- Nov 27, 2016
- 18,774
- 36,585
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Or to finish teams off when we get up. So the end of the game isn't as taxing
On SM-F946B using BigFooty.com mobile app
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 0
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 0
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
List Mgmt. 2025 List Management 📃
- Thread starter Aphrodite
- Start date
- Tagged users None
On SM-F946B using BigFooty.com mobile app
If that's the case, strong chance McMahon gets the last spot
- Apr 7, 2006
- 1,733
- 5,376
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I just don't know who our CHB is. The only key defender we've got is Weiters. Young is more a VFL player obviously and then you're down to McGovern / SOS types.
Even if they put McMahon on the list he's not really a key defender he's probably the same height as SOS but even skinnier.
If weiters goes down injured we're in for a long year. There is zero depth or support behind him.
Even if they put McMahon on the list he's not really a key defender he's probably the same height as SOS but even skinnier.
If weiters goes down injured we're in for a long year. There is zero depth or support behind him.
Let’s hope they go for Phillips. He plays a lockdown KPD role.
The stats I've read are that he is of a similar height and weight as Ethan Phillips (198cm + 90kg).
Silvagni 194cm
McMahon 198cm
Phillips 198cm
G-Barras 195cm
McMahon 198cm
Phillips 198cm
G-Barras 195cm
That carlton team of this century has some starting 4
Cruz. CRIPPA, Kouta and Judd
Injury free and at their peak they'd beat 18 blokes by themselves
* Kicking to Fev, Cc and H
Cruz. CRIPPA, Kouta and Judd
Injury free and at their peak they'd beat 18 blokes by themselves
* Kicking to Fev, Cc and H
- Jul 11, 2023
- 818
- 1,484
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Haynes 192 4th Tall but more an Interceptor.
Silvagni will be played as a CHB
I want to see how Jack adapts throughout the year first, i think he’ll matchup on certain KPF’s fine while particular others it will be a challenge…
Others I’m in agreement with…
Not sure we should go DGB, reserves list I’m happy to trial him…
Close weren’t they…not Matty Carroll but JB
- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,822
- 13,302
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Listening to him on the radio yesterday i certainly got the impression he will be playing as a lockdown tall defender. Hopefully he is up to it.
- Jul 24, 2018
- 2,479
- 9,894
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Whose making way for Jagga in our team of the century….
Too soon?
Too soon?
- Jul 24, 2018
- 2,479
- 9,894
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Didn’t really know where to put this, but the comps gonna hate us even more in two years
“Oh yes Cripps is finally slowing down… oh wait who’s this Cody walker kid. Ffs”
Jagga Cody Walsh Cerra hopefully still TDK, and then guys like Bcampo and Lordy, well placed for life after Cripps for the first time
“Oh yes Cripps is finally slowing down… oh wait who’s this Cody walker kid. Ffs”
Jagga Cody Walsh Cerra hopefully still TDK, and then guys like Bcampo and Lordy, well placed for life after Cripps for the first time
A good lockdown key back needs pace off the mark. Does JSOS have that first 5m burst?
Absolutely this.
I am pretty certain we have the next generation midfield all mapped out, even at this early stage.
We are a decent way towards covering the next generation of defenders, on the proviso O’Farrell lives up to his potential and (perhaps) Harry Dean proves a genuine AFL player (signs are good)
Young ruck O’Keeffe looks the goods, while TDK theoretically has another seven or more years.
The forwards will likely become the focus. Lemmey starting to step up to the standard, Motlop maturing, I still have plenty of hope for Durds. Kemp is still a watch as to how effective he will be as a third tall/second key. Then there is the X-Factor of Ashton Moir. Solid forward credentials for HOK adds to a potential mix in tandem with TDK. Cody W is very capable forward in that mix, at very least in his formative years. (Lucas Koutoufides shaping as a possible key forward from 2028 draft)
Needing a couple of “pieces” up forward, but time is in our side and not too far away assuming reasonable trajectories.
Our second SSP addition will assist either back (Grainger-Barras or Phillips) or forward if Liam McMahon gets the gig as a key/third tall or some chance Will White as a small forward. All named could conceivably contribute to our next generation, on top of immediate impact.
Austin and friends have quietly gone about future proofing the list. The key will be maintaining our developing players, particularly talls, while our established “stars” continue their careers.
JSOS would not be my first choice IF we had a good lockdown defender with pace off the mark. Hopefully HOF becomes that in a few years.
Remains to be seen, but Jack is quicker than many give him credit for and his ability to read the game better than most will assist.
I am quite bullish that all of Silvagni, Haynes and McGovern could co-exist with Weitering. None are pedestrian, all are smart footballers. McGovern a bit of a key with his “willingness” to defend. The Tigers won flags not so long back with four, even five 190cm plus defenders.
If we plan on moving the ball quicker and having more behind the ball preventing the opposition from scoring it will go along way to helping.
Still reckon we need another option up forward if we lose Charles or H during the year. When that news report came through last week with big H holding his shoulder at training, it put the fear of god in me.
Last year we delisted/traded Owies (forward), Martin (forward), Cunners (forward/mid) and Kennedy, who was largely playing as a forward during the back half of the season.
We've since brought in Haynes (defender), Carroll (defender), O'Farrell (defender), Charleson (defender), as well as Jagga and the Campo's (mids). We're also moving JSOS down back, and Cincotta will return at some stage.
Lem is a tall forward option but doesn't particularly play tall. For mine, we definitely needs another forward who can take a grab aka McMahon.
Last year we delisted/traded Owies (forward), Martin (forward), Cunners (forward/mid) and Kennedy, who was largely playing as a forward during the back half of the season.
We've since brought in Haynes (defender), Carroll (defender), O'Farrell (defender), Charleson (defender), as well as Jagga and the Campo's (mids). We're also moving JSOS down back, and Cincotta will return at some stage.
Lem is a tall forward option but doesn't particularly play tall. For mine, we definitely needs another forward who can take a grab aka McMahon.
If adding someone as injury depth, versatility does not hurt at all. You never know where the injuries will come from.
And with all the defenders introduced, there is still both the Irish lads who have stated they’ll also be down back this year - only so many positions avail to learn how to ply their trade.
Brodie Kemp moves forward to offset all this change…
Dramoth
Premium Platinum
As far as I'm concerned, we take McMahon as our other PSSP player and leave Newy's LTI list spot until the MSD. We have a number of players who can step up into his role, Doch as the prime example.
At that point we can address anything we might need for the second half of the year. We can sign DGB to the VFL and if we need to, pick him up in the MSD.
At that point we can address anything we might need for the second half of the year. We can sign DGB to the VFL and if we need to, pick him up in the MSD.
