- Mar 1, 2005
- 7,751
- 15,736
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- carlton
I wouldn t worry. He had the same passionate views about Cripps. Too slow , will never make it.
List Mgmt. Carlton's 2018 Draft Thread (cont. in Part 2)
- Thread starter HalAlaric
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I wouldn t worry. He had the same passionate views about Cripps. Too slow , will never make it.
I'm not
I'm trying to balance the list
Harry might turn out ok
but he doesn't have forever
and after next year he's going to be worth not much
we need midfielders
and if you want to pick up Ben and we have pick 1 for the big L
you'll find it harder and harder
actually I said he will be injury prone because of his size and role
plus those type take longer
he's already playing injured
- Mar 1, 2005
- 7,751
- 15,736
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- carlton
I call BS . Thats being dogmatic
- Mar 1, 2005
- 7,751
- 15,736
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- carlton
Nah you said he was too slow.
actually I said will be injury prone but you can win if you're determined to win
I don't care!
lol
- Mar 1, 2005
- 7,751
- 15,736
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- carlton
LOL I dont have to win. I just like pompous windbags like yourself to be accountable for your posts. You want to run away from what you have said in the past, change your name...Whatever!
Last edited by a moderator:
If we must 'balance the list', I'd be putting the likes of 'not enough love for...', Kerr and De Koning on notice first (unless the latter is being groomed as a ruckman) because at their best, they offer less than Mckay. You never trade from the top down unless you are desperate and you already know the limitations of what you are trading out. I reckon Brissy had Schache sussed and he was sending out mixed messages. I think injury and lack of opportunity suggest that McKay may still have a lot of development left in him and we really don't know what we'd risk giving up.
- Nov 27, 2016
- 18,639
- 36,306
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Metalcrusher
A God Amongst The People
- Banned
- #2,410
No way H-Mac is going anywhere. Anyone remember a certain J Kennedy …….
https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pc-west-coast-eagles--joshua-kennedy
Have a good look at the start of his career to when he took off …….
Very subjective view THS … HMac has played 6 AFL games for 12 goals! That's not a bad return for 6 games of footy. Extrapolating out that's 46 goals a season ……
Saying he is not going to be worth much after next year is so visionary futuristic you should go into predicting the Interest rate Prime markets.
Yes we need midfielders … no argument there.
Lukosious is like a Forward version of Crippa …. he will fit in without restricting anything. He has been constantly playing the midfield to forward line area as both a roaming mid and stay at home forward. His running is elite and can both beat the small lock down defender … which he out marks or completely blown up the KPD because they cant keep up.
Ben will not cost much IF he gets drafted (which he probably will)
https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pc-west-coast-eagles--joshua-kennedy
Have a good look at the start of his career to when he took off …….
Very subjective view THS … HMac has played 6 AFL games for 12 goals! That's not a bad return for 6 games of footy. Extrapolating out that's 46 goals a season ……
Saying he is not going to be worth much after next year is so visionary futuristic you should go into predicting the Interest rate Prime markets.
Yes we need midfielders … no argument there.
Lukosious is like a Forward version of Crippa …. he will fit in without restricting anything. He has been constantly playing the midfield to forward line area as both a roaming mid and stay at home forward. His running is elite and can both beat the small lock down defender … which he out marks or completely blown up the KPD because they cant keep up.
Ben will not cost much IF he gets drafted (which he probably will)
Collier-Dawkins and Rowbottom getting plenty of the ball.
Ben King sounds as though he's doing quite well, also.
Can only wonder how our Ben is doing.
I missed the first half. I thought West was very impressive in the 3rd.
Bit of trivia for everyone. What did Harry achieve in his first 8 games that the players below could not?
Ablett
Carey
Dunstall
Modra
Lockett
Brown
the Riewoldts
Tredrea
Fevola
Lloyd
Franklin
Kennedy
bluedabadee
Team Captain
Short back and sides?
Not quite
Blubagger71
Club Legend
- Aug 30, 2014
- 1,530
- 2,094
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Goal in each game?
Correct. I'm wondering what the record (most consecutive games) from debut is.
- Oct 10, 2016
- 3,112
- 7,468
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Are we tanking next yr already to get him
What do people think of Sharp for W.A.?
He's an under-ager, but what a little jet, he is.
Very eye-catching. a Brownlow beckons.
I know I've already sung this kid's praises, but Chayce Jones played another cracker today. Can find the ball on the inside or the outside, spreads from the contest, runs both ways, excellent pace and acceleration, plenty of runs down tackles, good in the air and off the deck, terrific disposal and kicks goals. Oozes leadership and class.
He's not the biggest kid at 180cm, but can certainly keep his body over the ball when working inside the contest. One of the things I like most about Jones is his consistency of performance from match to match and his ability to bring his team mates into the game. While Jones doesn't find quite as much of the ball Walsh, his defensive efforts, ability to run both ways and his impact per possession make up for it.
Is he is good as Connor Rozee??? At this stage, based upon his output, work-rate and impact I'd have to yes.....but the Nationals have only just started. Can he make Top 10??? Dunno.....but like Tom Sparrow from SA, Chayce Jones is certainly one to follow through the U18 National Carnival.
He's not the biggest kid at 180cm, but can certainly keep his body over the ball when working inside the contest. One of the things I like most about Jones is his consistency of performance from match to match and his ability to bring his team mates into the game. While Jones doesn't find quite as much of the ball Walsh, his defensive efforts, ability to run both ways and his impact per possession make up for it.
Is he is good as Connor Rozee??? At this stage, based upon his output, work-rate and impact I'd have to yes.....but the Nationals have only just started. Can he make Top 10??? Dunno.....but like Tom Sparrow from SA, Chayce Jones is certainly one to follow through the U18 National Carnival.
Tom Sparrow for me, but think he will now be gone, before our 2nd rounder pick.
15-20 tange looking likely
- Aug 22, 2014
- 14,017
- 51,135
- AFL Club
- Carlton
People writing H off lol
He's 20/11. That's baby years for a 200cm player.
My God. So funny.
And he has an attitude?? No harm in that. All the good KPFs had a healthy ego.
Seriously some of you need to get a life!!
He's 20/11. That's baby years for a 200cm player.
My God. So funny.
And he has an attitude?? No harm in that. All the good KPFs had a healthy ego.
Seriously some of you need to get a life!!
- Status
Similar threads
