Rumour Bluemour Discussion XXXV - 'Loopy' Season has begun

[Benaly28]

If we want to tear the heart out of the fabric of the Carlton football club and trade Harry for Petracca then we haven’t learnt anything in the past 20 years.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Beyond Blue]

If we get Aleer and Rachele I’ll be very happy.

 

[Electric Blue]

If we want to tear the heart out of the fabric of the Carlton football club and trade Harry for Petracca then we haven’t learnt anything in the past 20 years.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

It is NOT going to happen


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[BlueJet]

We aren’t trading Harry McKay.

I feel we've somehow reached the point where Harry is underrated.

 

[BringFevBack2021]

I feel the club should only consider player for player if that club had indicated they wanted a trade or that player was not productive in playing the way we want to play

If H said he wanted a trade I would understand

But if he didn’t I would oppose it

 

[DangerousD]

Leppitsch and Caracalla both reported to be on the move this off season, both have massive amounts of premiership experience as players and coaches.

Yet no articles I’ve read, suggest they are coming to us.

 

[DangerousD]

So clubs are offering players contracts they have no intention of honouring?

I would suggest in some cases, yes, the contract in theory could be totally unreasonable, forcing the player to look elsewhere.

My view is that it’s too risky to do it with Martin, but the club might be just looking for a small pick upgrade or something.

 

[Monty1978]

In a world where the pick is based on talent not future injuries.

Bloke has talent oozing but his body or our club have let him down, more than likely a combination of both.

That world doesn’t exist mate …Martin is barely fit and firing … guy has fleeced the league since being drafted … he is not getting pick 26 which ever way you look at it .26 you truely believe that

 

[Blue By Blood]

Harry won’t be going anywhere. We aren’t that dumb. Only like 10 weeks ago he was rated as statistically best key forward in the game by champion data. I feel like many don’t realise how hard it is to get a decent key forward let alone a gun one. Madness to trade these guys away. Imagine Curnow being triple teamed then.

 

[Monty1978]

I've made my thoughts clear on Elijah.

Let's see if he can stand up tomorrow when needed.

Love your posts mate and your refreshing on this board , suprised you’re not on the EH bandwagon … assume you think he is lazy and chooses when to go ?

 

[BringFevBack2021]

I've made my thoughts clear on Elijah.

Let's see if he can stand up tomorrow when needed.

One of our best this year, cmon DQ

 

[GT619]

much easier to find an elite mid than an elite tall....

this draft has plenty of then

 

[Soapy V]

I would suggest in some cases, yes, the contract in theory could be totally unreasonable, forcing the player to look elsewhere.

My view is that it’s too risky to do it with Martin, but the club might be just looking for a small pick upgrade or something.

I understand that happens. Clubs offer minimum when they are 50/50 on a player and aren’t fussed whether they take it or not BUT to offer a player a contract that they won’t offer isn’t something I’d want to be known for

 

[Soapy V]

One of our best this year, cmon DQ

Where has DQ said different?

 

[GT619]

It is NOT going to happen


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

he's back atomic bomb

 

[BringFevBack2021]

Where has DQ said different?

read thread

 

[Soapy V]

I feel we've somehow reached the point where Harry is underrated.

By the club or supporters?

It’s just on line speculation. Club wouldn’t even be considering trading him

 

[Soapy V]

Agree with this.
He see’s the game on a different level to most players.
Imagine if he totally committed and spent the off season with Cripps taking his fitness to elite levels …

IMO it just time. Coming off an ACL and starting at GCS hasn’t helped. Their development/culture isn’t great

I’m expecting that after another pre season we will see him go to another level in 2025

 

[Soapy V]

read thread

I have. He hasn’t

Happy for you to show me different

 

[Bryce Bubbles]

Was Harry mad at our club for his "concussion" saga a few weeks ago, or was that the media trying sell papers and clicks?

 

[BringFevBack2021]

I have. He hasn’t

just put me back on ignore, deliberately obtuse for no reason whatsoever

 

[Soapy V]

Love your posts mate and your refreshing on this board , suprised you’re not on the EH bandwagon … assume you think he is lazy and chooses when to go ?

TBF where has he said he isn’t a fan.

All DQ has said that he doesn’t go hard all the time and when required. I 100% agree with this. Watch him closely and he at times he can cruise and not work hard enough

I wouldn’t call it lazy. I think it’s bad habits of a young player coming from GCS

When he improves this we will have an absolute gun

 

[myblueroan]

Where has DQ said different?

After someone said O. Hollands is the worst Carlton player they've ever seen.

Elijah is worse.

1. Game Day RND 21 - Carlton v Collingwood Game Day ​

   flipping lazy hand from EH with no effort...
   • Word Count: 8
   • xDQ82x
   • Post #756
   • Aug 3, 2024
   • Forum: Carlton
2. X
   

   Game Day RND 21 - Carlton v Collingwood Game Day ​

   Eh... It's called a handball
   • Word Count: 5
   • xDQ82x
   • Post #658
   • Aug 3, 2024
   • Forum: Carlton

     • Game Day RND 21 - Carlton v Collingwood Game Day ​

       That's EHs goal... Poor
       • Word Count: 4
       • xDQ82x
       • Post #367
       • Aug 3, 2024
       • Forum: Carlton
3. X
   

   Game Day RND 21 - Carlton v Collingwood Game Day ​

   That's cause he never runs
   • Word Count: 5
   • xDQ82x
   • Post #349
   • Aug 3, 2024
   • Forum: Carlton
4. X
   

   Game Day RND 21 - Carlton v Collingwood Game Day ​

   E.hollands doesn't have it
   • Word Count: 5
   • xDQ82x
   • Post #291
   • Aug 3, 2024
   • Forum: Carlton
   Seems more like a vendetta to me and apologies if I'm wrong. But it keeps going. He plays for us. He has a ton of potential and he's shown a lot already.
   Of course he'll improve with another pre season. And a good healthy mental headspace...positive environment in st CFC.
   
   If you can't encourage maybe dial it down. If it's personal, work it out is all I'm saying, cos it seems unfair. Especially when you seem to have inside info. People pay attention to what you say.

 

[Soapy V]

just put me back on ignore, deliberately obtuse for no reason whatsoever

Just asking for evidence that’s all. Tired of people accusing others without proof or to suit an agenda

 

[BringFevBack2021]

Just asking for evidence that’s all. Tired of people accusing others without proof or to suit an agenda

Soapy, there’s no agenda - take the tin foil hat off

He said we’d never won a trade
A poster said Acres and Lij were steals
DQ said he had made his thoughts on Lij clear

Which implies he thinks Lij wasn’t a steal, if he thinks otherwise he can reply to my very playful, harmless response and tell me otherwise

It’s not that deep man, just chill dude