Injury Blue Healers Medical Room 2022

[Coops93]

5 bogs probably and then barely anything.

Brayshaw will right up there now. Clarry too.

Yep.

Another 5 bogs to round out the back end and maybe he's in with a shot.

 

[rp84]

Yep.

Another 5 bogs to round out the back end and maybe he's in with a shot.

Yeah, I suspect its 28-34 to win.

I do wonder if he's hindered as well. Just hasn't looked the same even in the games where he hasn't rucked.

Was daylight ahead of the rest of the comp in the first 5 weeks

 

[teagueyubeauty]

We need one of the ITK' s to give us a nice gift ala Harry back early but this time with cerra and weiters

Saw footage of Grundy back in fitness work but heard nothing about Pitto, they were injured in the same round.

Weiterbot said himself he’s a chance for the Aints but more likely West Coke


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[myblueroan]

I thought we did get one last week suggesting Weiters and Pitto were ahead of schedule and would be back in 2 weeks

We did but I heard Pickers on Sat morning telling dear old Margaret that he would not be back for Saints game and even longer in his opinion. But Margaret stuck fat and said she had heard a whisper saying otherwise.

 

[Carlton06]

 

[The Blue Weirdo]

Yeah I was chatting with a mate about our injuries and came to the conclusion weitering, cerra and pitto were the main players missing. The others are more maybe best 22 or always injured that we've learned to cover them

Gov maybe makes us better, very little to work from as a backman.

Oscar played 2 good games but my opinion would be found out and be a depth player.

Williams we haven't missed at all. Matchy and cunners are always injured

Sent from my CPH2005 using Tapatalk

And we also have replacements for Cerra in the VFL.
So that's really only 2 irreplaceable players, and they are important ones.
No excuses.
We can beat Freo at Marvel this week, if our mids and small forwards regain their early season form.

 

[F_therest]

This is gold.

 

[F_therest]

Most sides would have more spine players and less 3rd talls

Speaking strictly about the backline, I'd argue that Weitering, Young, Omac and Durdin is at least equivalent to other clubs...don't think any club has 5+ key defenders on their list.

Then third talls we have Gov, Marchy, Plow, Kemp and Parks which again would be the most 3rd defenders of any team.

That's almost a quarter of our entire list.

 

[thylacine60]

I am fast coming to the belief that following Carlton now is akin to the horrors of Stephen King's The Stand. We're just seeing how far we can get before it's all over.

 

[swuzzlebubble]

Speaking strictly about the backline, I'd argue that Weitering, Young, Omac and Durdin is at least equivalent to other clubs...don't think any club has 5+ key defenders on their list.

We only have Durdin because of injuries to the others. IE started the season with 3 which would have to be lowest in league.

 

[Arr0w]

Speaking strictly about the backline, I'd argue that Weitering, Young, Omac and Durdin is at least equivalent to other clubs...don't think any club has 5+ key defenders on their list.

Then third talls we have Gov, Marchy, Plow, Kemp and Parks which again would be the most 3rd defenders of any team.

That's almost a quarter of our entire list.

That may seem the case, in terms of genuine KPD's, but it's not, even if you add possible swingmen and most importantly how many of ours have been injury prone (Omac in the case of KPD's) at the start of this year. Durdin was also an a reactive decision due to our injuries

So keeping in mind, quality, durability heading into this year

Lions - Andrews, Payne, McStay, Gardiner
Tigers - Tarrant, Balta, Gibcus, Miller, Nyuon
Demons - May, Petty, Daw, McDonald, Weideman, M. Brown
Carlton - Weitering, Young, Omac (Let's not include Jones as we had the SSP period to address a replacement)

All other sides went into the start of the season with 25% or more resources in one area, more if you include Omac's injury concerns.

I and others have been banging on about this concern for over 2 years, at what point do people concede that our list management in this area could have been better, rather than leaning on injuries, when you go in with insufficient resources

 

[Magruder]

That may seem the case, in terms of genuine KPD's, but it's not, even if you add possible swingmen and most importantly how many of ours have been injury prone (Omac in the case of KPD's) at the start of this year. Durdin was also an a reactive decision due to our injuries

So keeping in mind, quality, durability heading into this year

Lions - Andrews, Payne, McStay, Gardiner
Tigers - Tarrant, Balta, Gibcus, Miller, Nyuon
Demons - May, Petty, Daw, McDonald, Weideman, M. Brown
Carlton - Weitering, Young, Omac (Let's not include Jones as we had the SSP period to address a replacement)

All other sides went into the start of the season with 25% or more resources in one area, more if you include Omac's injury concerns.

I and others have been banging on about this concern for over 2 years, at what point do people concede that our list management in this area could have been better, rather than leaning on injuries, when you go in with insufficient resources

We started the season with Weiters, OMac and a very raw Lewis Young

The rest are 3rd y’all’s or utilities

We have a shallow pool of spine players, at least 3 are of the highest quality but depth must be addressed

The question becomes who is gettable?

We addressed run from the backline, competitiveness etc and midfield depth over the last couple of seasons. Who is available for KPP Ruck plug and play?

 

[manang magoos]

We did but I heard Pickers on Sat morning telling dear old Margaret that he would not be back for Saints game and even longer in his opinion. But Margaret stuck fat and said she had heard a whisper saying otherwise.

Pickers might be a player manager but he really don’t know shite he works for and with that goose Hutchy for a start

 

[Arr0w]

We started the season with Weiters, OMac and a very raw Lewis Young

The rest are 3rd y’all’s or utilities

We have a shallow pool of spine players, at least 3 are of the highest quality but depth must be addressed

The question becomes who is gettable?

We addressed run from the backline, competitiveness etc and midfield depth over the last couple of seasons. Who is available for KPP Ruck plug and play?

Yeap

I don't think you have to spend big, as we have seen with us adding Young, Durdin, plenty of these types out there. Elsewhere I listed a number of cheap options without including some viable ones playing at the lower levels.

 

[Aphrodite]

Take it to List Management.

Thanks!

 

[F_therest]

That may seem the case, in terms of genuine KPD's, but it's not, even if you add possible swingmen and most importantly how many of ours have been injury prone (Omac in the case of KPD's) at the start of this year. Durdin was also an a reactive decision due to our injuries

So keeping in mind, quality, durability heading into this year

Lions - Andrews, Payne, McStay, Gardiner
Tigers - Tarrant, Balta, Gibcus, Miller, Nyuon
Demons - May, Petty, Daw, McDonald, Weideman, M. Brown
Carlton - Weitering, Young, Omac (Let's not include Jones as we had the SSP period to address a replacement)

All other sides went into the start of the season with 25% or more resources in one area, more if you include Omac's injury concerns.

I and others have been banging on about this concern for over 2 years, at what point do people concede that our list management in this area could have been better, rather than leaning on injuries, when you go in with insufficient resources

I do agree we need more KPP depth...forwards even more so. 4 key defenders is enough and Marchy could fill in if required...the issue is he and omac are always injured. And gov.

And if Mirkov isn't ready for a few years we could even need another ruck.

Not sure if it was Austin's doing but the Bulldogs have been lacking in KPPs for many years and he used to be with them. Hopefully this isn't a blind spot for him...surely not and our coaches would get a say.

 

[F_therest]

We started the season with Weiters, OMac and a very raw Lewis Young

The rest are 3rd y’all’s or utilities

We have a shallow pool of spine players, at least 3 are of the highest quality but depth must be addressed

The question becomes who is gettable?

We addressed run from the backline, competitiveness etc and midfield depth over the last couple of seasons. Who is available for KPP Ruck plug and play?

You'd think it would be the next part of our list we address.

Austin in the last few years has improved our best 22 half back (Saad, Williams), midfield (Cerra, Hewett) and small forwards (Durdin, Motlop for the future).

With getting Young as well he's done a great job.

They were areas we also needed to address. I suppose he can't do everything at once. KPP depth next please.

 

[Magical_EddieBetts]

I have a feeling the tread will continue (Walshy, Harry returning ahead of schedule) and Weiters could be back next week ....

 

[Newton Blues]

Saw a link for Rd 15 and then it disappeared so I googled it. Anyway clicked the link and laughed I saw casboult suspended and gunna miss and thought they must have made a mistake and didn’t put him on the Gold Coast section. Then I saw Marchbank is now out for the season and Plowman 1 week with knee and thought how bad can our backline get! Then saw Charlie curnow

30

Charlie Curnow

Age

27

Ht

194cm

Wt

94kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

13.3

3star

K

9.7

4star

HB

3.6

3star

M

5.3

5star

T

2.2

4star

G

1.3

5star

No current season stats available

D

10.8

3star

K

6.4

3star

HB

4.4

4star

M

3.2

4star

T

1.6

4star

G

0.8

4star

knee!!! And shit myself! To finally realise I had the same date and round as last year!! But thought I’d share to show how similar players injured! Parkes etc

 

[Mr_Plow]

Saw a link for Rd 15 and then it disappeared so I googled it. Anyway clicked the link and laughed I saw casboult suspended and gunna miss and thought they must have made a mistake and didn’t put him on the Gold Coast section. Then I saw Marchbank is now out for the season and Plowman 1 week with knee and thought how bad can our backline get! Then saw Charlie curnow knee!!! And s**t myself! To finally realise I had the same date and round as last year!! But thought I’d share to show how similar players injured! Parkes etcView attachment 1429448View attachment 1429450

Cuningham, McDonald, Marchbank, McGovern and Parks... Some things never change.

 

[Magical_EddieBetts]

 

[LanceRomance]

Saw a link for Rd 15 and then it disappeared so I googled it. Anyway clicked the link and laughed I saw casboult suspended and gunna miss and thought they must have made a mistake and didn’t put him on the Gold Coast section. Then I saw Marchbank is now out for the season and Plowman 1 week with knee and thought how bad can our backline get! Then saw Charlie curnow knee!!! And s**t myself! To finally realise I had the same date and round as last year!! But thought I’d share to show how similar players injured! Parkes etcView attachment 1429448View attachment 1429450

I'd wait for the club one.

 

[AT97]

I have a feeling the tread will continue (Walshy, Harry returning ahead of schedule) and Weiters could be back next week ....

similiar feeling about pittonet.

 

[Benaly28]

Get those two back and everything changes creates a domino effect.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[F_therest]

Am I reading the injury reports wrong...

If Weitering and Pitto are listed as 3 weeks and recover exactly on time, wouldn't they come back for the Geelong game? Aren't the weeks usually number of games?

So for example if a guy is listed as 1 week in the Tuesday injury report, he's not playing that weekend but the next.

Heading into Freo they are 3 weeks. Saints 2 weeks. WC still 1 week. Then available for Geelong?