Confirmed Bailey Smith: 4-way trade: B. Smith (WB) & pick 45 to Geel / pick 38 to Carl / Macrae (WB) to StK / pick 17 & Kennedy (Carl) to WB

[STPer18]

Hoping he leaves and dogs win the next flag. The satisfaction like hawks and buddy leaving.

Yeah we did that with Ablett too.

 

[calder_daddy]

Hoping he leaves and dogs win the next flag. The satisfaction like hawks and buddy leaving.

Yeah we did that with Ablett too.

Only difference is Both Hawthorn and Geelong were still competing in GF’s when they left
Not a team who finished 6th

 

[FootyLad0]

Sydney can utilize 17 & 19 and likely get 22 for Parker. So they trade up or give us a better deal than Geelong can.

I remember when you guys were saying he was going to Gold Coast too.
What happened to that?
Haven’t heard a whiff of it since and now Sydney?

I can’t wait to see which team is named next

 

[WB_]

Daily reminder for Dogs fans to touch grass and avoid making a tit of themselves in here.

Far more overly antagonistic Geelong fans here in need of such a message.

 

[adogsfan5]

They've got their timeline completely out of whack.

They're supposed to be using the period before the trade to aggressively pump up Bailey's tyres as one of the greatest players of his generation....and only start calling him an untalented w***er hack AFTER the trade is done.

Geelongs list manager doesn’t read bigfooty. I don’t think it really matters.

 

[TiAn_]

Far more overly antagonistic Geelong fans here in need of such a message.

Eerily similar levels of cringe to the Essendon nuffs during the Stringer trade. Think it’ll work just fine for the Dogs, again.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Reckon Pies are a real chance if they get pick 12 from Noble deal

The pies are about as much chance of getting p12 for noble as I am of being an f1 driver next year.

 

[Ashman23]

The pies are about as much chance of getting p12 for noble as I am of being an f1 driver next year.

So, you're Liam Lawson?

Congrats on replacing Daniel.

 

[Pencil case]

The pies are about as much chance of getting p12 for noble as I am of being an f1 driver next year.

It’ll be apart of a huge swap of picks, not just Noble.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

It’ll be apart of a huge swap of picks, not just Noble.

Pies won't get 12 unless they are giving up their future 1st with noble (and they would be mad to do that) they have nothing else of value to use to get 12. It's a non starter.

 

[Pencil case]

Pies won't get 12 unless they are giving up their future 1st with noble (and they would be mad to do that) they have nothing else of value to use to get 12. It's a non starter.

It’s been reported that they can without using a future first.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

It’s been reported that they can without using a future first.

Not even GC are that stupid.

 

[calder_daddy]

The pies are about as much chance of getting p12 for noble as I am of being an f1 driver next year.

Not even GC are that stupid.

GC need points for Lombard
Don’t count it out, it’s actually not the worst trade if you consider the points GC can receive and a player that’s contracted

 

[Pure_Ownage]

GC need points for Lombard
Don’t count it out, it’s actually not the worst trade if you consider the points GC can receive and a player that’s contracted

There's stacks of better ways they can get more points without doing that deal (look at what bris have done in previous years).

 

[calder_daddy]

There's stacks of better ways they can get more points without doing that deal (look at what bris have done in previous years).

Points index has changed dramatically you know that.
I’m not suggesting it will happen, it’s not as fair fetched as it sounds
Remember GC did give us a player and pick 7

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Far more overly antagonistic Geelong fans here in need of such a message.

My interest is progressing you all to the acceptance stage of the grieving process, and to move past the belligerent stage where you're all acting faux list manager tough guy.

You'll get what you get and both clubs will move on maturely, as is the way with real list management teams.
You'll lose a player you've replaced in the team and the recruiter will do his best to find a good player for the dogs for years to come.

 

[Pencil case]

My interest is progressing you all to the acceptance stage of the grieving process, and to move past the belligerent stage where you're all acting faux list manager tough guy.

You'll get what you get and both clubs will move on maturely, as is the way with real list management teams.
You'll lose a player you've replaced in the team and the recruiter will do his best to find a good player for the dogs for years to come.

What in the yap

 

[WB_]

My interest is progressing you all to the acceptance stage of the grieving process, and to move past the belligerent stage where you're all acting faux list manager tough guy.

You'll get what you get and both clubs will move on maturely, as is the way with real list management teams.
You'll lose a player you've replaced in the team and the recruiter will do his best to find a good player for the dogs for years to come.

I certainly agree with the second half of the post, but as indicated before, there are many Geelong posters in here for whom "faux list manager tough guy" is an apt description.

 

[adogsfan5]

Someone hasn't explained to you where in the food chain the Dogs are in the AFL world?
Destination clubs like us, well we're the apex predators. At best you're an opportunistic Hyena type, feasting on our scraps

Daily reminder for Dogs fans to touch grass and avoid making a tit of themselves in here.

My interest is progressing you all to the acceptance stage of the grieving process, and to move past the belligerent stage where you're all acting faux list manager tough guy.

Oh the irony.

 

[TiAn_]

Oh the irony.

King Cringe. A normal unit would be embarrassed.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

King Cringe. A normal unit would be embarrassed.

I've said it for many years, Geelong fans are the absolute worst onthe trade threads.

Everyone they're looking at is worth half price because they ate some sardines or went surfing once but the minute one of their players is mentioned it's 12 first rounders to get them to the table.

Half their fans still reckon they can get Baz without losing their first rounder or a player

The Bowes trade totally broke their brains and now they think they'll just get to ream every team for any player they want.

 

[adogsfan5]

King Cringe. A normal unit would be embarrassed.

Its one of those trying to be cool and not triggered situations, but doing the complete opposite.

 

[Tristan34]

I've said it for many years, Geelong fans are the absolute worst onthe trade threads.

Everyone they're looking at is worth half price because they ate some sardines or went surfing once but the minute one of their players is mentioned it's 12 first rounders to get them to the table.

Half their fans still reckon they can get Baz without losing their first rounder or a player

The Bowes trade totally broke their brains and now they think they'll just get to ream every team for any player they want.

Why does Geelong live rent free in your mind??

 

[HairyO]

Reckon Pies are a real chance if they get pick 12 from Noble deal

You think Smith is choosing between Cats and Pies?

I couldnt imagine anyone ever doing that. Totally different lifestyle choices.

 

[calder_daddy]

I've said it for many years, Geelong fans are the absolute worst onthe trade threads.

Everyone they're looking at is worth half price because they ate some sardines or went surfing once but the minute one of their players is mentioned it's 12 first rounders to get them to the table.

Half their fans still reckon they can get Baz without losing their first rounder or a player

The Bowes trade totally broke their brains and now they think they'll just get to ream every team for any player they want.

I suggest you point out these people because I for one have only seen every Geelong poster agreeing he is worth atleast one first rounder

Your making this difficult on us, you tend to stick your noise in.
Just let 2 good list managers go at it and go enjoy your large irrelevant club.