to look and try things.

Kemp fwd/mid, Ollie to HB are just two examples

I think Jack to defence will be seen as a brilliant move 👍
Given Jon Ralph's recent form, it's probably Charlie that's going back... 😝
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Carlton’s 2025 AFL list analysed: Trade targets, key players, predicted finish and more


Hun


I know it’s only Ralph Mouth saying it, but gee whiz…if we finish 7th next year then it’s hard to see Voss being coach in 2026.

It’s top four/preliminary finalist or bust. The key players are in their prime. There are no more excuses for this group IMO.
 
Sounds great. Kemp in those few games looked much more dangerous forward then SOS ever has. Probably doesn't provide us much defensively but in that role, you want a guy to be genuinely dangerous. SOS on the other hand is much more disciplined than Kemp, which bodes well for defence. Feel the switch might maximise each players strengths while hiding their weaknesses.
I've said this before but I'd like to see Jack at FB and Weiters come up to CHB.
Jack won't like to get beaten, is pretty smart with body positioning, and strong (and looks to have bulked up a bit more from that photo).

It will release Weiters if Jack can build his trust and let him play intercept.

The two could change as OP requires.
 
Sounds great. Kemp in those few games looked much more dangerous forward then SOS ever has. Probably doesn't provide us much defensively but in that role, you want a guy to be genuinely dangerous. SOS on the other hand is much more disciplined than Kemp, which bodes well for defence. Feel the switch might maximise each players strengths while hiding their weaknesses.
I agree to a point.

Jack's last game before injury was something out of the box. Just not a regular occurrence.

On SM-F946B using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
True but signs were good. When he becomes third option next to Charlie & McKay he could really surprise especially with a pre season preparing for this role

I’m a Jack fan but Kemp has a bit more agility and X factor IMO
Jack's got that dog in him. Which is an amazing quality to have.

On SM-F946B using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
True but signs were good. When he becomes third option next to Charlie & McKay he could really surprise especially with a pre season preparing for this role

I’m a Jack fan but Kemp has a bit more agility and X factor IMO
I think Kemp is quicker, better leap, better contested mark. Will provide him more scoring opportunties then Jack as a deep forward.

Still, think Kemps best position is as an attacking 3rd tall defender but Govs got that role and I reckon JSOS is better suited to the vacant 2nd KPD position with his discipline and ability to half a contest.

I wonder what it means for Moir if Kemp plays forward though. Moirs got more tricks and the ability to impact on the ground as well as the air. Im not sure you can play Charlie, Harry, Kemp, Moir all forward atm. Would lack pressure.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 List Management 📃

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top