Gone Critical
Moderator
- Moderator
- #26
Chewy this does nothing for your credibility or to clear you of the perception of a wacking Hawthorn bias
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Bryce Gibbs v Cyril Rioli
- Thread starter Hodgepodge
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Chewy this does nothing for your credibility or to clear you of the perception of a wacking Hawthorn bias
Gibbs thanks.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #29
Junior Boy looks like a jet though - if he keeps improving look out
To be honest, i don't see any more improvement out of Rioli, skills-wise. But his endurance at least will improve, and that should mean fewer skill errors.
I assume u have no idea about football it is the only logical explianation for this above commentary
- Banned
- #32
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N3tr8wrWA0s
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mL7ZMJWgTCc
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7jKwoxuYD9w
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGa7eBRyxqk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o_HBB7VQ9Zk
Gibbs>>>>>Rioli.
Gibbs is just four months older than Rioli and younger than Rhys Palmer, so I know who will be the better player.
Judd went alright...
magpie10
Team Captain
Jeez i feel sorry for all those unbiased hawthorn supporters, kids like this must annoy you.
Firstly, cyril is a gun and will be a very good player, but i don't think had as good a year as judd's first year. Don't forget, cyril played some shockers and was close to getting rested at one stage early on.
Secondly, to those biased hawthorn supporters, just because he played the best 10 possession GF doesn't mean he is a world beater. Someone recently compared him to judd aswell
BTW, bryce gibbs will be a champion, just look at the way he tore up goodes mid-season.
Firstly, cyril is a gun and will be a very good player, but i don't think had as good a year as judd's first year. Don't forget, cyril played some shockers and was close to getting rested at one stage early on.
Secondly, to those biased hawthorn supporters, just because he played the best 10 possession GF doesn't mean he is a world beater. Someone recently compared him to judd aswell
BTW, bryce gibbs will be a champion, just look at the way he tore up goodes mid-season.
Cyril is one of the first picked in the Hawthorn premiership side week in week out..
Gibbs is one of the last picked in a bottom 4 side..
end thread
Gibbs is one of the last picked in a bottom 4 side..
end thread
- Banned
- #36
a) Instead of quoting my whole post and having a go at me like that, why don't you edit the quote to show the relevant part? At least then, I'll instantly know what you're referring to.
b) I wasn't calling Joel Selwood a pansy. He is as brave as they come. I wasn't calling anyone a pansy. I just hate it when footballers try to milk free kicks as though they were South American soccer players. It always used to be the old footballers who staged for frees. Nowadays we see the gun 1st and 2nd year players do it. Such a shame... It's a blight on the game and it has nothing to do with any club bias.
c) I don't give a shit whether you think I'm biased or not. I enjoy posting my drivel and reading other people's drivel. Hopefully someone else enjoys reading my drivel. One thing I don't particularly enjoy reading on here are comments from the peanut gallery... people who think they are critics or something and talk about other people's posts instead of football.
d) show me an unbiased football fan and I'll show you someone who isn't really a football fan
Not in the one game. He hasn't got close to it.
Surely he doesn't mean across different games as many players perform that and are far from special. Chad Fletcher even did it 3 times this season
- Sep 26, 2004
- 47,850
- 64,826
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #38
Gibbs doesn't play for West Coast, Fremantle, Port or Melbourne so I think you are a little confused.
Or surely you weren't suggesting that Gibbs is one of the last picked in the Carlton side?
Either way, you are wrong. But hey, thanks for providing us with a few laughs!
Reptilia
Club Legend
spot on!
Of course you're biased just like we all are. At least you comments are generally backed up & if disputed intelligently you can see peoples points. Thats what the main board should be for & I think you do well.
I thought the OP was the only Hawks supporter who would be ignorant enough to make such a stupid post ..and then along comes this Einstein, these kids must really embarrass the sensible Hawks supporters .
FWI worth Rioli has been a sensation in the Hawks forward line a real excitement machine ..he should be giving the Hawks supporters enjoyment for many a year .
As for Gibbs ..the kid will be an absolute gun of the competition .
Found this intersting. Gibbs is only 4 months older than Rioli.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #43
I really don't understand how one baulk is justification for an entire youtube video . . . lots of players do those.
Judd wasn't at your club. You can't brag about him
Yeah, why those 2 players? Why not Mitch Thorp v Shaun Grigg? Or James Hird v Leeter Collier? Idiotic
Obviously didn't watch many Carlton games in 2008. Sydney game, Port game etc. he applied very hard tags but was able to find a lot of the pill and use it magnificently. He usually doesn't kick goals while tagging though.
Cyril will improve enormously. It's no secret Clarko wants him in the middle soon enough.
To anyone who thinks Gibbs is soft, watch from 1:50 onwards: http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=o_HBB7VQ9Zk
Obviously you can't read as he said someone that can apply a hard tag, get 30 touches and kick 3 goals.
Gibbs has never achieved that.
If he meant across different games then it's hardly a sign of 'something special' since many achieve it including the ultra talented Chad Fletcher
