- Thread starter
- #3
Last edited:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Prelim Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
So, let me get this straight.
Option 1 is to trade my pick 9 player for your pick 45 player - swapping the clear best player in his position for what is maybe the 17th best player in his position?
Hahahaha.
or swap an equivalent player (2xAA vs a couple of 4 xAA's) for 3 50 pick downgrades?
Where do I sign?
In all seriousness, it was just a structural preference so I thought I'd make a generous 70 pick upgrade offer (for the last player (i.e. worst) of my 2nd tier key forward list). Not worth completely destroying my team for it.
Thanks anyway.
You have to give something to get something and the KPF's are just about all gone.
Your Tier 2 key forward, is definitely well and truly a Tier 1 forward in my eyes and I won't be able to replace him.
Of this pool, the following are the multiple Coleman Winners:
4 - Franklin
3 - J.Riewoldt, Lloyd
2 - Gehrig, Kennedy, Fevola, Curnow
And the only 4 players in the entire pool to average 4.5+ goals per game across a single season are Lloyd (2001), Gehrig (2004), Franklin (2008) and Fevola (2008).
How long do you think Darling, Gunston, Cloke, Petrie and O'Loughlin types will be around though? Some people are yet to pick a tall forward!I was open to a reasonable suggestion.
I think we're too far apart to get there.
He was the 17th selected key forward which is about right.
There are players still not selected within about 20 goals of his career tally that I'll be able to get later in the draft.
Let's not worry about it (even though trading is fun!)
I was open to a reasonable suggestion.
I think we're too far apart to get there.
He was the 17th selected key forward which is about right.
There are players still not selected within about 20 goals of his career tally that I'll be able to get later in the draft.
Let's not worry about it (even though trading is fun!)
Gehrig played exactly 1 season at full back (2001)- and a handful of games swung back the following year.Again, I don't really care for career total goals and that's where he was selected, not where I had him rated, I had him a lot higher. He was 8th on my list of key forwards.
Tom Hawkins isn't better than Wayne Carey.
And Gehrig kicked 550 goals despite playing about 60 games at full back. Converting via his rate of scoring that puts him around J.Riewoldt career goal level from about 70 less games.
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
Isnt white 1994
At least this double banger only took one player I wanted.
All this time I thought it was the draft yearDebuted 1995.
Eligible.
He was on my list.
All this time I thought it was the draft year
Me too.I thought McPharlin might be the type to slide - evidently not.
I'm curious to see the final breakdown too.Another East Fremantle keeping above that 10 percent still.
Any other key players on the horizon?East Fremantle so far
Cripps Kennedy Mcpharlin Black Cousins Taylor Sandilands
Damn, I was looking at both but with upcoming picks especially McPharlin. Underrated gun defender who accounted for some very, very good players.
And if this gets done I can make my next selection pronto.
Couple of possibilitiesAny other key players on the horizon?