Bluemour Discussion Thread XI - Facts Not Welcome

Under what circumstances will you be happy to trade for Shiel?


  • Total voters
    399

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Would have agreed last year or the year before. Not now.
Reason? I thought he fell out with the coach but you may know more? He was really handy at freo and was tearing us up in that game in ?2017? before breaking his leg. I thought he'd be handy as a backup option and was getting plenty of it in the magoos but GC wouldn't play him. Thought he would be pretty fired up to prove Dew wrong too and would cost nothing on rookie list.


On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Look at this. Just look at it:

"Suns INs: Pick #1, Casboult, Miles?
Suns OUTs: Lynch, Hall?, Pick #29

Blues INs: Pick #17-19, Pick #29, Pick #36, Hall?, Grigg?
Blues OUTs: Pick #1, Casboult

Tigers INs: Lynch
Tigers OUTs: Pick #17-19, Pick #36, Grigg?, Miles?"

I'm never looking at other clubs trade threads again.

Which board did this come from? I'm assuming Gold Coast, because surely the Richmond folk are planning for Lynch as a free agent, not via trade.

I know the folks up north are new to all this, but why on earth would any of those clubs entertain this deal?

Gold Coast are already getting Pick 3 for Lynch. And they have Pick 2. And we're not gonna take Lukosius. So why not just trade Hall for Casboult and 29 for Miles?

Carlton aren't ever going to consider trading away Pick 1 for a collection of junk, the most valuable of which is Pick 18.

And Richmond don't give up their first and second picks, a best 22 player and a depth player, for a free agent.
 
Oh Shaun Grigg. :drunk:

So wait, isn't this suggesting Pick #1 and Casboult are going to the GC for Hall and Pick #29? And then we are getting Grigg, Pick #17-19 and Pick #36 for nothing? And GC get Miles also for nothing?

We are giving up pick 1 and Casboult (who for some reason is being sent as some sort of salary dump) and getting Pick #17-19, Pick #29, Pick #36, Hall, Grigg.

I reported the post. I'm literally filthy with it for no reason.
 
Look at this. Just look at it:

"Suns INs: Pick #1, Casboult, Miles?
Suns OUTs: Lynch, Hall?, Pick #29

Blues INs: Pick #17-19, Pick #29, Pick #36, Hall?, Grigg?
Blues OUTs: Pick #1, Casboult

Tigers INs: Lynch
Tigers OUTs: Pick #17-19, Pick #36, Grigg?, Miles?"

I'm never looking at other clubs trade threads again.[/QUOTE
What thread did that come from, got to head over there for some laughs.
 
Which board did this come from? I'm assuming Gold Coast, because surely the Richmond folk are planning for Lynch as a free agent, not via trade.

I know the folks up north are new to all this, but why on earth would any of those clubs entertain this deal?

Gold Coast are already getting Pick 3 for Lynch. And they have Pick 2. And we're not gonna take Lukosius. So why not just trade Hall for Casboult and 29 for Miles?

Carlton aren't ever going to consider trading away Pick 1 for a collection of junk, the most valuable of which is Pick 18.

And Richmond don't give up their first and second picks, a best 22 player and a depth player, for a free agent.

GC board. That's why they somehow ended up with Pick 1.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top